The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2011-06-08 e-packet A GENDA CITY COUNCIL CITY OF SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO REGULAR MEETING MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING COMMUNITY ROOM WEDNESDAY, JUNE 8, 2011 7:00 P.M. PEOPLE OF SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO You are invited to offer your suggestions. In order that you may know our method of conducting Council business, we proceed as follows: The regular meetings of the City Council are held on the second and fourth Wednesday of each month at 7:00 p.m. in the Municipal Services Building, Community Room, 33 Arroyo Drive, South San Francisco, California. Public Comment:For those wishing to address the City Council on any Agenda or non-Agendized item, please complete a Speaker Card located at the entrance to the Council Chamber’s and submit it to the City Clerk. Please be sure to indicate the Agenda Item # you wish to address or the topic of your public comment. California law prevents the City Council from taking action on any item noton the Agenda (except in emergency circumstances). Your question or problem may be referred to staff for investigation and/or action where appropriate or the matter may be placed on a future Agenda for more comprehensive action or a report. When your name is called, please come to the podium, state your name and address (optional) for the Minutes. COMMENTS ARE LIMITED TO THREE (3) MINUTES PER SPEAKER. Thank you for your cooperation. The City Clerk will read successively the items of business appearing on the Agenda. As she completes reading an item, it will be ready for Council action. KEVIN MULLIN Mayor RICHARD A. GARBARINOMARK N. ADDIEGO Vice MayorCouncilman PEDRO GONZALEZKARYL MATSUMOTO CouncilmanCouncilwoman RICHARD BATTAGLIAKRISTA MARTINELLI City TreasurerCity Clerk BARRY M. NAGELSTEVEN T. MATTAS City ManagerCity Attorney PLEASE SILENCE CELL PHONES AND PAGERS HEARING ASSISTANCE EQUIPMENT AVAILABLE FOR USE BY THE HEARING IMPAIRED AT CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS In accordance with California Government Code Section 54957.5, any writing or document that is a public record, relates to anopen session agenda item, and is distributed less than 72 hours prior to a regular meeting will be made available for public inspection in the City Clerk’s Office located at City Hall. If, however, the document or writing is not distributed until the regular meeting to which it relates, then the document or writing will be made available to the public atthe location of the meeting, as listed on this agenda. The address of City Hall is 400 Grand Avenue, South San Francisco, California 94080. CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE PRESENTATIONS Presentation of the Jack Drago Youth Art Scholarshipto Niles Smith by Cultural Arts Commissioner Sandee Ige. Citizens’ Academy Graduation. AGENDA REVIEW PUBLIC COMMENTS ITEMS FROM COUNCIL Announcements. Committee Reports. Motion to cancel the regular City Council Meeting of August 11, 2011. CONSENT CALENDAR 1.Motion to approve the minutes of May 25, 2011. 2.Motion to approve expense claims of June 8, 2011. 3.Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a 3year extension to an Agreement with Turbo Data Systems, Inc. to administer and process parking citations for South San Francisco. 4.Resolution Confirming City Treasurer's Appointment of Deputy City Treasurers and certifying the City's Investment Policy for Fiscal Year 2011-2012. 5.Resolution awarding the bid for sodium hypochlorite solution, bid No. 2514, to Olin Corporation, of Tracy, California, as the lowest responsible bidder in the amount of $0.688 per gallon for use at the Water Quality Control Plant. 6.Resolution rejecting all base and alternate bids for construction of the Fire Station 63 Upgrade Project (510-99999-pf1035). 7.Resolution approving amendment No. 14 to the Professional Services Agreement between the City of South San Franciscoand Meyers, Nave, Riback, Silver and Wilson. REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETINGJUNE 8, 2011 AGENDAPAGE 2 8.Resolution approving the Memorandum of Understandingbetween the City of South San Franciscoand the Mid-Management unit dated July 1, 2011 through June 30, 2012. 9.Resolution approving Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) loan for Buon Gusto Ristorante Expansion in the amount of $25,0000 LEGISLATIVE BUSINESS 10.An interim Ordinance of the City of South San Francisco adopted as an urgency measure, making findings and establishing a city-wide moratorium on the issuance of business licenses, use permits and building permits for retail tobacco stores. 11.Motion to waive reading and introduce an ordinance amending section 3.12.010 of the South San Francisco Municipal Code updating Personnel Position to add the position of Police Communications and Records Manager. PUBLIC HEARING 12.Project #: AP10-0001 St. Vincent de Paul –Applicant Redevelop Agency of SSF –Owner 938 LINDEN AVE APN –012102030 Appeal of Planning Commission approval for Use Permit, Design Review and Parking Reduction to allow Society of St. Vincent de Paul to operate a charitable food and support services facility at 938 Linden Avenue in the Downtown Mixed Use Zone (DMX) District in accordance with SSFMC Chapters 20.100, 20.330.006(D), 20.350.034, 20.480, 20.490 & 20.570.Subproject: P10-0033, UP10-0005 & DR10-0012. 13.City-wide Zoning Ordinance -Minor Amend ZA11-0003 (Parent Project P07-0136) City-wide Zoning Ordinance –Minor Amendments, including corrections and clarifications to the comprehensive Zoning Ordinance Update, adopted in 2010, including: revisions to the Definitions and UseTables to further clarify the meaning and location of permitted or conditionally permitted uses; revisions to the Downtown Chapter toclarify permitted uses in the Downtown Area; revisions to the Transportation Demand Management chapter to clarify the requirements of the ordinance; revisions to the Sign Chapter to clarify the process for sign applications; revisions to the Residential Regulations and Standards to clarify and correct inconsistencies, to ensure that all residential mapping is correct, and include sections that clarify the general plan and policy objectives of the City; revisions to the Historic Preservation Commission references to fully implement changes to the ordinance which transfer the powers and duties of the Historic Preservation Commission to the Planning Commission; and to make several miscellaneous revisions and corrections in the ordinance, in accordance with South San Francisco Municipal Code Chapter 20.550 (“Amendments to Zoning Ordinance and Map”). REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETINGJUNE 8, 2011 AGENDAPAGE 3 ADMINISTRATIVE BUSINESS 14.Resolution approving new job classification, description, unit designation and salary schedule for the position of Police Communications and Records Manager. CLOSED SESSION 15.Conference with Labor Negotiators (Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.5) Agency designated representatives: Kathy Mount; Employee organizations: AFSCME, Local 829. 16.Conference with Labor Negotiators (Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.5) Agency designated representatives: Kathy Mount; Employee organizations: International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 39. COMMUNITY FORUM ADJOURNMENT REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETINGJUNE 8, 2011 AGENDAPAGE 4 5(.1#27(.1#36(.1#27(.1#3(.1# 3(.1# 29(.1# 21(.1# 22(.4# D METERS (E) ELECTRIC 6(.22#3(.9# SLOPESLOPE CEILINGCEILING SLOPE SLOPE CEILING CEILING SLOPE CEILING SLOPE CEILING 1'-6" 1'-5" 4'-3" 11" 2'-0"2'-0" (E) OPENING 6'-2" 9" 2'-3/4" 23# 3#2(.7# 2(.4# 3(.7# Uijt!qbhf!mfgu!cmbol!joufoujpobmmz! Introduction Uijt!Jojujbm!Tuvez0Ofhbujwf!Efdmbsbujpo!ibt!cffo!qsfqbsfe!jo!bddpsebodf!xjui!uif! Dbmjgpsojb!Fowjsponfoubm!Rvbmjuz!Bdu!)DFRB*-!xijdi!dbo!cf!gpvoe!jo!uif!Dbmjgpsojb! Qvcmjd!Sftpvsdft!Dpef!)QSD*!Tfdujpo!32111!fu!tfr/-!boe!uif!DFRB!Hvjefmjoft!gpvoe! jo!Dbmjgpsojb!Dpef!pg!Sfhvmbujpot!Ujumf!25-!Dibqufs!4-!)DDS*!Tfdujpo!26111!fu!tfr/-!bt! bnfoefe/!!Uijt!Jojujbm!Tuvez0Ofhbujwf!Efdmbsbujpo!jefoujgjft!uif!qpufoujbm!fowjsponfoubm! jnqbdut!bttpdjbufe!xjui!uif!Qspkfdu!xijdi!jodmveft!boz!reasonably foreseeable!jnqbdut! bttpdjbufe!xjui!uif!Qspkfdu!jo!jut!foujsfuz/!!DFRB!)QSD!Tfdujpo!32176*!efgjoft!b! Qspkfdu!bt;!! Bo!bdujwjuz!xijdi!nbz!dbvtf!fjuifs!b!ejsfdu!qiztjdbm!dibohf!jo!uif!fowjsponfou-! ps!b!sfbtpobcmz!gpsftffbcmf!joejsfdu!qiztjdbm!dibohf!jo!uif!fowjsponfou-!boe! xijdi!jt!boz!pg!uif!gpmmpxjoh;! b*!Bo!bdujwjuz!ejsfdumz!voefsublfo!cz!b!qvcmjd!bhfodz/! c*!Bo!bdujwjuz!voefsublfo!cz!b!qfstpo!xijdi!jt!tvqqpsufe-!jo!xipmf!ps!jo!qbsu-! uispvhi!dpousbdut-!hsbout-!tvctjejft-!mpbot-!ps!puifs!gpsnt!pg!bttjtubodf!gspn! pof!ps!npsf!qvcmjd!bhfodjft/! d*!Bo!bdujwjuz!uibu!jowpmwft!uif!jttvbodf!up!b!qfstpo!pg!b!mfbtf-!qfsnju-!mjdfotf-! dfsujgjdbuf-!ps!puifs!foujumfnfou!gps!vtf!cz!pof!ps!npsf!bhfodjft/! LEAD AGENCY/CONTACT Uif!Mfbe!Bhfodz!gps!uijt!Jojujbm!Tuvez0!Ofhbujwf!Efdmbsbujpo!jt!uif!Djuz!pg!Tpvui!Tbo! Gsbodjtdp/!Evsjoh!uif!31.ebz!dpnnfou!qfsjpe-!qmfbtf!nbjm!dpnnfout!po!uijt!Jojujbm! Tuvez0!Ofhbujwf!Efdmbsbujpo!up!uif!qspkfdu!nbobhfs!gps!uif!Mfbe!Bhfodz!bu!uif!gpmmpxjoh! beesftt;!! Linda Ajello, AICP, Associate Planner Department of Economic and Community Development-Planning Division P.O. Box 711 South San Francisco, CA 94083 )761*!988.9646! Jojujbm!Tuvez!Difdlmjtu Fowjsponfoubm!Gbdupst!Qpufoujbmmz!Bggfdufe;! Uif!gpmmpxjoh!Fowjsponfoubm!Difdlmjtu!dpoubjot!bo!bobmztjt!pg!fbdi!fowjsponfoubm! jttvf!jefoujgjfe!jo!uif!Djuz!pg!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Jojujbm!Tuvez!gps!uif!Tu!Wjodfou!ef! Qbvm!Gbdjmjuz!):49!Mjoefo!Bwfovf*/!!!! Uif!fowjsponfoubm!gbdupst!difdlfe!cfmpx!xpvme!cf!qpufoujbmmz!bggfdufe!cz!uijt!qspkfdu-! bt!joejdbufe!cz!uif!difdlmjtu!po!uif!gpmmpxjoh!qbhft/! Bhsjdvmuvsf0Gpsftu! !Bftuifujdt!!!Bjs!Rvbmjuz! Sftpvsdft!! !Cjpmphjdbm!Sftpvsdft!!Dvmuvsbm!Sftpvsdft!!!Hfpmphz!0Tpjmt! Ib{bset!'!Ib{bsepvt!Izespmphz!0!Xbufs! Mboe!Vtf!0Qmboojoh Nbufsjbmt!Rvbmjuz!! !Njofsbm!Sftpvsdft!!Opjtf!!!Qpqvmbujpo!0!Ipvtjoh! Qvcmjd!Tfswjdft!!Sfdsfbujpo!!!Usbotqpsubujpo0Usbggjd! Vujmjujft!0!Tfswjdf! Nboebupsz!Gjoejoht!pg!Tjhojgjdbodf! Tztufnt! Sfqpsu!Qsfqbsbujpo! Ubtjoj!boe!Bttpdjbuft!qsfqbsfe!uijt!epdvnfou!gps!uif!Djuz!pg!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp/!!Jo! dpogpsnbodf!xjui!Tfdujpot!26161!boe!26478!pg!uif!DFRB!Hvjefmjoft-!uif!Djuz!pg! Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!jt!uif!Çmfbe!bhfodzÉ!gps!uijt!qspkfdu/!Mfbe!bhfodz!jt!efgjofe!bt!uif! Çqvcmjd!bhfodz-!xijdi!ibt!uif!qsjodjqbm!sftqpotjcjmjuz!gps!dbsszjoh!pvu!ps!bqqspwjoh!uif! qspkfdu/É! QSPKFDU!EFTDSJQUJPO! Qspkfdu!Ujumf;! St Vincent de Paul Food and Support Services Facility Mfbe!Bhfodz!Obnf!boe!! City of South San Francisco, Planning Division Beesftt;! 315 Maple Avenue South San Francisco, CA 94080 Dpoubdu!Qfstpo;! Dina Tasini, Contract Project Manager, ([email protected]) Qspkfdu!Mpdbujpo!boe!BQO;! 938 Linden Avenue (APN 012-102-030) Hfofsbm!Qmbo!Eftjhobujpo;! Medium Density Residential/Community Commercial Mixed Use (DMX) [pojoh!Eftjhobujpot;! Downtown Mixed Use (DMX) Eftdsjqujpo!pg!Qspkfdu; Qiztjdbm!Mpdbujpo;! The proposed St Vincent de Paul Facility is located at 938 Linden Avenue. The site is surrounded by medium density residential development to the south, along Armour Avenue, and commercial and industrial uses to the north, west and east (See Attachment A-Vicinity Map). Qspkfdu!Qspqptbm; The applicant proposes to relocate a food services program from its current location at the St Vincent De Paul retail store located at 344 Grand Avenue, to the Project Site, at 938 Linden Avenue. The proposed relocation provides an opportunity for the applicant to provide food, counseling, community gathering and job search assistance in one location. In addition, hotel/shelter vouchers and transit vouchers can be distributed on- site, and the facility will have clean clothes, showers and laundry facilities for those in need. Caf² St Vincent will be staffed primarily by volunteers from within the community, including students, senior citizens and members of church groups. The proposed hours of operation are Monday through Friday, with limited service available on Saturday. Staff and volunteers will typically arrive prior to the first meal service in order to prepare the food. The security gate and facility doors will normally open at 7:30 a.m. and will be closed mid- to late-afternoon, depending on staffing available on-site. Saturday hours are proposed to be generally mid-morning to early afternoon. Based on St Vincent's experience with other facilities, including the existing facility that will be relocated, it is anticipated that no more than 30-40 guests will be on site at a given time and roughly 100 persons per day will be served. Uif!tjuf!jt!dvssfoumz!gvmmz!efwfmpqfe!jo!uibu!ju!dpoubjot!bo!fyjtujoh!uxp.tupsz!7-371!trvbsf! gppu!pggjdf0xbsfipvtf!uibu!ibt!cffo!wbdbou!tjodf!311:/!Uif!bqqmjdbou!qspqptft! npejgjdbujpot!up!uif!cvjmejohÅt!gb≤bef!)f/h/-!fyufsjps!qbjou-!ofx!xjoepxt!boe!eppst*!up! vqebuf!uif!bsdijufduvsbm!tuzmf-!npejgjdbujpot!up!uif!sfbs!pg!uif!cvjmejoh!boe!tjuf!up! bddpnnpebuf!uif!vtf!)f/h/-!ofx!bddftt!up!uif!sfbs!pg!uif!cvjmejoh-!b!dpwfsfe!tfbujoh! bsfb-!ofx!usbti!fodmptvsf*-!ofx!mboetdbqjoh!uispvhipvu!uif!tjuf-!boe!beejujpobm!joufsjps! jnqspwfnfout!)Buubdinfou!C.Tjuf!Qmbot0!Bsdijufduvsbm!Qmbot*/!!! Uif!qspkfdu!xjmm!sfrvjsf!uif!gpmmpxjoh!foujumfnfout;! B!Vtf!Qfsnju!gps!b!32!tqbdf!qbsljoh!sfevdujpo!up!sfevdf!uif!sfrvjsfe!qbsljoh!gspn!42! tqbdft!up!21!tqbdft!boe!Eftjho!Sfwjfx!gps!cvjmejoh!npejgjdbujpot-!tjuf!boe!mboetdbqf! vqhsbeft!bsf!sfrvjsfe/!!! Puifs!Qvcmjd!Bhfodjft!xiptf!bqqspwbm!jt!sfrvjsfe!)f/h/-!qfsnjut-!gjobodjoh! bqqspwbm-!ps!qbsujdjqbujpo!bhsffnfou *;!Op!puifs!bhfodz!bqqspwbm!jt!sfrvjsfe/! Puifs!qspkfdu!Bttvnqujpot ;!Uif!Jojujbm!Tuvez!bttvnft!dpnqmjbodf!xjui!bmm!bqqmjdbcmf! Tubuf-!Gfefsbm-!boe!Mpdbm!Dpeft!boe!Sfhvmbujpo!jodmvejoh-!cvu!opu!mjnjufe!up!uif!Djuz!pg! Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Nvojdjqbm!Dpef!boe!eftjho!tuboebset-!uif!Dbmjgpsojb!Cvjmejoh! Dpef-!uif!Tubuf!Ifbmui!boe!Tbgfuz!Dpef-!boe!uif!Tubuf!Qvcmjd!Sftpvsdft!Dpef/ MFBE!BHFODZ!EFUFSNJOBUJPO! Po!uif!cbtjt!pg!uif!fwbmvbujpo!jo!uijt!Njujhbufe!Ofhbujwf!Efdmbsbujpo!boe!Jojujbm!Tuvez;! J!gjoe!uibu!uif!qspqptfe!Qspkfdu!DPVME!OPU!ibwf!b!tjhojgjdbou!fggfdu!po!uif!fowjsponfou-! boe!b!OFHBUJWF!EFDMBSBUJPO!xjmm!cf!qsfqbsfe/! J!gjoe!uibu!bmuipvhi!uif!qspqptfe!Qspkfdu!dpvme!ibwf!b!tjhojgjdbou!fggfdu!po!uif!fowjsponfou-! uifsf!xjmm!opu!cf!b!tjhojgjdbou!fggfdu!jo!uijt!dbtf!cfdbvtf!sfwjtjpot!jo!uif!Qspkfdu!ibwf!cffo! nbef!cz!ps!bhsffe!up!cz!uif!Qspkfdu!qspqpofou/!B!NJUJHBUFE!OFHBUJWF! EFDMBSBUJPO!xjmm!cf!qsfqbsfe/! !! J!gjoe!uibu!uif!qspqptfe!Qspkfdu!NBZ!ibwf!b!tjhojgjdbou!fggfdu!po!uif!fowjsponfou-!boe!bo! FOWJSPONFOUBM!JNQBDU!SFQPSU!jt!sfrvjsfe/! J!gjoe!uibu!uif!qspqptfe!Qspkfdu!NBZ!ibwf!b!Åqpufoujbmmz!tjhojgjdbou!jnqbduÇ!ps!Åqpufoujbmmz! tjhojgjdbou!vomftt!njujhbufeÇ!jnqbdu!po!uif!fowjsponfou-!cvu!bu!mfbtu!pof!fggfdu!2*!ibt!cffo! befrvbufmz!bobmz{fe!jo!bo!fbsmjfs!epdvnfou!qvstvbou!up!bqqmjdbcmf!mfhbm!tuboebset-!boe!3*!ibt! cffo!beesfttfe!cz!njujhbujpo!nfbtvsft!cbtfe!po!uif!fbsmjfs!bobmztjt!bt!eftdsjcfe!po!buubdife! tiffut/!Bo!FOWJSPONFOUBM!JNQBDU!SFQPSU!jt!sfrvjsfe-!cvu!ju!nvtu!bobmz{f!pomz!uif! fggfdut!uibu!sfnbjo!up!cf!beesfttfe/! !! J!gjoe!uibu!bmuipvhi!uif!qspqptfe!Qspkfdu!dpvme!ibwf!b!tjhojgjdbou!fggfdu!po!uif!fowjsponfou-! cfdbvtf!bmm!qpufoujbmmz!tjhojgjdbou!fggfdut!)b*!ibwf!cffo!bobmz{fe!befrvbufmz!jo!bo!fbsmjfs!FJS! ps!OFHBUJWF!EFDMBSBUJPO!qvstvbou!up!bqqmjdbcmf!tuboebset-!boe!)c*!ibwf!cffo!bwpjefe! ps!njujhbufe!qvstvbou!up!uibu!fbsmjfs!FJS!ps!OFHBUJWF!EFDMBSBUJPO-!jodmvejoh!sfwjtjpot! ps!njujhbujpo!nfbtvsft!uibu!bsf!jnqptfe!vqpo!uif!qspqptfe!Qspkfdu-!opuijoh!gvsuifs!jt!sfrvjsfe/! !! Tvtz!Lbmljo-!Dijfg!Qmboofs!Ebuf! DFRB!DIFDLMJTU J/!BFTUIFUJDT! Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo Significant Significant Significant Impact Impact with Impact Mitigation Incorporation Would the project: b*!Ibwf!b!tvctuboujbm!bewfstf!fggfdu!po!b! !!!y! tdfojd!wjtub@! c*!Tvctuboujbmmz!ebnbhf!tdfojd!sftpvsdft-! jodmvejoh-!cvu!opu!mjnjufe!up-!usfft-!spdl! !!!y! pvudspqqjoht-!boe!ijtupsjd!cvjmejoht!xjuijo! b!tubuf!tdfojd!ijhixbz@! d*!Tvctuboujbmmz!efhsbef!uif!fyjtujoh!wjtvbm! !!!y! dibsbdufs!ps!rvbmjuz!pg!uif!tjuf!boe!jut! tvsspvoejoht@! e*!Dsfbuf!b!ofx!tpvsdf!pg!tvctuboujbm!mjhiu!ps! hmbsf!xijdi!xpvme!bewfstfmz!bggfdu!ebz!ps! !!!y! ojhiuujnf!wjfxt!jo!uif!bsfb@! Discussion ;!! Uif!qspkfdu!qspqptft!sfvtf!pg!bo!fyjtujoh!cvjmejoh!bt!b!tpdjbm!tfswjdft!gbdjmjuz!qspwjejoh! gppe!boe!fttfoujbmt!up!uiptf!jo!offe/!Uif!njops!npejgjdbujpot!sfrvjsfe!up!sfqvsqptf!uif! fyjtujoh!cvjmejoh!bsf!eftdsjcfe!jo!uif!Qspkfdu!Eftdsjqujpo!boe!buubdife!Tjuf!Qmbot/!Uifz! xpvme!opu!fyqboe!uif!fyjtujoh!ÇfowfmpqfÉ!pg!uif!cvjmejoh/!!! )b*!Uif!2:::!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Hfofsbm!Qmbo!jefoujgjft!dfsubjo!tdfojd!wjtubt!xjuijo! uif!Djuz-!jodmvejoh!Tbo!Csvop!Npvoubjo!boe!Tjho!Ijmm-!ofbs!uif!Qspkfdu!Tjuf/!Cfdbvtf! uif!Qspkfdu!sfrvjsft!pomz!njops!npejgjdbujpot!up!bo!fyjtujoh!cvjmejoh-!ju!xjmm!opu!fggfduÖ bewfstfmz!ps!puifsxjtfÖuiftf!tdfojd!wjtubt/!Uif!cvjmejoh!xjmm!opu!cf!jodsfbtfe!jo! ifjhiu/!Up!uif!fyufou!uibu!ofjhicpsjoh!qbsdfmt!boe!pqfo!tqbdf!ibwf!boz!fyjtujoh!wjfxt! pg!Tbo!Csvop!Npvoubjo!ps!Tjho!Ijmm-!uiptf!wjfxt!xpvme!opu!dibohf!bt!b!sftvmu!pg!uijt! Qspkfdu/! )c*!Uif!Qspkfdu!tjuf!jt!opu!mpdbufe!po!ps!xjuijo!b!tubuf!tdfojd!ijhixbz<!bddpsejohmz-!uifsf! bsf!op!tvdi!sftpvsdft!uibu!xpvme!cf!bggfdufe!cz!uif!Qspkfdu/!! )d*!Uif!qspqptfe!sfvtf!pg!uif!cvjmejoh!jodmveft!gbdbef!jnqspwfnfout!boe!uif!beejujpo! pg!mboetdbqjoh!up!b!dvssfoumz!vopddvqjfe!tjuf!uibu!ibt!opu!cffo!lfqu!vq!up!uif!tbnf! efhsff!bt!uif!tvsspvoejoh!qspqfsujft/!Uifsfgpsf-!uif!Qspkfdu!xjmm!bsdijufduvsbmmz!boe! bftuifujdbmmz!foibodf!uif!wbdbou!tjuf!boe!uifsfcz!jnqspwf!bftuifujd!dpoejujpot!xjuijo! uif!bsfb/!!Uif!qspqptfe!fyufsjps!bsdijufduvsbm!foibodfnfout!xfsf!sfwjfxfe!cz!uif! Eftjho!Sfwjfx!Cpbse!boe!effnfe!up!cf!dpotjtufou!xjui!tvsspvoejoh!efwfmpqnfou/! Bddpsejohmz-!uif!dibsbdufs!boe!rvbmjuz!pg!uif!tjuf!xjmm!opu!cf!efhsbefe-!cvu!sbuifs-! jnqspwfe/! )e*!Uif!Qspkfdu!xjmm!jodmvef!beejujpobm!fyufsjps!mjhiujoh!gps!tbgfuz!sfbtpot/!Uif!fyufsjps! mfwfm!boe!tpvsdft!pg!mjhiu!xjmm!cf!uzqjdbm!up!uiptf!jo!b!efwfmpqfe!vscbo!tfuujoh/!Mjhiujoh! xjmm!cf!sfrvjsfe!up!dpnqmz!xjui!Tpvui!Tbo!GsbodjtdpÅt!efwfmpqnfou!tuboebset-!jodmvejoh! dpouspm!pg!pvuepps!bsujgjdjbm!mjhiu-!tvdi!bt!uif!vtf!pg!gjyuvsft!uibu!tijfme!mjhiu!boe!qsfwfou! pcusvtjwf!hmbsf!poup!uif!qvcmjd!sjhiu!pg!xbz!ps!bekpjojoh!qspqfsujft/!Gvsuifs-!uif!gbdjmjuz!jt! opu!qspqptjoh!up!pqfsbuf!evsjoh!uif!fwfojoh!ps!ojhiuujnf!ipvst-!xijdi!xjmm!gvsuifs! njojnj{f!uif!vtf!pg!mjhiu!evsjoh!uiftf!ipvst/!Bddpsejohmz-!uif!Qspkfdu!xjmm!opu!dsfbuf!b! ofx!tpvsdf!pg!tvctuboujbm!mjhiu!ps!hmbsf!xijdi!xpvme!bewfstfmz!bggfdu!ebz!ps!ojhiuujnf! wjfxt!jo!uif!bsfb/! II. AGRICULTURAL/ FOREST RESOURCES Jo!efufsnjojoh!xifuifs!jnqbdut!up! Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo bhsjdvmuvsbm!sftpvsdft!bsf!tjhojgjdbou! Significant Significant Significant Impact fowjsponfoubm!fggfdut-!mfbe!bhfodjft!nbz! Impact with Impact sfgfs!up!uif!Dbmjgpsojb!Bhsjdvmuvsbm!Mboe! Mitigation Fwbmvbujpo!boe!Tjuf!Bttfttnfou!Npefm! Incorporation )2::8*!qsfqbsfe!cz!uif!Dbmjgpsojb!Efqu/!pg! Dpotfswbujpo!bt!bo!pqujpobm!npefm!up!vtf!jo! bttfttjoh!jnqbdut!po!bhsjdvmuvsf!boe! gbsnmboe/!Jo!efufsnjojoh!xifuifs!jnqbdut!up! gpsftu!sftpvsdft-!jodmvejoh!ujncfsmboe-!bsf! tjhojgjdbou!fowjsponfoubm!fggfdut-!mfbe! bhfodjft!boe!sfgfs!up!jogpsnbujpo!dpnqjmfe! cz!uif!Dbmjgpsojb!Efqbsunfou!pg!Gpsftusz0!Gjsf! Qspufdujpo!sfhbsejoh!uif!tubufÅt!jowfoupsz!pg! gpsftu!mboe-!jodmvejoh!uif!Gpsftu!boe!Sbohf! Bttfttnfou!Qspkfdu!boe!uif!Gpsftu!Mfhbdz! Bttfttnfou!Qspkfdu!<!boe!gpsftu!dbscpo! nfbtvsfnfou!nfuipepmphz!qspwjefe!jo! Gpsftu!Qspupdpmt!bepqufe!cz!uif!Dbmjgpsojb! Bjs!Sftpvsdft!Cpbse/!Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! b*!Dpowfsu!Qsjnf!Gbsnmboe-!Vojrvf! Gbsnmboe-!ps!Gbsnmboe!pg!Tubufxjef! Jnqpsubodf!)Gbsnmboe*-!bt!tipxo!po!uif! !!!y! nbqt!qsfqbsfe!qvstvbou!up!uif!Gbsnmboe! Nbqqjoh!boe!Npojupsjoh!Qsphsbn!pg!uif! Dbmjgpsojb!Sftpvsdft!Bhfodz-!up!opo. bhsjdvmuvsbm!vtf@! c*!Dpogmjdu!xjui!fyjtujoh!{pojoh!gps!bhsjdvmuvsbm! !!!y! vtf-!ps!b!Xjmmjbntpo!Bdu!dpousbdu@! d*!Dpogmjdu!xjui!fyjtujoh!{pojoh!gps-!ps!dbvtf! sf{pojoh!pg!gpsftu!mboe!)!bt!efgjofe!jo! Qvcmjd!Sftpvsdft!Dpef!Tfdujpo!23331! !!!y! )h*-!ujncfsmboe!)!bt!efgjofe!cz!QSD!Dpef! Tfdujpo!5637*!ps!ujncfsmboe!{pofe! Ujncfsmboe!Qspevdujpo!)bt!efgjofe!cz! Hpwfsonfou!Dpef!Tfdujpo!62215)h**! !!!y! !e*!Sftvmu!jo!mptt!pg!gpsftu!mboe!ps!dpowfstjpo! pg!gpsftu!mboe!up!opo.gpsftu!vtf! f*!Jowpmwf!puifs!dibohft!jo!uif!fyjtujoh! !!!y! fowjsponfou!xijdi-!evf!up!uifjs!mpdbujpo! ps!obuvsf-!dpvme!sftvmu!jo!dpowfstjpo!pg! Gbsnmboe-!up!opo.bhsjdvmuvsbm!vtf@! Discussion: a-b and e) The Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program (FMMP) of the California Resources Agency designate the proposed project area as Urban and Built-Up Land. No Prime Farmlands, Farmlands of Statewide Importance, or Williamson Act contract lands are located within the in the proposal area. d!boe!e*!Uifsf!bsf!op!eftjhobufe!gpsftu!mboet!xjuijo!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb/!!Uifsf!jt!b! qspqptfe!sf{pojoh!pg!uif!qspqfsuz!cvu!op!mptt!pg!gpsftu!mboe!ps!dpowfstjpo!pg!gpsftu! mboe!xjmm!pddvs!bt!b!sftvmu!pg!uif!efwfmpqnfou!ps!qspqptfe!mboe!vtf!bdujpot/! III. AIR QUALITY Xifsf!bwbjmbcmf-!uif!tjhojgjdbodf!dsjufsjb!Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo ftubcmjtife!cz!uif!bqqmjdbcmf!bjs!rvbmjuz! Significant Significant Significant Impact nbobhfnfou!ps!bjs!qpmmvujpo!dpouspm!ejtusjdu! Impact with Impact nbz!cf!sfmjfe!vqpo!up!nblf!uif!gpmmpxjoh! Mitigation efufsnjobujpot/!Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! Incorporation b*!Dpogmjdu!xjui!ps!pctusvdu!jnqmfnfoubujpo!pg! !!!y! uif!bqqmjdbcmf!bjs!rvbmjuz!qmbo@! c*!Wjpmbuf!boz!bjs!rvbmjuz!tuboebse!ps! !!y!! dpousjcvuf!tvctuboujbmmz!up!bo!fyjtujoh!ps! qspkfdufe!bjs!rvbmjuz!wjpmbujpo@! d*!Sftvmu!jo!b!dvnvmbujwfmz!dpotjefsbcmf!ofu! jodsfbtf!pg!boz!dsjufsjb!qpmmvubou!gps!xijdi! uif!qspkfdu!sfhjpo!jt!opo.buubjonfou!voefs! !!y!! bo!bqqmjdbcmf!gfefsbm!ps!tubuf!bncjfou!bjs! rvbmjuz!tuboebse!)jodmvejoh!sfmfbtjoh! fnjttjpot!xijdi!fydffe!rvboujubujwf! uisftipmet!gps!p{pof!qsfdvstpst*@! e*!Fyqptf!tfotjujwf!sfdfqupst!up!tvctuboujbm! !!y!! qpmmvubou!dpodfousbujpot@! f*!Dsfbuf!pckfdujpobcmf!pepst!bggfdujoh!b! !!!y! tvctuboujbm!ovncfs!pg!qfpqmf@! Discussion: Qspkfdu!Tfuujoh;! Uif!qspkfdu!jt!mpdbufe!jo!uif!Djuz!pg!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!jo!Tbo!Nbufp!Dpvouz!boe! jt!xjuijo!uif!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Cbz!Bsfb!Cbtjo/!!Uif!mpdbm!bhfodz!xjui!Kvsjtejdujpo!pwfs! bjs!rvbmjuz!npojupsjoh!boe!qmboojoh!jo!uif!Cbtjo!jt!uif!Cbz!Bsfb!Bjs!Rvbmjuz! Nbobhfnfou!Ejtusjdu!)CBBRNE*/!Uif!Cbz!Bsfb!Bjs!Rvbmjuz!Nbobhfnfou!Ejtusjdu! )CBBRNE*!boe!uif!Dbmjgpsojb!Bjs!Sftpvsdft!Cpbse!)DBSC*!pqfsbuf!b!sfhjpobm! npojupsjoh!ofuxpsl!uibu!nfbtvsft!uif!bncjfou!dpodfousbujpot!pg!tjy!dsjufsjb!bjs! qpmmvubout;!p{pof-!dbscpo!npopyjef!)DP*-!ojusphfo!ejpyjef!)OP3*-!tvmgvs!ejpyjef! )TP3*-!qbsujdvmbuf!nbuufs!)QN*/!Uif!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Cbz!Bsfb!Cbtjo!jt!bmtp!dvssfoumz! eftjhobufe!bt!b!opobuubjonfou!bsfb!gps!Tubuf!QN.21!boe!QN.3/6!tuboebset!cvu!jt! mjtufe!bt!vodmbttjgjfe!voefs!gfefsbm!QN.21!boe!QN.3/6!tuboebset/!Uif!tuboebset!gps! DP-!OP3-!TP3-!boe!mfbe!bsf!cfjoh!nfu!jo!uif!Cbz!Bsfb/!Uif!Cbz!Bsfb!jt!dvssfoumz!b! nbshjobm!opo.buubjonfou!bsfb!gps!uif!Gfefsbm!9.ipvs!p{pof!tuboebse!boe!opo. buubjonfou!bsfb/!!! Po!Kvof!3-!3121-!uif!Cbz!Bsfb!Bjs!Rvbmjuz!Nbobhfnfou!EjtusjduÅt!Cpbse!pg!Ejsfdupst! bepqufe!ofx!DFRB!uisftipmet!pg!tjhojgjdbodf/!Uif!uisftipmet!bsf!jodmvefe!jo!uif! Bjs!EjtusjduÅt!vqebufe!DFRB!Hvjefmjoft/!Uif!Hvjefmjoft!beesftt!sfdfou!dibohft!jo! bjs!rvbmjuz!tuboebset!gps!p{pof!boe!qbsujdvmbuf!nbuufs!)QN*!gspn!uif!Tubuf!pg! Dbmjgpsojb!boe!uif!V/T/!FQB/!Jo!beejujpo-!uif!ofx!hsffoipvtf!hbt!uisftipmet!xfsf! efwfmpqfe!up!fotvsf!uibu!uif!Cbz!Bsfb!nffut!uif!TubufÅt!qmbo!up!beesftt!dmjnbuf! dibohf/! b*!Dpogmjdu!xjui!ps!pctusvdu!jnqmfnfoubujpo!pg!uif!bqqmjdbcmf!bjs!rvbmjuz!qmbo@!!! Uif!Cbz!Bsfb!3116!P{pof!Tusbufhz!jt!uif!dvssfou!bqqmjdbcmf!bjs!rvbmjuz!qmbo!)Cbz! Bsfb!Rvbmjuz!Nbobhfnfou!Ejtusjdu-!3117*/!!B!qspkfdu!xpvme!cf!kvehfe!up!dpogmjdu!ps! pctusvdu!jnqmfnfoubujpo!pg!uif!sfhjpobm!bjs!rvbmjuz!qmbo!jg!ju!xpvme!cf!jodpotjtufou! xjui!uif!hspxui!bttvnqujpot-!jo!ufsnt!pg!qpqvmbujpo-!fnqmpznfou!ps!sfhjpobm!hspxui! jo!wfijdmf!njmft!usbwfmfe!)WNU*/!Uijt!dpvme!pddvs!jg!b!qspkfdu!sfrvjsft!b!hfofsbm!qmbo! bnfoenfou!ps!{pojoh!bnfoenfou!sftvmujoh!jo!hsfbufs!usbggjd!wpmvnft!uibo!qfsnjuufe! voefs!dvssfou!{pojoh/!!!! Uif!qspqptfe!qspkfdu!epft!opu!sfrvjsf!boz!bnfoenfout!up!uif!Hfofsbm!Qmbo!ps! [pojoh!Psejobodf-!boe!uifsfgpsf!op!dibohft!up!uif!bmmpxfe!vtft!jo!uif!bsfb-! efotjuz!ps!tdbmf!pg!efwfmpqnfou!!cfzpoe!xibu!jt!dvssfoumz!qfsnjuufe!bsf!qspqptfe<! bddpsejohmz-!uif!qspkfdu!xjmm!opu!sftvmu!jo!hsfbufs!WNU/!!Gvsuifsnpsf-!uif!qspqptfe! qspkfdu!epft!opu!jodmvef!fyqbotjpo!pg!vujmjujft!ps!jogsbtusvduvsf!uibu!nbz!sftvmu!jo! gvuvsf!hspxui/!!Bt!b!sftvmu!pg!njojnbm!dibohf!up!uif!cvjmejoh-!uif!sfvtf!pg!bo!fyjtujoh! cvjmejoh-!op!beejujpobm!efwfmpqnfou-!op!fyqbotjpo!pg!vujmjujft-!dpotjtufodz!xjui!uif! Hfofsbm!Qmbo!boe!dpnqmjbodf!xjui!uif![pojoh!Psejobodf-!uif!qspkfdu!xjmm!opu!dpogmjdu! xjui!uif!bqqmjdbcmf!bjs!rvbmjuz!qmbo!boe!op!jnqbdu!xjmm!pddvs/!! c*!Wjpmbuf!boz!bjs!rvbmjuz!tuboebse!ps!dpousjcvuf!tvctuboujbmmz!up!bo!fyjtujoh!ps! qspkfdufe!bjs!rvbmjuz!wjpmbujpo@!!! Uif!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Cbz!Bsfb!Bjs!Cbtjo!jt!dvssfoumz!eftjhobufe!bt!b!opo!buubjonfou! gps!tubuf!boe!obujpobm!p{pof!tuboebset!boe!obujpobm!qbsujdvmbuf!nbuufs!bncjfou!bjs! rvbmjuz!tuboebset/ Uif!Cbz!Bjs!Rvbmjuz!Nbobhfnfou!Ejtusjdu!Hvjefmjoft!jodmvef! tdsffojoh!dsjufsjb!gps!qspkfdut!uibu!sftvmu!jo!qpufoujbmmz!tjhojgjdbou!bjs!rvbmjuz!jnqbdut/!! Uif!tdsffojoh!dsjufsjb!mjtu!xbt!dsfbufe!up!qspwjef!mfbe!bhfodjft!boe!qspkfdu! bqqmjdbout!b!dpotfswbujwf!ftujnbuf!pg!qpufoujbm!jnqbdut/!!Uif!qspqptfe!7-371!trvbsf! gppu!cvjmejoh!uibu!xjmm!cf!vtfe!gps!gppe!tfswjdf!gbmmt!cfmpx!uif!tdsffojoh!tj{f!gps! sftubvsbout!)vtfe!bt!uif!nptu!dpotfswbujwf!tjnjmbs!mboe!vtf!uzqf*!!)tff!Buubdinfou! D!Uisftipme!Dsjufsjb!Ubcmf!4.2.CBBRNE*/!!!Jo!beejujpo-!gps!qspkfdut!uibu!bsf!njyfe. vtf-!jogjmm-!boe0ps!qspyjnbuf!up!usbotju!tfswjdf!boe!mpdbm!tfswjdft-!fnjttjpot!xpvme!cf! mftt!uibo!uif!hsffogjfme!uzqf!qspkfdu!uibu!uiftf!tdsffojoh!dsjufsjb!bsf!cbtfe!po Hjwfo!uibu!op!qiztjdbm!efwfmpqnfou!jt!qspqptfe-!uif!qspkfdu!gbmmt!cfmpx!uif! tjhojgjdbodf!dsjufsjb-!jt!bo!jogjmm!qspkfdu-!dmptf!up!usbotju!boe!nbkpsjuz!pg!qbuspot!vujmj{f! qvcmjd!usbotju-!uif!qspkfdu!xpvme!opu!dpousjcvuf!up!uif!Cbz!BsfbÅt!opo.buubjonfou! dpoejujpot/!Uijt!jnqbdu!xpvme!cf!mftt!uibo!tjhojgjdbou/ d*!Sftvmu!jo!b!dvnvmbujwfmz!ofu!jodsfbtf!pg!boz!dsjufsjb!qpmmvubou!gps!xijdi!uif!qspkfdu! sfhjpo!jt!opo.buubjonfou!voefs!bo!bqqmjdbcmf!gfefsbm!ps!tubuf!bncjfou!bjs!rvbmjuz! tuboebse@!!! Bt!ejtdvttfe!bcpwf!uif!qspqptfe!qspkfdu!xpvme!opu!wjpmbuf!bjs!rvbmjuz!tuboebset!ps! dpousjcvuf!up!bo!fyjtujoh!ps!qspkfdufe!bjs!rvbmjuz!wjpmbujpo/!!Uif!qspqptfe!qspkfdu!jt! qfsnjuufe!xjuijo!uijt!{pojoh!ejtusjdu!boe!qspqptft!op!beejujpobm!efwfmpqnfou!uibu! nbz!sftvmu!jo!b!dvnvmbujwf!jodsfbtf!jo!dsjufsjb!qpmmvubout/!Jo!beejujpo-!uif!qspqptfe! qspkfdu!epft!opu!jodmvef!vqhsbeft!up!fyjtujoh!jogsbtusvduvsf!ps!vujmjujft!jo!b!nboofs! uibu!xjmm!sftvmu!jo!hspxui.joevdjoh!jnqbdut!bu!uif!tjuf/!!Uifsfgpsf-!uif!jnqbdu!xjmm!cf! mftt!uibo!tjhojgjdbou/! e*!Fyqptf!tfotjujwf!sfdfqupst!up!tvctuboujbm!qpmmvubou!dpodfousbujpot!!! !!!!Uif!bqqmjdbou!qspqptft!up!sfvtf!bo!fyjtujoh!gbdjmjuz!gps!gppe!boe!tpdjbm!tfswjdf! qspwjtjpo/!Uif!qspkfdu!xjmm!opu!fyqptf!tfotjujwf!sfdfqupst!up!qpmmvubou!dpodfousbujpot/! Uif!njojnbm!dpotusvdujpo!bdujwjujft!boe!xpvme!opu!hfofsbuf!tvctuboujbm!qpmmvubou! dpodfousbujpot/!Tjodf!dpotusvdujpo!sfmbufe!tpvsdft!xpvme!cf!dpotjefsfe!uif!pomz! qpttjcmf!qpmmvubou!dpodfousbujpot!gps!uif!qspqptfe!qspkfdu!boe!cfdbvtf!uifz!pddvs! gps!b!tipsu!qfsjpe!pg!ujnf!boe!bsf!b!tvctuboujbm!ejtubodf!gspn!ofbscz!sfdfqupst-!uif! qspkfdu!xjmm!opu!fyqptf!tfotjujwf!sfdfqupst!up!tvctuboujbm!qpmmvubout!boe!uijt!jnqbdu! xpvme!cf!mftt!uibo!tjhojgjdbou/!!Gvsuifsnpsf-!uif!qspqptfe!qspkfdu!epft!opu!jodmvef! boz!ofx!efwfmpqnfou-!dpnqmjft!xjui!uif!Hfofsbm!Qmbo!boe![pojoh!Psejobodf! sftvmujoh!jo!op!gvuvsf!jodsfbtft!jo!ifbmui!sjtlt!gspn!uif!Qspkfdu/!!Uijt!jnqbdu!xpvme! cf!mftt!uibo!tjhojgjdbou/! f*!Dsfbuf!pckfdujpobcmf!pepst!bggfdujoh!b!tvctuboujbm!ovncfs!pg!qfpqmf/! Uif!qspqptfe!qspkfdu!xjmm!opu!dpogmjdu!xjui!ps!pctusvdu!jnqmfnfoubujpo!pg!uif!sfhjpobm! bjs!rvbmjuz!qmbo!ps!wjpmbuf!boz!bjs!rvbmjuz!tuboebse-!ps!sftvmu!jo!b!dvnvmbujwfmz! dpotjefsbcmf!ofu!jodsfbtf!pg!boz!dsjufsjb!qpmmvubou!evf!up!uif!gbdu!uibu!uijt!jt! qspqptfe!sfvtf!pg!bo!fyjtujoh!cvjmejoh!boe!xiptf!bdujwjuz!jt!qfsnjuufe!boe!jt! dpotjtufou!xjui!efwfmpqnfou!jo!uif!bsfb!boe!hfofsbm!qmbo!qpmjdz!bt!xfmm!bt!qspnpuft! jogjmm!efwfmpqnfou/!!Uif!vtf!xjmm!opu!dsfbuf!boz!pckfdujpobcmf!pepst!bggfdujoh!b! tvctuboujbm!ovncfs!pg!qfpqmf/!!Uijt!jnqbdu!xpvme!cf!mftt!uibo!tjhojgjdbou/ JW/!CJPMPHJDBM!SFTPVSDFT! Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu! Jnqbdu!xjui!Jnqbdu! Njujhbujpo! Jodpsqpsbujpo! Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! b*!Ibwf!b!tvctuboujbm!bewfstf!fggfdu-!fjuifs! ejsfdumz!ps!uispvhi!ibcjubu!npejgjdbujpot-! po!boz!tqfdjft!jefoujgjfe!bt!b!dboejebuf-! tfotjujwf-!ps!tqfdjbm!tubuvt!tqfdjft!jo! !!!y! mpdbm!ps!sfhjpobm!qmbot-!qpmjdjft-!ps! sfhvmbujpot-!ps!cz!uif!Dbmjgpsojb! Efqbsunfou!pg!Gjti!boe!Hbnf!ps!V/T/! Gjti!boe!Xjmemjgf!Tfswjdf@! c*!Ibwf!b!tvctuboujbm!bewfstf!fggfdu!po!boz! sjqbsjbo!ibcjubu!ps!puifs!tfotjujwf!obuvsbm! dpnnvojuz!jefoujgjfe!jo!mpdbm!ps!sfhjpobm! !!!y! qmbot-!qpmjdjft-!sfhvmbujpot-!ps!cz!uif! Dbmjgpsojb!Efqbsunfou!pg!Gjti!boe!Hbnf! ps!VT!Gjti!boe!Xjmemjgf!Tfswjdf@! d*!Ibwf!b!tvctuboujbm!bewfstf!fggfdu!po! gfefsbmmz!qspufdufe!xfumboet!bt!efgjofe!cz! Tfdujpo!515!pg!uif!Dmfbo!Xbufs!Bdu! !!!y! )jodmvejoh-!cvu!opu!mjnjufe!up-!nbsti-! wfsobm!qppm-!dpbtubm-!fud/*!uispvhi!ejsfdu! sfnpwbm-!gjmmjoh-!izespmphjdbm!joufssvqujpo-! ps!puifs!nfbot@! e*!Joufsgfsf!tvctuboujbmmz!xjui!uif!npwfnfou! pg!boz!obujwf!sftjefou!ps!njhsbupsz!gjti!ps! xjmemjgf!tqfdjft!ps!xjui!ftubcmjtife!obujwf! !!!y! sftjefou!ps!njhsbupsz!xjmemjgf!dpssjepst-!ps! jnqfef!uif!vtf!pg!obujwf!xjmemjgf!ovstfsz! tjuft@! f*!Dpogmjdu!xjui!boz!mpdbm!qpmjdjft!ps! psejobodft!qspufdujoh!cjpmphjdbm! !!!y! sftpvsdft-!tvdi!bt!b!usff!qsftfswbujpo! qpmjdz!ps!psejobodf@! g*!Dpogmjdu!xjui!uif!qspwjtjpot!pg!bo!bepqufe! Ibcjubu!Dpotfswbujpo!Qmbo-!Obuvsbm! !!!y! Dpnnvojuz!Dpotfswbujpo!Qmbo-!ps!puifs! bqqspwfe!mpdbm-!sfhjpobm-!ps!tubuf!ibcjubu! dpotfswbujpo!qmbo@! Ejtdvttjpo;!! a-f). The project proposes to develop on an existing infill site, which is fully developed and has been used for office use since 1952. The site does not contain any sensitive habitats or any special status species and will not interfere with or cause movement of any native resident or migratory fish or wildlife species. There is no Habitat Conservation Plan, Natural Community Conservation Plan or other bqqspwfe!mpdbm-!sfhjpobm!ps!tubuf!ibcjubu!dpotfswbujpo!qmbo!uibu!bqqmjft!up!uif!tjuf/! Bddpsejohmz-!uifsf!xpvme!cf!op!jnqbdut!up!cjpmphjdbm!sftpvsdft!bt!b!sftvmu!pg!uif! qspkfdu/! W/!DVMUVSBM!SFTPVSDFT! Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu! Jnqbdu!xjui!Jnqbdu! Njujhbujpo! Jodpsqpsbujpo! Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! b*!Dbvtf!b!tvctuboujbm!bewfstf!dibohf!jo!uif! !!y!! tjhojgjdbodf!pg!b!ijtupsjdbm!sftpvsdf!bt! efgjofe!jo!(26175/6@! c*!Dbvtf!b!tvctuboujbm!bewfstf!dibohf!jo!uif! !!y!! tjhojgjdbodf!pg!bo!bsdibfpmphjdbm! sftpvsdf!qvstvbou!up!(26175/6@! d*!Ejsfdumz!ps!joejsfdumz!eftuspz!b!vojrvf! !!y!! qbmfpoupmphjdbm!sftpvsdf!ps!tjuf!ps!vojrvf! hfpmphjd!gfbuvsf@! e*!Ejtuvsc!boz!ivnbo!sfnbjot-!jodmvejoh! !!y!! uiptf!joufssfe!pvutjef!pg!gpsnbm! dfnfufsjft@! Ejtdvttjpo;!! b.e*!Mboe!vtft!xjuijo!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb!jodmvef!dpnnfsdjbm!boe!sftjefoujbm!vtft/!!Uif! qspkfdu!bsfb!ibt!opu!cffo!tvswfzfe!gps!ijtupsjdbm-!bsdibfpmphjdbm!ps!qbmfpoupmphjdbm!! sftpvsdft-!ps!ivnbo!sfnbjot!bt!njojnbm!qiztjdbm!dibohft!bsf!qspqptfe!bt!qbsu!pg! uif!jotubmmbujpo!pg!mboetdbqjoh!boe!dpotusvdujpo!sfmbufe!up!uif!sfvtf!pg!uif!cvjmejoh/!! Uif!qspkfdu!tjuf!ibt!ijtupsjdbmmz!cffo!vtfe!gps!pggjdf!boe!dpnnfsdjbm!vtft!ju!jt!gvmmz! qbwfe!boe!uif!qspqptfe!qspkfdu!epft!opu!jodmvef!boz!sfnpwbm!pg!btqibmu!ps!ejhhjoh! jo!tpjm!fydfqu!gps!mjnjufe!jotubmmbujpo!pg!mboetdbqjoh/!Ju!jt!vomjlfmz!uibu!ivnbo!sfnbjot! ps!sftpvsdft!pg!ijtupsjdbm-!bsdifpmphjdbm!ps!qbmfoujmphjdbm!wbmvf!fyjtu!po!uif!tjuf!evf! up!uif!ejtuvscfe!obuvsf!ps!uif!tjuf!boe!jut!tvsspvoejoht/!!Jo!uif!fwfou!uibu!boz! bsdibfpmphjdbm!sfnbjot!ps!sftpvsdft!bsf!gpvoe!evsjoh!tjuf!qsfqbsbujpo-!qspwjtjpot!pg! tubuf!mbx!boe!qpmjdjft!jo!uif!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Hfofsbm!Qmbo!)Qpmjdz!8/6.J.6*! xpvme!pqfsbuf!up!sfevdf!boz!qpufoujbm!jnqbdu!up!b!mftt!uibo!tjhojgjdbou!mfwfm-!cz! sfrvjsjoh!dpotusvdujpo!bdujwjujft!up!tupq-!bqqspqsjbuf!bvuipsjujft!)f/h/-!uif!dpspofs!jo! uif!fwfou!ivnbo!sfnbjot!bsf!vodpwfsfe*!cf!opujgjfe-!boe!b!uibu!njujhbujpo!qmbo! qsfqbsfe!cz!b!rvbmjgjfe!bsdibfpmphjtu!cf!jnqmfnfoufe/!Dpnqmjbodf!xjui!uiftf! tuboebset!boe!qpmjdjft!xjmm!fotvsf!uibu!uif!QspkfduÅt!jnqbdut!sfnbjo!mftt!uibo! tjhojgjdbou/ !!! VI. GEOLOGY AND SOILS Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo Significant Significant Significant Impact Impact with Impact Mitigation Incorporation Would the project: !!y!! b*!Fyqptf!qfpqmf!ps!tusvduvsft!up!qpufoujbm! tvctuboujbm!bewfstf!fggfdut-!jodmvejoh!uif! sjtl!pg!mptt-!jokvsz-!ps!efbui!jowpmwjoh;! j*!Svquvsf!pg!b!lopxo!fbsuirvblf!gbvmu-!bt! efmjofbufe!po!uif!nptu!sfdfou!Bmrvjtu. Qsjpmp!Fbsuirvblf!Gbvmu![pojoh!Nbq! !!!y! jttvfe!cz!uif!Tubuf!Hfpmphjtu!gps!uif!bsfb! ps!cbtfe!po!puifs!tvctuboujbm!fwjefodf!pg! b!lopxo!gbvmu@!Sfgfs!up!Ejwjtjpo!pg!Njoft! boe!Hfpmphz!Tqfdjbm!Qvcmjdbujpo!53/! !!y!! jj*!Tuspoh!tfjtnjd!hspvoe!tibljoh@! jjj*!Tfjtnjd.sfmbufe!hspvoe!gbjmvsf-!jodmvejoh! !!y!! mjrvfgbdujpo@! !!!y! jw*!Mboetmjeft@! c*!Sftvmu!jo!tvctuboujbm!tpjm!fsptjpo!ps!uif! !!!!y! mptt!pg!upqtpjm@! d*!Cf!mpdbufe!po!b!hfpmphjd!voju!ps!tpjm!uibu!jt! votubcmf-!ps!uibu!xpvme!cfdpnf!votubcmf! bt!b!sftvmu!pg!uif!qspkfdu-!boe!qpufoujbmmz! !!!y! sftvmu!jo!po.!ps!pgg.tjuf!mboetmjef-!mbufsbm! tqsfbejoh-!tvctjefodf-!mjrvfgbdujpo!ps! dpmmbqtf@! e*!Cf!mpdbufe!po!fyqbotjwf!tpjm-!bt!efgjofe!jo! Tfdujpo!2914/6/4!pg!uif!Dbmjgpsojb!Cvjmejoh! !!!y! Dpef!)3121*-!dsfbujoh!tvctuboujbm!sjtlt!up! mjgf!ps!qspqfsuz@! f*!Ibwf!tpjmt!jodbqbcmf!pg!befrvbufmz! tvqqpsujoh!uif!vtf!pg!tfqujd!ubolt!ps! !!!y! bmufsobujwf!xbtuf!xbufs!ejtqptbm!tztufnt! xifsf!tfxfst!bsf!opu!bwbjmbcmf!gps!uif! ejtqptbm!pg!xbtuf!xbufs@! Discussion: a) The Project Site is not located within an Alquist-Priolo Earthquake Fault Zone and no active or potentially active faults traverse the Project Site. Thus, potential impacts related to surface fault rupture would be less than significant. The site is located with an area designated by ABAG as flatland. There is no threat of landslides on the project site; therefore the Project would have no impact with respect to landslides. The site is located near the San Andreas Fault and within an area which could experience strong earthquake shaking or seismic related ground failure; however, renovation of the existing buildings and improvements on the site will be required to comply with the California Building Code, to ensure that the people and structures on the site will not be exposed to substantial adverse effects, including risk of loss, injury or death. Accordingly this impact would be less than significant. b-e) The Project proposes reuse of an existing structure that has been supported by underlying soil and geologic composition without significant issue. Renovation and reuse of the structure would not affect the soils ability to continue to support the existing structure, as the renovation and reuse will involve minimal physical changes to the site and building. The Project, therefore, will not result in greater instability of the soil. There is no evidence of the soil demonstrating expansive qualities, as defined in the California BuildingThe site is currently served by sewer; there is no . need for septic tanks or similar alternatives. Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu Jnqbduxjui!Jnqbdu Njujhbujpo! Jodpsqpsbujpo Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu; a) Generate greenhouse gas emissions, x either directly or indirectly, that may have a significant impact on the environment b) Conflict with an applicable plan, policy or regulation adopted for the purpose of x reducing the emissions of greenhouse gases a-b) Gases that trap heat in the atmosphere are referred to as greenhouse gases (GHGs) because they capture heat radiated from the sun as it is reflected back into the atmosphere, much like a greenhouse does. The accumulation of GHGs has been implicated as a driving force for global climate change. Definitions of climate change between and across regulatory authorities and the scientific community, but in general can be described as the changing of the earths climate caused by natural fluctuations and anthropogenic activities, which alter the composition of the global atmosphere. California State law defines GHGs as Carbon Dioxide, Methane, Nitrous Oxide, Hydrofluorocarbons, Perfluorocarbons, and Sulfur Hexafluoride. The primary contributions to GHG emissions in California are transportation, electric power production from both State and out of state sources, industry, agriculture and forestry, and other sources, which include commercial and residential activities. At present, the City of South San Francisco does not have an adopted plan or specific policies to reduce GHG emissions, although the City is early in the process of creating a Climate Action Plan and many of the Citys policies and ordinancessuch as one of the regions most aggressive Transportation Demand Management (TDM) programs achieve the same objective. South San Franciscos current TDM Ordinance, which requires that non- residential development generating more than 100 daily trips must incorporate measures to ensure that at least 28% of all trips are made through alternative mode use. As incentives to implement programs that will further reduce vehicle trips, the TDM provisions provide a floor area ratio (FAR) bonus in accordance with the General Plan when 30% to 45% of all trips involve alternative mode use, depending on the type of development and requested FAR. The City is completing an emissions survey that will provide a basis for formally developing such tools. Although the General Plan did not specify policies and programs designed to reduce GHG emissions, many of the Plans policies will contribute to this objective by promoting development that is less reliant on motor vehicles. The proposed project will not generate more than 100 trips per day; the majority of trips will be completed using public transportation, bicycles and walking. So even though a specific policy has not zfu!cffo!bepqufe-!uif!qspqptfe!Qspkfdu!xjmm!cf!opu!fydffe!uif!uisftipme!boe!xpvme!cf! dpotjefsfe!mftt!uibo!tjhojgjdbou/! WJJJ/!IB[BSET!BOE!IB[BSEPVT!NBUFSJBMT! Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu! Jnqbdu!xjui!Jnqbdu! Njujhbujpo! Jodpsqpsbujpo! Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! b*!Dsfbuf!b!tjhojgjdbou!ib{bse!up!uif!qvcmjd! ps!uif!fowjsponfou!uispvhi!uif!spvujof! !!y!! usbotqpsu-!vtf-!ps!ejtqptbm!pg!ib{bsepvt! nbufsjbmt@! c*!Dsfbuf!b!tjhojgjdbou!ib{bse!up!uif!qvcmjd! ps!uif!fowjsponfou!uispvhi!sfbtpobcmz! gpsftffbcmf!vqtfu!boe!bddjefou! !!!y! dpoejujpot!jowpmwjoh!uif!sfmfbtf!pg! ib{bsepvt!nbufsjbmt!joup!uif! fowjsponfou@! d*!Fnju!ib{bsepvt!fnjttjpot!ps!iboemf! ib{bsepvt!ps!bdvufmz!ib{bsepvt! !!!y! nbufsjbmt-!tvctubodft-!ps!xbtuf!xjuijo! pof.rvbsufs!njmf!pg!bo!fyjtujoh!ps! qspqptfe!tdippm@! e*!Cf!mpdbufe!po!b!tjuf!xijdi!jt!jodmvefe!po! b!mjtu!pg!ib{bsepvt!nbufsjbmt!tjuft! dpnqjmfe!qvstvbou!up!Hpwfsonfou!Dpef! !!!y! Tfdujpo!76:73/6!boe-!bt!b!sftvmu-!xpvme!ju! dsfbuf!b!tjhojgjdbou!ib{bse!up!uif!qvcmjd!ps! uif!fowjsponfou@! f*!Gps!b!qspkfdu!mpdbufe!xjuijo!bo!bjsqpsu!mboe! vtf!qmbo!ps-!xifsf!tvdi!b!qmbo!ibt!opu! cffo!bepqufe-!xjuijo!uxp!njmft!pg!b!qvcmjd! !!!y! bjsqpsu!ps!qvcmjd!vtf!bjsqpsu-!xpvme!uif! qspkfdu!sftvmu!jo!b!tbgfuz!ib{bse!gps!qfpqmf! sftjejoh!ps!xpsljoh!jo!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb@! g*!Gps!b!qspkfdu!xjuijo!uif!wjdjojuz!pg!b!qsjwbuf! bjstusjq-!xpvme!uif!qspkfdu!sftvmu!jo!b! !!!y! tbgfuz!ib{bse!gps!qfpqmf!sftjejoh!ps! xpsljoh!jo!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb@! h*!Jnqbjs!jnqmfnfoubujpo!pg!ps!qiztjdbmmz! joufsgfsf!xjui!bo!bepqufe!fnfshfodz! !!!y! sftqpotf!qmbo!ps!fnfshfodz!fwbdvbujpo! qmbo@! i*!Fyqptf!qfpqmf!ps!tusvduvsft!up!b! tjhojgjdbou!sjtl!pg!mptt-!jokvsz!ps!efbui! jowpmwjoh!xjmemboe!gjsft-!jodmvejoh!xifsf! !!!y! xjmemboet!bsf!bekbdfou!up!vscboj{fe!bsfbt! ps!xifsf!sftjefodft!bsf!joufsnjyfe!xjui! xjmemboet@! Ejtdvttjpo;!! a- c) The proposed project is to operate a charitable food and social services facility within an existing building located on a fully developed site. No hazardous materials are proposed to be transported or used as part of the operation of this facility. Therefore, no release or emissions of hazardous materials will occur. During construction, hazardous materials could be transported to the project site. Construction activities typically involve the use of substances such as paints, fuels, and solvents. Construction activities are subject to federal, state and local laws and requirements that are designed to minimize and help avoid potential health and safety risks associated with hazardous materials. There are no schools located within one-quarter mile of the proposed project; therefore there would be no impact. d) The project site is not included on lists of hazardous materials sites pursuant to any government code; there would be no impact. Furthermore a Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) (See Attachment D) was conducted for the property and found that there are no underground tanks, nor any evidence that the site has historically been used for storage, use or disposal of hazardous materials. The Phase 1 ESA did conclude that with the exception of a recommended indoor air assessment (which has been completed for the project and is also included in Attachment D), there were no recognized environmental conditions on the property. There was no recommendation of remediation of any ground or soil contamination at the site. Furthermore the applicant is not proposing any substantial below grade construction and the site is fully developed with a building and paved surface parking lot. e-f) The site is located in close proximity of San Francisco International Airport but there are no private airstrips in the vicinity. The Project proposes reuse of an existing structure that has historically been used for office/warehouse use. The limited use proposed by the Project will not result in a safety hazard for people working at the site or residing in the area. g) The project would not result in any changes to existing streets or emergency roads, and therefore would not interfere with any response or emergency evacuation plan that may be in affect for the area. h) The project is not located near wildlands. JY/!IZESPMPHZ!BOE!XBUFS!RVBMJUZ! Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu! Jnqbdu!xjui!Jnqbdu! Njujhbujpo! Jodpsqpsbujpo! Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! b*!Wjpmbuf!boz!xbufs!rvbmjuz!tuboebset!ps! !!!y! xbtuf!ejtdibshf!sfrvjsfnfout@! c*!Tvctuboujbmmz!efqmfuf!hspvoexbufs! tvqqmjft!ps!joufsgfsf!tvctuboujbmmz!xjui! hspvoexbufs!sfdibshf!tvdi!uibu!uifsf! xpvme!cf!b!ofu!efgjdju!jo!brvjgfs!wpmvnf!ps! b!mpxfsjoh!pg!uif!mpdbm!hspvoexbufs!ubcmf! !!!y! mfwfm!)f/h/-!uif!qspevdujpo!sbuf!pg!qsf. fyjtujoh!ofbscz!xfmmt!xpvme!espq!up!b!mfwfm! xijdi!xpvme!opu!tvqqpsu!fyjtujoh!mboe! vtft!ps!qmboofe!vtft!gps!xijdi!qfsnjut! ibwf!cffo!hsboufe*@! d*!Tvctuboujbmmz!bmufs!uif!fyjtujoh!esbjobhf! qbuufso!pg!uif!tjuf!ps!bsfb-!jodmvejoh! uispvhi!uif!bmufsbujpo!pg!uif!dpvstf!pg!b! !!y!! tusfbn!ps!sjwfs-!jo!b!nboofs!xijdi!xpvme! sftvmu!jo!tvctuboujbm!fsptjpo!ps!tjmubujpo! po.!ps!pgg.tjuf@! e*!Tvctuboujbmmz!bmufs!uif!fyjtujoh!esbjobhf! qbuufso!pg!uif!tjuf!ps!bsfb-!jodmvejoh! uispvhi!uif!bmufsbujpo!pg!uif!dpvstf!pg!b! !!y!! tusfbn!ps!sjwfs-!ps!tvctuboujbmmz!jodsfbtf! uif!sbuf!ps!bnpvou!pg!tvsgbdf!svopgg!jo!b! nboofs!xijdi!xpvme!sftvmu!jo!gmppejoh!po.! ps!pgg.tjuf@! f*!Dsfbuf!ps!dpousjcvuf!svopgg!xbufs!xijdi! xpvme!fydffe!uif!dbqbdjuz!pg!fyjtujoh!ps! !!y!! qmboofe!tupsnxbufs!esbjobhf!tztufnt!ps! qspwjef!tvctuboujbm!beejujpobm!tpvsdft!pg! qpmmvufe!svopgg@! g*!Puifsxjtf!tvctuboujbmmz!efhsbef!xbufs! !!y!! rvbmjuz@! h*!Qmbdf!ipvtjoh!xjuijo!b!211.zfbs!gmppe! ib{bse!bsfb!bt!nbqqfe!po!b!gfefsbm! !!!y! Gmppe!Ib{bse!Cpvoebsz!ps!Gmppe! Jotvsbodf!Sbuf!Nbq!ps!puifs!gmppe!ib{bse! efmjofbujpo!nbq@! i*!Qmbdf!xjuijo!b!211.zfbs!gmppe!ib{bse!bsfb! !!!y! tusvduvsft!xijdi!xpvme!jnqfef!ps!sfejsfdu! gmppe!gmpxt@! Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu! Jnqbdu!xjui!Jnqbdu! Njujhbujpo! Jodpsqpsbujpo! Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! i) Expose people or structures to a significant risk of loss, injury or death x involving flooding, including flooding as a result of the failure of a levee or dam? j) Inundation by seiche, tsunami, or x mudflow? Ejtdvttjpo;!! a-b) The site is fully developed hence no new development or drainage is proposed. The applicant will be required to comply with all applicable water quality standards including the City's Storm Water Quality Management and Discharge Control Ordinance, and National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) requirements. The project would result in minimal, if any, changes to existing topography, and will include new landscaped (permeable) area, therefore the project will not negatively affect groundwater supplies, interfere substantially with groundwater recharge, or lower the local groundwater table level. c-f) The proposed Project does not include changes to the topography, includes little to no grading therefore it will not alter existing drainage patterns in a manner that would cause erosion, siltation, or flooding conditions on or off the site. The project will not contribute runoff that would exceed the capacity of existing drainage systems, or otherwise substantially degrade water quality. g-h) The project is located in Zone B an area of moderate flood hazard, usually the 1 area between the limits of the 100-year and 500-year floods. B Zones are also used to designate base floodplains of lesser hazards, such as areas protected by levees from 100-year flood, or shallow flooding areas with average depths of less than one foot or drainage areas less than 1 square mile. The Project does not propose placement of any housing or new structures at the site. i-j) The project site is not near a levee or dam, nor any large body of water that could cause seiche, tsunami, or mudflow. 1 FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Map, City of SSF, Community Panel Number 065062 0002 B, effective September 2, 1981 Y/!MBOE!VTF!BOE!QMBOOJOH! Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo Significant Significant Significant Impact Impact with Impact Mitigation Incorporation Would the project: a) Physically divide an established x community? b) Conflict with any applicable land use plan, policy, or regulation of an agency with jurisdiction over the project (including, but not limited to the general plan, specific x plan, local coastal program, or zoning ordinance) adopted for the purpose of avoiding or mitigating an environmental effect? c) Conflict with any applicable habitat x conservation plan or natural community conservation plan? Discussion: a) Will the project physically divide an established community? No. The project is proposed on a fully developed commercial site. The project site is bordered by residential and commercial/industrial development, and is consistent with applicable General Plan and zoning standards. b) Will the project conflict with any applicable land use plan, policy, or regulation of an agency with jurisdiction over the project (including, but not limited to the general plan, specific plan, local coastal program, or zoning ordinance) adopted for the purpose of avoiding or mitigating an environmental effect? No. The proposed project is consistent with the goals and policies of the General Plan. The General Plan has a mixed designation for the site, including Community Commercial and Downtown Medium Density, which allows for social services. The proposed project is also complies with the Citys zoning regulations for the Downtown Mixed Use (DMX) Zoning District, provided the Parking Reduction application is approved by the City. (Attachment E- General Plan) (Attachment F -Zoning Designation) c) Will the project conflict with any applicable habitat conservation plan or natural community conservation plan? No. There are no local or regional habitat conservation or natural community conservation plans that are applicable to the project site. XI. MINERAL RESOURCES Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo Significant Significant Significant Impact Impact with Impact Mitigation Incorporation Would the project: a) Result in the loss of availability of a known mineral resource that would be of x value to the region and the residents of the state? b) Result in the loss of availability of a locally-important mineral resource x recovery site delineated on a local general plan, specific plan or other land use plan? Discussion: a-b). There are no known mineral resources or mineral resource recovery in the area. Thus no impacts to mineral resources are anticipated to occur as a result of the proposed project. XII. NOISE Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo Significant Significant Significant Impact Impact with Impact Mitigation Incorporation Would the project result in: b*!Fyqptvsf!pg!qfstpot!up!ps!hfofsbujpo!pg! opjtf!mfwfmt!jo!fydftt!pg!tuboebset! !!y!! ftubcmjtife!jo!uif!mpdbm!hfofsbm!qmbo!ps! opjtf!psejobodf-!ps!bqqmjdbcmf!tuboebset! pg!puifs!bhfodjft@! c*!Fyqptvsf!pg!qfstpot!up!ps!hfofsbujpo!pg! !!y!! fydfttjwf!hspvoecpsof!wjcsbujpo!ps! hspvoecpsof!opjtf!mfwfmt@! d*!B!tvctuboujbm!qfsnbofou!jodsfbtf!jo! !!y!! bncjfou!opjtf!mfwfmt!jo!uif!qspkfdu!wjdjojuz! bcpwf!mfwfmt!fyjtujoh!xjuipvu!uif!qspkfdu@! e*!B!tvctuboujbm!ufnqpsbsz!ps!qfsjpejd! jodsfbtf!jo!bncjfou!opjtf!mfwfmt!jo!uif! !!y!! qspkfdu!wjdjojuz!bcpwf!mfwfmt!fyjtujoh! xjuipvu!uif!qspkfdu@! f*!Gps!b!qspkfdu!mpdbufe!xjuijo!bo!bjsqpsu!mboe! vtf!qmbo!ps-!xifsf!tvdi!b!qmbo!ibt!opu! cffo!bepqufe-!xjuijo!uxp!njmft!pg!b!qvcmjd! !!!y! bjsqpsu!ps!qvcmjd!vtf!bjsqpsu-!xpvme!uif! qspkfdu!fyqptf!qfpqmf!sftjejoh!ps!xpsljoh! jo!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb!up!fydfttjwf!opjtf! mfwfmt@! g*!Gps!b!qspkfdu!xjuijo!uif!wjdjojuz!pg!b!qsjwbuf! bjstusjq-!xpvme!uif!qspkfdu!fyqptf!qfpqmf! !!!y! sftjejoh!ps!xpsljoh!jo!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb!up! fydfttjwf!opjtf!mfwfmt@! Discussion: b.e*!Uif!opjtf!mfwfm!bu!uif!tjuf!xjmm!cf!xjuijo!bddfqubcmf!mjnjut!ftubcmjtife!jo!uif! Hfofsbm!Qmbo/!!Uif!opjtf!mfwfmt!bu!uif!tjuf!xjmm!jodsfbtf!cz!2.3!efdjcfmt!boe!jt! efufsnjofe!up!cf!bddfqubcmf!)Dibsmft!Tbmufs-!Opjtf!Bttfttnfou!Tuvez!3122-! buubdife!bt!Buubdinfou!H*/!Uif!vtf!pg!nfdibojdbm!frvjqnfou!boe!qfpqmf! dpohsfhbujoh!bu!uif!tjuf!xjmm!cf!xjuijo!bddfqubcmf!opjtf!mfwfmt!boe!xjmm!opu!bewfstfmz! jnqbdu!uif!tvsspvoejoh!dpnnfsdjbm!efwfmpqnfou!boe!sftjefodft!up!uif!tpvui/!Uif! qfsjpet!xifo!gppe!jt!cfjoh!dpplfe!ps!tfswjdft!bsf!qspwjefe!nbz!jodsfbtf!bncjfou! opjtf!mfwfmt!cvu!opu!bcpwf!bddfqubcmf!mfwfmt!)Tbmufs!3122*/! f*!Uif!qspkfdu!jt!mpdbufe!jo!dmptf!qspyjnjuz!up!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Joufsobujpobm!Bjsqpsu! ipxfwfs!op!pof!xjmm!cf!sftjejoh!bu!uif!mpdbujpo!boe!wjtjut!up!uif!tjuf!bsf!gps!tipsu! qfsjpet!pg!ujnf!sfevdjoh!ps!fmjnjobujoh!boz!fyqptvsf!fjuifs!tipsu!ps!mpoh!ufsn/!! Gvsuifsnpsf-!bt!ejtdvttfe!fbsmjfs!uif!opjtf!mfwfmt!hfofsbufe!cz!uif!qspqptfe!vtf! bsf!gpvoe!up!cf!bddfqubcmf/! f) The project is not located near a private airstrip, therefore; there will be no significant impact. YJJJ/!QPQVMBUJPO!BOE!IPVTJOH! Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu! Jnqbdu!xjui!Jnqbdu! Njujhbujpo! Jodpsqpsbujpo! Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! a) Induce substantial population growth in an area, either directly (for example, by X proposing new homes and businesses) or indirectly (for example, through extension of roads or other infrastructure)? b) Displace substantial numbers of existing x housing, necessitating the construction of replacement housing elsewhere? c) Displace substantial numbers of people, x necessitating the construction of replacement housing elsewhere? Ejtdvttjpo;!! a) No new residential dwelling units, roads, or other substantial infrastructure improvements are proposed as part of the facility. b-c) The site is developed with a vacant building previously used as offices, no residences are being demolished and or removed, and no new housing will be required. The project proposes reuse of a commercial building with no residential component. The Project will not result in displacement of any housing or people. YJW/!QVCMJD!TFSWJDFT! a) Would the project result in substantial Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! adverse physical impacts associated with the Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu! provision of new or physically altered Jnqbdu!xjui!Jnqbdu! governmental facilities, need for new or Njujhbujpo! physically altered governmental facilities, the Jodpsqpsbujpo! construction of which could cause significant environmental impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response times or other performance objectives for any of the public services: x Fire protection? x Police protection? x Schools? x Parks? x Other public facilities? a) The project site is fully developed. The applicant will be occupying the building and will remodel the facility to accommodate the new use. The Police Department does not anticipate an increase in service demand, because the use largely exists in the Downtown area today. However, the Police Department has agreed to expand their presence in and around the proposed use. The expanded Police presence is not specific to SVdP, but they will certainly benefit from the additional Police presence. Aside from the Police Department, there will be no need for additional services. Services for the area have already been allocated; there will be no need for additional services. There will be no additional needs for schools since no new residences are created as part of this proposal. XV. RECREATION Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo Significant Significant Significant Impact Impact with Impact Mitigation Incorporation b*!Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu!jodsfbtf!uif!vtf!pg! fyjtujoh!ofjhicpsippe!boe!sfhjpobm!qbslt! !!!y! ps!puifs!sfdsfbujpobm!gbdjmjujft!tvdi!uibu! tvctuboujbm!qiztjdbm!efufsjpsbujpo!pg!uif! gbdjmjuz!xpvme!pddvs!ps!cf!bddfmfsbufe@! c*!Epft!uif!qspkfdu!jodmvef!sfdsfbujpobm! gbdjmjujft!ps!sfrvjsf!uif!dpotusvdujpo!ps! !!!y! fyqbotjpo!pg!sfdsfbujpobm!gbdjmjujft!xijdi! njhiu!ibwf!bo!bewfstf!qiztjdbm!fggfdu!po! uif!fowjsponfou@! Discussion: b*!Uif!qspqptbm!jt!up!qspwjef!gppe!boe!tpdjbm!tfswjdft!gps!qfpqmf!jo!offe<!uijt!xjmm!opu! jodsfbtf!uif!vtf!pg!ps!sfrvjsf!qspwjtjpo!pg!sfdsfbujpobm!gbdjmjujft/! c*!Uifsf!bsf!njojnbm!sfdsfbujpobm!gbdjmjujft!qspqptfe!bt!qbsu!pg!uijt!bqqmjdbujpo/!!Uif! bqqmjdbou!jt!qspqptjoh!bo!pvuepps!tfbujoh!bsfb0bsfb!gps!dmjfout!up!dpohsfhbuf!po! uif!tjuf!up!nffu!uif!offet!pg!uif!dmjfout!potjuf-!sbuifs!uibo!xjuijo!uif!qvcmjd!sjhiu. pg.xbz/!!! YWJ/!USBOTQPSUBUJPO0USBGGJD! Qpufoujbmmz!Mftt!Uibo!Mftt!UiboOp! Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Tjhojgjdbou!Jnqbdu! Jnqbdu!xjui!Jnqbdu! Njujhbujpo! Jodpsqpsbujpo! Xpvme!uif!qspkfdu;! b*!!Dpogmjdu!xjui!bo!bqqmjdbcmf!qmbo-! psejobodf!ps!qpmjdz!!ftubcmjtijoh! nfbtvsft!pg!fggfdujwfoftt!gps!uif! qfsgpsnbodf!pg!uif!djsdvmbujpo!tztufn-! ubljoh!joup!bddpvou!bmm!npeft!pg! usbotqpsubujpo!jodmvejoh!nbtt!usbotju!boe! !!!y! opo.npupsj{fe!usbwfm!sfmfwbou! dpnqpofout!pg!uif!djsdvmbujpo!tztufn-! jodmvejoh!cvu!opu!mjnjufe!up!joufstfdujpot-! tusffut-!ijhixbzt!boe!gsffxbzt-! qfeftusjbo!boe!cjdzdmf!qbuit-!boe!nbtt! usbotju! c*!Dpogmjdu!xjui!bo!bqqmjdbcmf!dpohftujpo! nbobhfnfou!qsphsbn-!jodmvejoh!cvu! mjnjufe!up!uif!mfwfm!pg!tfswjdf!tuboebset! !!!y! boe!usbwfm!efnboe!nfbtvsft-!ps!puifs! tuboebset!ftubcmjtife!cz!uif!Dpvouz! dpohftujpo!nbobhfnfou!bhfodz!ps! eftjhobufe!spbet!ps!ijhixbzt! d*!Sftvmu!jo!b!dibohf!jo!bjs!usbggjd!qbuufsot-! jodmvejoh!fjuifs!bo!jodsfbtf!jo!usbggjd! !!!y! mfwfmt!ps!b!dibohf!jo!mpdbujpo!uibu!sftvmut! jo!tvctuboujbm!tbgfuz!sjtlt@! e*!Tvctuboujbmmz!jodsfbtf!ib{bset!evf!up!b! eftjho!gfbuvsf!)f/h/-!tibsq!dvswft!ps! !!!y! ebohfspvt!joufstfdujpot*!ps!jodpnqbujcmf! vtft!)f/h/-!gbsn!frvjqnfou*@! !!!y! f*!Sftvmu!jo!jobefrvbuf!fnfshfodz!bddftt@! g*!Dpogmjdu!xjui!bepqufe!qpmjdjft-!qmbot-!ps! qsphsbnt!tvqqpsujoh!bmufsobujwf! !!!y! usbotqpsubujpo!)f/h/-!cvt!uvsopvut-!cjdzdmf! sbdlt*@! Ejtdvttjpo;! b*!Uif!qspkfdu!jt!qspqptfe!po!b!gvmmz!efwfmpqfe!tjuf!xjuijo!bo!ftubcmjtife! dpnnfsdjbm0sftjefoujbm!njyfe.vtf!{pof!ejtusjdu/!!Uif!nbkpsjuz!pg!uif!qbuspot!xjmm! bssjwf!bu!uif!tjuf!vtjoh!qvcmjd!usbotqpsubujpo-!cjdzdmft!ps!xbmljoh/!Uif!fyjtujoh! gppe!boe!tpdjbm!tfswjdf!gbdjmjuz!pqfsbufe!cz!Tu!Wjodfou!ef!Qbvm!jt!mpdbufe!bu!455! Hsboe!Bwfovf/!!B!tvswfz!pg!uif!tjuf!boe!jut!qbuspot!xbt!dpoevdufe!jo!Gfcsvbsz! 3122/!!Uif!sftvmut!qspwjefe!uif!gpmmpxjoh!jogpsnbujpo;!bqqspyjnbufmz!251!qbuspot! boe!wpmvouffst!bssjwf!ebjmz-!pg!uiptf!26!bssjwfe!po!cjdzdmft-!26!uppl!qvcmjd!usbotju-! 23.24!bssjwfe!cz!qsjwbuf!wfijdmf!boe!uif!sfnbjojoh!xbmlfe/!Bddpsejohmz-!cfdbvtf! the proposed Project will generate so few new vehicle trips, the Project will not conflict with or exceed the Citys measures of effectiveness for the streets and circulation system. (See Attachment H.) b) The projected vehicle volumes would not exceed projected levels of service either individually or cumulatively. The data collected by John Wilson, Sandis Engineers (Attachment H), shows low traffic volumes and no conflict with any congestion management practices and policies. c) The proposed new land use does not affect traffic patterns. d) The proposed project does not include any changes to the existing and approved street design, and there will be no conflict with compatible uses in the area. e) The current traffic circulation was approved by the City when the original building was approved. The reuse of the building does not include any changes to circulation or emergency access. f) There is no conflict with existing polices and plans. In fact, there is a substantial reduction in trips to the site than a typical commercial business since the majority of the patrons arrive via public transportation, bicycle and walking. XVII. UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo Significant Significant Significant Impact Impact with Impact Mitigation Incorporation Would the project: b*!Fydffe!xbtufxbufs!usfbunfou! !!!y! sfrvjsfnfout!pg!uif!bqqmjdbcmf!Sfhjpobm! Xbufs!Rvbmjuz!Dpouspm!Cpbse@! c*!Sfrvjsf!ps!sftvmu!jo!uif!dpotusvdujpo!pg! ofx!xbufs!ps!xbtufxbufs!usfbunfou! !!!y! gbdjmjujft!ps!fyqbotjpo!pg!fyjtujoh!gbdjmjujft-! uif!dpotusvdujpo!pg!xijdi!dpvme!dbvtf! tjhojgjdbou!fowjsponfoubm!fggfdut@! d*!Sfrvjsf!ps!sftvmu!jo!uif!dpotusvdujpo!pg! ofx!tupsn!xbufs!esbjobhf!gbdjmjujft!ps! !!!y! fyqbotjpo!pg!fyjtujoh!gbdjmjujft-!uif! dpotusvdujpo!pg!xijdi!dpvme!dbvtf! tjhojgjdbou!fowjsponfoubm!fggfdut@! e*!Ibwf!tvggjdjfou!xbufs!tvqqmjft!bwbjmbcmf!up! tfswf!uif!qspkfdu!gspn!fyjtujoh! !!!y! foujumfnfout!boe!sftpvsdft-!ps!bsf!ofx!ps! fyqboefe!foujumfnfout!offefe@! f*!Sftvmu!jo!b!efufsnjobujpo!cz!uif! xbtufxbufs!usfbunfou!qspwjefs!xijdi! tfswft!ps!nbz!tfswf!uif!qspkfdu!uibu!ju!ibt! !!!y! befrvbuf!dbqbdjuz!up!tfswf!uif!qspkfduÅt! qspkfdufe!efnboe!jo!beejujpo!up!uif! qspwjefsÅt!fyjtujoh!dpnnjunfout@! g*!Cf!tfswfe!cz!b!mboegjmm!xjui!tvggjdjfou! !!!y! qfsnjuufe!dbqbdjuz!up!bddpnnpebuf!uif! qspkfduÅt!tpmje!xbtuf!ejtqptbm!offet@! h*!Dpnqmz!xjui!gfefsbm-!tubuf-!boe!mpdbm! !!!y! tubuvuft!boe!sfhvmbujpot!sfmbufe!up!tpmje! xbtuf@! a-b) The proposed facility will not cause an increase in wastewater treatment requirements that would exceed current carrying capacity, nor will the project result in the need to construct new water or wastewater treatment facilities. c) The proposed project includes reuse an existing building with no increase in square footage or intensification of use. The existing facilities will be sufficient and no new storm water facilities will be necessary. d-e) The proposed project is located within an existing service area, the applicant proposes reuse of an existing building in which water has previously been supplied. As such, development of the site has been considered in the purveyors projections to serve. g*!Uif!tjuf!xjmm!cf!tfswfe!cz!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Tdbwfohfs!Dpnqboz<!tjodf!uif! bsfb!jt!dvssfoumz!tfswfe!uif!xbtuf!dpmmfdups!xjmm!cf!bcmf!up!bddpnnpebuf!tfswjdf/! /! h*!Uif!qspkfdu!xjmm!dpnqmz!xjui!bmm!gfefsbm-!tubuf!boe!mpdbm!tubuvft!sfmbufe!up!tpmje! xbtuf/!Uif!tjuf!xjmm!cf!tfswjdfe!cz!uif!tfswfe!cz!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp! Tdbwfohfs!Dpnqboz!xip!jt!tfswjoh!uif!bsfb!dbo!boe!xjmm!tfswjdf!uif!tjuf!boe! tpmje!xbtuf!xjmm!cf!efmjwfsfe!up!uif!mboegjmm!xjui!op!tjhojgjdbou!jnqbdu!up!dbqbdjuz!bu! uif!mboegjmm/! Ejtdvttjpo;!! YWJJJ/!NBOEBUPSZ!GJOEJOHT!PG!TJHOJGJDBODF! Potentially Less Than Less ThanNo Significant Significant Significant Impact Impact with Impact Mitigation Incorporation b*!Epft!uif!qspkfdu!ibwf!uif!qpufoujbm!up! efhsbef!uif!rvbmjuz!pg!uif!fowjsponfou-! tvctuboujbmmz!sfevdf!uif!ibcjubu!pg!b!gjti! ps!xjmemjgf!tqfdjft-!dbvtf!b!gjti!ps!xjmemjgf! qpqvmbujpo!up!espq!cfmpx!tfmg.tvtubjojoh! !!!y! mfwfmt-!uisfbufo!up!fmjnjobuf!b!qmbou!ps! bojnbm!dpnnvojuz-!sfevdf!uif!ovncfs!ps! sftusjdu!uif!sbohf!pg!b!sbsf!ps!foebohfsfe! qmbou!ps!bojnbm!ps!fmjnjobuf!jnqpsubou! fybnqmft!pg!uif!nbkps!qfsjpet!pg! Dbmjgpsojb!ijtupsz!ps!qsfijtupsz@! c*!Epft!uif!qspkfdu!ibwf!jnqbdut!uibu!bsf! joejwjevbmmz!mjnjufe-!cvu!dvnvmbujwfmz! dpotjefsbcmf@!)#Dvnvmbujwfmz! dpotjefsbcmf#!nfbot!uibu!uif!jodsfnfoubm! !!!y! fggfdut!pg!b!qspkfdu!bsf!dpotjefsbcmf!xifo! wjfxfe!jo!dpoofdujpo!xjui!uif!fggfdut!pg! qbtu!qspkfdut-!uif!fggfdut!pg!puifs!dvssfou! qspkfdut-!boe!uif!fggfdut!pg!qspcbcmf! gvuvsf!qspkfdut*@! d*!Epft!uif!qspkfdu!ibwf!fowjsponfoubm! fggfdut!xijdi!xjmm!dbvtf!tvctuboujbm! !!!y! bewfstf!fggfdut!po!ivnbo!cfjoht-!fjuifs! ejsfdumz!ps!joejsfdumz@! Discussion: b.d*!Uifsf!bsf!op!gjti!ps!xjmemjgf!qpqvmbujpot!jo!uif!bsfb/!!Uif!tjuf!boe!jut! tvsspvoejoh!bsf!gvmmz!efwfmpqfe/!Uif!qspkfdu!xjmm!ibwf!op!dvnvmbujwf!jnqbdut!po! uif!fowsponfou!tjodf!ju!jt!qspqptfe!xjuijo!bo!fyjtujoh!dpnnfsdjbm!bsfb!boe!jt!jo! dpnqmjbodf!boe!dpotjtufou!xjui!uif!Hfofsbm!Qmbo!boe![pojoh!Dpef/!Gvsuifs-!uif! qspkfdu!qspqptft!uif!sfvtf!pg!bo!fyjtujoh!cvjmejoh!xjui!pomz!njops!npejgjdbujpot! uibu!xjmm!opu!fyqboe!uif!cvjmejoh!ps!tvctuboujbmmz!dibohf!uif!qiztjdbm! fowjsponfou/!Uif!fowjsponfoubm!bobmztft!efnpotusbuf!uibu!uif!qspqptfe!vtf! xjmm!hfofsbuf!wfsz!gfx!ofx!wfijdmf!usjqt!boe!xjmm!opu!tvctuboujbmmz!jodsfbtf! ambient noise. The projects contribution to any cumulative impacts, therefore, would be less than cumulatively considerable. There are no substantial effects on humans to reusing this facility for a food and social service facility. MJTU!PG!BUUBDINFOUT;! B/!Wjdjojuz!Nbq! C/!Bsdijufduvsbm!Eftjho!qsfqbsfe!cz!Wbo!Nfuufs!Xjmmjbnt!Qpmmbdl!ebufe!Kvof!7-!3121! D/!Uisftipme!Dsjufsjb!Bjs!Qpmmvubout!Ubcmf!4.2.!Cbz!Bsfb!Bjs!Rvbmjuz!Nbobhfnfou! Ejtusjdu-!Nbz!3122! E/!Qibtf!2!Fowjsponfoubm!Tjuf!Bttfttnfou-!boe!Qibtf!JJ!Joepps!Bjs!Rvbmjuz! Bttfttnfou! F/!Hfofsbm!Qmbo!Eftjhobujpot!gps!qspkfdu!tjuf! G/![pojoh!Ejtusjdu!Eftjhobujpot!gps!qspkfdu!tjuf! H/!Opjtf!Bttfttnfou-!Dibsmft!Tbmufs!ebufe!Bqsjm!2-!3122! I/!Usbggjd!Tuvez!qsfqbsfe!cz!Kpio!Xjmtpo-!Tboejt!Fohjoffst-!ebufe!Gfcsvbsz!39-! 3122! Sfgfsfodft! Djuz!pg!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp/!Hfofsbm!Qmbo/!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp-!DB/! Djuz!pg!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp-!Nvojdjqbm!Dpef-!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp-!DB/!Nbz!3-! 2:89/! Djuz!pg!Tpvui!Tbo!Gsbodjtdp!Qmboojoh!Sfqpsu-!Pdupcfs!32-!3121! BCBH-!Fbsuirvblf!! GFNB-!Gmppe!Dpouspm!Nbqt! Qbsljoh!Tvswfz.!qsfqbsfe!cz!Kpio!Xjmtpo-!Tboejt!Djwjm!Fohjoffst-!)3039022*! Attachment A Vicinity Map St. Vincent de Paul Initial Study - Appendix May 2011 1 5(.1#27(.1#36(.1#27(.1#3(.1# 3(.1# 29(.1# 21(.1# 22(.4# E NFUFST )F*!FMFDUSJD 6(.22#3(.9# SLOPESLOPE CEILINGCEILING SLOPE SLOPE CEILING CEILING SLOPE CEILING SLOPE CEILING 1'-6" 2(.6# 5(.4# 22# 3(.1#3(.1# )F*!PQFOJOH 7(.3# :# 3(.405# 23# 3#2(.7# 2(.4# 3(.7# BuubdinfouD.CBBRNEUisftipmeDsjufsjb BuubdinfouE.QibtfJFTB BuubdinfouE.QibtfJJJoeppsBjsRvbmjuzBttfttnfou 100 Galli Drive, Suite 1 Novato, CA 94949 (415) 883-6203 fax (415) 883-6204 September 3, 2009 City of South San Francisco Community Development Attn. Mr. Norma Fragoso 315 Maple Avenue South San Francisco, CA 94080 Subject: Results of Transmittal of Indoor Air Quality Assessment For 938 Linden Avenue South San Francisco, California CSS Project No: 6601 Dear Ms. Fragoso: CSS Environmental Services, Inc. (CSS) is pleased to submit the following results of an Indoor Air Quality Assessment (Assessment) performed for the property at 938 Linden Avenue (the Site) in South San Francisco, CA. The current assessment was performed to investigate the findings of a Piers Environmental Services Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (March 2009) of the Site indicating that “concentrations of petroleum hydrocarbons beneath the property pose a potential risk of volatilization to indoor air.” This property is under consideration for purchase by the City of South San Francisco for commercial use. Through the conduct of this Assessment, CSS has found that hydrocarbon compounds are present in indoor air at the Site and in outdoor air in the Site vicinity, at similar concentrations. A likely source of hydrocarbon compounds is a nearby freeway, Highway 101 located about a block east of the Site. Among the hydrocarbon compounds detected, benzene was found at concentrations exceeding residential human health screening levels in both indoor and outdoor air. As indoor air concentrations of benzene are no greater than those found in outdoor air, commercial occupancy of the Site poses no greater risk to human health from benzene exposure than the background for other Site vicinity workers. The reader is referred to the body of this letter report for further details of this environmental investigation and its findings. The Site is occupied by a two story building founded on a concrete slab and perimeter foundation with no basement. The building was constructed prior to 1956 and is of concrete block construction with a flat roof. At the time of our indoor air sampling, the building was vacant and no operating HVAC system was present. To evaluate indoor air concentrations within the Site structure, CSS collected three indoor air samples over a six hour period on August 19, 2009. Samples were collected in 6-liter summa canisters pre-cleaned and evacuated by the testing laboratory, Air Toxics Limited of Folsom, California. A constant flow rate of air sampling over the period was implemented through the use of calibrated flow controllers, one dedicated to each canister. CSS’s field records of air sample collection are attached. The samples 5650-INDOOR1 and 3744-INDOOR2 were collect from rooms on the first floor in the northwest and southeast corners of the building, respectively. Sample 33779-INDOOR3 was collected in a central room on the second floor of the building. To gauge the background concentration of outdoor air in the vicinity of the building, sample 11882-OUTDOOR-BG was collected from the parking area behind the Site building near the southern corner of the Site property. An unopened summa canister sample, TRIP BLANK accompanied the collected samples and was analyzed for quality control purposes. All 6601 SSF Linden Indoor Report FINAL.doc samples were analyzed by the Air Toxics Limited laboratory for benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylenes (BTEX) by Modified EPA TO-15 SIM (Selective Ion Monitoring). Air Toxics Limited is certified by the California Department of Health Services. During the time of sample collection the Site was vacant and the building’s ventilation system was not operating. Wind conditions were calm in the morning hours, with an afternoon breeze from the northwest noted in the afternoon. The Air Toxics Limited laboratory report of the air sample analyses for BTEX are attached and summarized in Table 1. Also presented in the table are the California Human Health Screening Levels for Indoor Air (CHHSLs for Residential Land Use, California Environmental Protection Agency, January 2005) and the Environmental Screening Levels for Ambient and Indoor Air (ESLs for Residential Land Use, Regional Water Quality Control Board, San Francisco Bay Region, May 2008). Of the BTEX compounds, benzene was the only compound detected at a concentration greater than its corresponding screening level. Benzene was detected in all but the TRIP BLANK sample and at concentrations within a 33 narrow range, from 0.53 mg/M (3744-INDOOR2) to 0.61 mg/M (5650-INDOOR1 and 11882- 3 OUTDOOR-BG). The CHHSL and ESL for benzene is 0.084 mg/M. CHHSLs and ESLs are conservative screening levels, for carcinogens such as benzene, residential screening levels are based on -6 an estimated one in a million (1 x 10) cancer risk and exposure 24 hours a day, 350 days a year, for 30 years.. As the maximum concentration of benzene was detected in the outdoor background sample, its presence is reflective of a background condition and commercial occupancy of the Site poses no greater risk to human health from benzene exposure than the background for other Site vicinity workers. Sources of elevated benzene in the background include motor vehicle emissions and industrial activities. In the United States, on-road motor vehicles account for 48% of benzene emissions and 70% in Southern California’s South Coast Air Basin (EPA, National Air Quality and Emissions Trend Report 1999). The Site is located within about 700 feet of a major freeway, Highway 101, located a block east of the Site. 3 Based upon the proposed commercial use of the Site, the benzene screening level of 0.084 mg/M is not representative of the limited exposure frequency and duration of the proposed use of the Site. A Site specific risk assessment considering the specific details of Site development and use would be necessary to evaluate the specific human health risk to Site workers from background concentrations of benzene. If you have any questions or comments regarding this report, please do not hesitate to call the undersigned at (415) 883-6203. Sincerely, CSS ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, INC. Aaron N. Stessman, PE REA Principal Engineer Attachments 6601 SSF Linden Indoor Report FINAL.doc ATTACHMENT A Table, Field Records and Analytical Report 6601 SSF Linden Indoor Report FINAL.doc 8/28/2009 Mr. Aaron Stessman CSS Environmental Services Corp. 100 Galli Drive Suite 1 Novato CA 94949 Project Name: 938 Linden Project #: 6601 Workorder #: 0908482 DearMr. Aaron Stessman The following report includes the data for the above referenced project for sample(s) received on 8/21/2009 at Air Toxics Ltd. The data and associated QC analyzed by Modified TO-15 SIM are compliant with the project requirements or laboratory criteria with the exception of the deviations noted in the attached case narrative. Thank you for choosing Air Toxics Ltd. for your air analysis needs. Air Toxics Ltd. is committed to providing accurate data of the highest quality. Please feel free to contact the Project Manager: Kyle Vagadori at 916-985-1000 if you have any questions regarding the data in this report. Regards, Kyle Vagadori Project Manager 180 BLUE RAVINE ROAD, SUITE B FOLSOM, CA - 95630 (916) 985-1000 .FAX (916) 985-1020 Hours 6:30 A.M to 5:30 PST Page 1 of 18 WORK ORDER #:0908482 WorkOrderSummary Mr. Aaron StessmanMr. Aaron Stessman CLIENT:BILL TO: CSS Environmental Services Corp.CSS Environmental Services Corp. 100 Galli Drive100 Galli Drive Suite 1Suite 1 Novato, CA 94949Novato, CA 94949 415-883-6203 PHONE:P.O. # FAX: 6601 938 Linden PROJECT # 08/21/2009 DATE RECEIVED: Kyle Vagadori CONTACT: 08/28/2009 DATE COMPLETED: RECEIPTFINAL FRACTION #NAMETESTVAC./PRES.PRESSURE 01A5650-INDOOR1Modified TO-15 SIM9.0 "Hg5 psi 02A3744-INDOOR2Modified TO-15 SIM5.0 "Hg5 psi 03A33779-INDOOR3Modified TO-15 SIM10.0 "Hg5 psi 04A11882-OUTDOOR-BGModified TO-15 SIM9.0 "Hg5 psi 04AA11882-OUTDOOR-BG Lab DuplicateModified TO-15 SIM9.0 "Hg5 psi 05ATRIP BLANKModified TO-15 SIM27.0 "Hg5 psi 06ALab BlankModified TO-15 SIMNANA 06BLab BlankModified TO-15 SIMNANA 07ACCVModified TO-15 SIMNANA 07BCCVModified TO-15 SIMNANA 08ALCSModified TO-15 SIMNANA 08BLCSModified TO-15 SIMNANA 08/28/09 CERTIFIED BY:DATE: Laboratory Director Certfication numbers: CA NELAP - 02110CA, LA NELAP/LELAP- AI 30763, NJ NELAP - CA004 NY NELAP - 11291, UT NELAP - 9166389892, AZ Licensure AZ0719 Name of Accrediting Agency: NELAP/Florida Department of Health, Scope of Application: Clean Air Act, Accreditation number: E87680, Effective date: 07/01/09, Expiration date: 06/30/10 Air Toxics Ltd. certifies that the test results contained in this report meet all requirements of the NELAC standards This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval of Air Toxics Ltd. 180 BLUE RAVINE ROAD, SUITE B FOLSOM, CA - 95630 (916) 985-1000 . (800) 985-5955 . FAX (916) 985-1020 Page 2 of 18 Laboratory Services Since 1989 LABORATORY NARRATIVE Modified TO-15 SIM CSS Environmental Services Corp. Workorder# 0908482 Five6LiterSummaCanister(SIMCertified)sampleswerereceivedonAugust21,2009.Thelaboratory performedanalysisviamodifiedEPAMethodTO-15usingGC/MSintheSIMacquisitionmode. Thisworkorderwasindependentlyvalidatedpriortosubmittalusing'USEPANationalFunctionalGuidelines' asgenerallyappliedtotheanalysisofvolatileorganiccompoundsinair.Arules-based,logicdriven, independentvalidationenginewasemployedtoassesscompleteness,evaluatepass/failofrelevantproject qualitycontrolrequirementsandverificationofallquantifiedamounts. Methodmodificationstakentorunthesesamplesaresummarizedinthetablebelow.Specificproject requirementsmayover-ridetheATLmodifications. RequirementTO-15ATL Modifications ICAL %RSD acceptance criteria</=30% RSD with 2 Project specific; default criteria is </=30% RSD with 10% compounds allowed of compounds allowed out to < 40% RSD out to < 40% RSD Daily Calibration+- 30% DifferenceProject specific; default criteria is </= 30% Difference with 10% of compounds allowed out up to </=40%.; flag and narrate outliers Blank and standardsZero airNitrogen Method Detection LimitFollow 40CFR Pt.136 The MDL met all relevant requirements in Method TO-15 App. B(statistical MDL less than the LOQ). The concentration of the spiked replicate may have exceeded 10X the calculated MDL in some cases Receiving Notes There were no receiving discrepancies. Analytical Notes Therewerenoanalyticaldiscrepancies. Definition of Data Qualifying Flags Eightqualifiersmayhavebeenusedonthedataanalysissheetsandindicatesasfollows: B-Compoundpresentinlaboratoryblankgreaterthanreportinglimit(backgroundsubtractionnot performed). J-Estimatedvalue. E-Exceedsinstrumentcalibrationrange. S-Saturatedpeak. Q-Exceedsqualitycontrollimits. U-Compoundanalyzedforbutnotdetectedabovethereportinglimit. Page 3 of 18 Laboratory Services Since 1989 UJ-Non-detectedcompoundassociatedwithlowbiasintheCCV N-Theidentificationisbasedonpresumptiveevidence. Fileextensionsmayhavebeenusedonthedataanalysissheetsandindicates asfollows: a-Filewasrequantified b-Filewasquantifiedbyasecondcolumnanddetector r1-Filewasrequantifiedforthepurposeofreissue Page 4 of 18 Summary of Detected Compounds MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM Client Sample ID: 5650-INDOOR1 Lab ID#: 0908482-01A AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.0960.190.300.61 Benzene 0.0380.320.141.2 Toluene 0.0380.0390.160.17 Ethyl Benzene 0.0760.120.330.54 m,p-Xylene 0.0380.0540.160.23 o-Xylene Client Sample ID: 3744-INDOOR2 Lab ID#: 0908482-02A AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.0800.170.260.53 Benzene 0.0320.290.121.1 Toluene 0.0320.0390.140.17 Ethyl Benzene 0.0640.130.280.56 m,p-Xylene 0.0320.0610.140.26 o-Xylene Client Sample ID: 33779-INDOOR3 Lab ID#: 0908482-03A AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) Benzene0.100.180.320.56 Toluene0.0400.290.151.1 m,p-Xylene0.0800.100.350.44 o-Xylene0.0400.0400.170.18 Client Sample ID: 11882-OUTDOOR-BG Lab ID#: 0908482-04A AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.0960.190.300.61 Benzene 0.0380.270.141.0 Toluene Client Sample ID: 11882-OUTDOOR-BG Lab Duplicate Lab ID#: 0908482-04AA Page 5 of 18 Summary of Detected Compounds MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM Client Sample ID: 11882-OUTDOOR-BG Lab Duplicate Lab ID#: 0908482-04AA AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.0960.190.300.60 Benzene 0.0380.270.141.0 Toluene Client Sample ID: TRIP BLANK Lab ID#: 0908482-05A No Detections Were Found. Page 6 of 18 Client Sample ID: 5650-INDOOR1 Lab ID#: 0908482-01A MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082419Date of Collection: 8/19/09 2:50:00 PM File Name: 1.91Date of Analysis: 8/24/09 07:10 PM Dil. Factor: AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.0960.190.300.61 Benzene 0.0380.320.141.2 Toluene 0.0380.0390.160.17 Ethyl Benzene 0.0760.120.330.54 m,p-Xylene 0.0380.0540.160.23 o-Xylene Container Type: 6 Liter Summa Canister (SIM Certified) Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10470-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 9770-130 Toluene-d8 9770-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 7 of 18 Client Sample ID: 3744-INDOOR2 Lab ID#: 0908482-02A MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082421Date of Collection: 8/19/09 2:52:00 PM File Name: 1.61Date of Analysis: 8/24/09 08:30 PM Dil. Factor: AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.0800.170.260.53 Benzene 0.0320.290.121.1 Toluene 0.0320.0390.140.17 Ethyl Benzene 0.0640.130.280.56 m,p-Xylene 0.0320.0610.140.26 o-Xylene Container Type: 6 Liter Summa Canister (SIM Certified) Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10470-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 9670-130 Toluene-d8 10470-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 8 of 18 Client Sample ID: 33779-INDOOR3 Lab ID#: 0908482-03A MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082512Date of Collection: 8/19/09 2:52:00 PM File Name: 2.01Date of Analysis: 8/25/09 06:19 PM Dil. Factor: AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.100.180.320.56 Benzene 0.0400.290.151.1 Toluene 0.040Not Detected0.17Not Detected Ethyl Benzene 0.0800.100.350.44 m,p-Xylene 0.0400.0400.170.18 o-Xylene Container Type: 6 Liter Summa Canister (SIM Certified) Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10470-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 9670-130 Toluene-d8 10070-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 9 of 18 Client Sample ID: 11882-OUTDOOR-BG Lab ID#: 0908482-04A MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082513Date of Collection: 8/19/09 2:55:00 PM File Name: 1.91Date of Analysis: 8/25/09 06:57 PM Dil. Factor: AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.0960.190.300.61 Benzene 0.0380.270.141.0 Toluene 0.038Not Detected0.16Not Detected Ethyl Benzene 0.076Not Detected0.33Not Detected m,p-Xylene 0.038Not Detected0.16Not Detected o-Xylene Container Type: 6 Liter Summa Canister (SIM Certified) Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10570-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 9570-130 Toluene-d8 9770-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 10 of 18 Client Sample ID: 11882-OUTDOOR-BG Lab Duplicate Lab ID#: 0908482-04AA MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082514Date of Collection: 8/19/09 2:55:00 PM File Name: 1.91Date of Analysis: 8/25/09 07:36 PM Dil. Factor: AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.0960.190.300.60 Benzene 0.0380.270.141.0 Toluene 0.038Not Detected0.16Not Detected Ethyl Benzene 0.076Not Detected0.33Not Detected m,p-Xylene 0.038Not Detected0.16Not Detected o-Xylene Container Type: 6 Liter Summa Canister (SIM Certified) Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10670-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 9470-130 Toluene-d8 9270-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 11 of 18 Client Sample ID: TRIP BLANK Lab ID#: 0908482-05A MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082516Date of Collection: 8/19/09 2:55:00 PM File Name: 1.00Date of Analysis: 8/25/09 09:58 PM Dil. Factor: AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.050Not Detected0.16Not Detected Benzene 0.020Not Detected0.075Not Detected Toluene 0.020Not Detected0.087Not Detected Ethyl Benzene 0.040Not Detected0.17Not Detected m,p-Xylene 0.020Not Detected0.087Not Detected o-Xylene Container Type: 6 Liter Summa Canister (SIM Certified) Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10670-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 9470-130 Toluene-d8 9770-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 12 of 18 Client Sample ID: Lab Blank Lab ID#: 0908482-06A MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082405Date of Collection: NA File Name: 1.00Date of Analysis: 8/24/09 08:11 AM Dil. Factor: AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.050Not Detected0.16Not Detected Benzene 0.020Not Detected0.075Not Detected Toluene 0.020Not Detected0.087Not Detected Ethyl Benzene 0.040Not Detected0.17Not Detected m,p-Xylene 0.020Not Detected0.087Not Detected o-Xylene Container Type: NA - Not Applicable Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10670-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 9870-130 Toluene-d8 9570-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 13 of 18 Client Sample ID: Lab Blank Lab ID#: 0908482-06B MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082505Date of Collection: NA File Name: 1.00Date of Analysis: 8/25/09 12:42 PM Dil. Factor: AmountRpt. LimitAmount Rpt. Limit Compound(ppbv)(ppbv)(ug/m3)(ug/m3) 0.050Not Detected0.16Not Detected Benzene 0.020Not Detected0.075Not Detected Toluene 0.020Not Detected0.087Not Detected Ethyl Benzene 0.040Not Detected0.17Not Detected m,p-Xylene 0.020Not Detected0.087Not Detected o-Xylene Container Type: NA - Not Applicable Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10670-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 9670-130 Toluene-d8 9870-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 14 of 18 Client Sample ID: CCV Lab ID#: 0908482-07A MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082402Date of Collection: NA File Name: 1.00Date of Analysis: 8/24/09 06:14 AM Dil. Factor: Compound%Recovery 101 Benzene 97 Toluene 99 Ethyl Benzene 97 m,p-Xylene 96 o-Xylene Container Type: NA - Not Applicable Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10470-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 10470-130 Toluene-d8 9970-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 15 of 18 Client Sample ID: CCV Lab ID#: 0908482-07B MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082502Date of Collection: NA File Name: 1.00Date of Analysis: 8/25/09 10:24 AM Dil. Factor: Compound%Recovery 98 Benzene 94 Toluene 95 Ethyl Benzene 94 m,p-Xylene 94 o-Xylene Container Type: NA - Not Applicable Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10270-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 10270-130 Toluene-d8 10470-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 16 of 18 Client Sample ID: LCS Lab ID#: 0908482-08A MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082403Date of Collection: NA File Name: 1.00Date of Analysis: 8/24/09 06:53 AM Dil. Factor: Compound%Recovery 113 Benzene 113 Toluene 108 Ethyl Benzene 106 m,p-Xylene 106 o-Xylene Container Type: NA - Not Applicable Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10570-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 10370-130 Toluene-d8 9970-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 17 of 18 Client Sample ID: LCS Lab ID#: 0908482-08B MODIFIED EPA METHOD TO-15 GC/MS SIM a082503Date of Collection: NA File Name: 1.00Date of Analysis: 8/25/09 11:20 AM Dil. Factor: Compound%Recovery 113 Benzene 113 Toluene 107 Ethyl Benzene 106 m,p-Xylene 106 o-Xylene Container Type: NA - Not Applicable Method Surrogates%RecoveryLimits 10570-130 1,2-Dichloroethane-d4 10170-130 Toluene-d8 10470-130 4-Bromofluorobenzene Page 18 of 18 ATTACHMENT B Limitations and Uncertainty LIMITATIONS AND UNCERTANITY This report was prepared by CSS Environmental Services, Inc. in general accordance with the accepted principals and standards of practice of consultants providing similar services at the time the project was conducted and within the scope of service outlined in our written proposal and/or verbal communication. It should be recognized that the definition and evaluation of environmental conditions, and information provided by others either written or verbal is a difficult and inexact science. Judgments leading to conclusions and recommendations generally are made with an incomplete knowledge of the conditions present. Any opinions presented apply to site conditions existing at the time of the inspection and/or document review and those reasonably foreseeable; they cannot necessarily apply to site changes made of which the inspector/reviewer could not observe and has not had the opportunity to evaluate. Changes in the conditions of the subject property can occur with time, because of the natural process or the works of man. It is further possible that variations and/or changes in the site conditions could exist beyond the points explored for this investigation. Also, changes in environmental quality could occur sometime in the future do to variations in operating conditions, rainfall, temperature or other factors. Changes in applicable environmental, engineering and construction standards and practices can also occur as the result of legislation or from the broadening of knowledge. Accordingly, the data and documents presented in the scope of work may be invalidated, wholly or in part, by changes beyond the control of CSS Environmental Services, Inc. If the client wishes to reduce uncertainty beyond the level associated with the scope of work, CSS Environmental Services, Inc. should be notified for additional consultation. The discussion and recommendations presented in this report are based on information which may include: 1) information and data provided by third party consultants, 2) the testing performed at, or samples collected from, the site, 3) the observations of field personnel, 4) the results of laboratory analyses, 5) reports by others, and 6) interpretations of federal, state, and local regulations and/or ordinances. Any conclusions presented are based on the assumption that conditions do not deviate from those observed during the assessment. It is understood that other conditions may exist at the site that could not be identified from the limited information discovered within the scope of the assessment. The comments and recommendations should not be construed as a guarantee that all safety, health, or environmental hazards that exist at the subject site are identified in this report. 6601 SSF Linden Indoor Report FINAL.doc Buubdinfou!F! Hfofsbm!Qmbo!Mboe!Vtf!Eftjhobujpo BuubdinfouH ENA NVIRONMENTAL OISE SSESSMENT S.VPFSSFR TINCENT DE AULOOD ERVICES AND UPPORT ACILITYELOCATION SSF,CA OUTH ANRANCISCO 12 May 2011 Prepared for: Linda Ajello City of South San Francisco 315 Maple Avenue South San Francisco, CA 94080 Email: [email protected] Prepared by: Randy D. Waldeck, P.E., Principal Consultant Charles M. Salter Associates, Inc. 130 Sutter Street, Suite 500 San Francisco, CA 94104 CSA Project No. 11-0029 Environmental Noise Assessment for St. Vincent de Paul Food Services & Support Facility Relocation 12 May 2011 CSA Project No. 11-0029 Page 2 I NTRODUCTION This report is an assessment of environmental noise associated with the proposed relocation of the St. Vincent de Paul (SVDP) Food Services and Support Facility. The facility provides food services, clean clothing, showers, and limited laundry facilities to those in need. The facility is currently located at 344 Grand Avenue and proposes to relocate to 938 Linden Avenue; both sites are in South San Francisco. The properties to the east and west of the project site consist of commercial land uses; the property south of (behind) the project site is zoned residential. There is concern that food service activities and mechanical equipment at the new facility will generate noise impacts at the neighboring properties. We have conducted an environmental noise assessment to determine whether noise from the new facility will exceed the relevant City standards. ES XECUTIVE UMMARY  The current noise level at the adjacent properties is considered “Acceptable” per the City’s General Plan.  Noise from SVDP activity (patrons, vehicle parking, and kitchen exhaust fans) may increase the noise level at the surrounding properties by 1 to 2 dBA, a difference that is not considered noticeable.  The noise level at the adjacent properties will still be within the “Acceptable” limits established by the City’s General Plan. Environmental Noise Assessment for St. Vincent de Paul Food Services & Support Facility Relocation 12 May 2011 CSA Project No. 11-0029 Page 3 AC COUSTICAL RITERIA General Plan We have reviewed the City of South San Francisco’s 1999 General Plan and determined that the following noise goals are applicable to this project:  Policy 9-G-1 : Protect public health and welfare by eliminating or minimizing the effects of existing noise problems, and by preventing increased noise levels in the future.  Policy 9-I-7 : Require the control of noise at source through site design, building design, landscaping, hours of operation, and other techniques, for new developments deemed to be noise generators. The General Plan also includes a table (Table 9.2-1) summarizing noise and land-use criteria to determine site acceptability. This table is reprinted below: T1:SSFNAL-UCS ABLE OUTHANRANCISCO OISE NDANDSEOMPATIBILITY TANDARDS (CNEL) Residential Commercial Category Less than 65 dBA Less than 70 dBA A Between 65 and 70 dBA Between 70 and 80 dBA B Greater than 70 dBA Greater than 80 dBA C ASatisfactory: No special insulation requirements Development requires analysis of noise reduction B requirements and noise insulation as needed CDevelopment should not be undertaken Environmental Noise Assessment for St. Vincent de Paul Food Services & Support Facility Relocation 12 May 2011 CSA Project No. 11-0029 Page 4 Municipal Code Noise Ordinance We have reviewed Chapter 8.32 of the South San Francisco Municipal Code and found the following ordinances applicable to the project:  8.32.030 Maximum Permissible Sound Levels: (a) It is unlawful for any person to operate or cause to be operated any source of sound at any location within the city or allow the creation of any noise on property owned, leased, occupied or otherwise controlled by such person, which causes the noise level when measured on any other property to exceed: (1) The noise level standard for that land use as specified in Table 8.32.030 [Table 2 in o this report] for a cumulative period of more than thirty minutes in any hour; (2) The noise level standard plus five dB for a cumulative period of more than fifteen o minutes in any hour; (3) The noise level standard plus ten dB for a cumulative period of more than five o minutes in any hour; (4) The noise level standard plus fifteen dB for a cumulative period of more than one o minute in any hour; or (5) The noise level standard or the maximum measured ambient level, plus twenty dB for o any period of time. T2:SSFNOPLS ABLE OUTHANRANCISCO OISE RDINANCE ROPERTYINETANDARDS Noise Level Land Use Category Time Period (dBA) 10 p.m. to 7 a.m. R-3 and D-C zones or any multiple-family 55 residential or mixed residential/commercial in any specific plan district 60 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. 10 p.m. to 7 a.m. C-1, P-C, Gateway and Oyster Point Marina 60 specific plan districts or any commercial use in any specific plan district 65 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. Although not stated explicitly, the Municipal Code noise standards are used to address noise from fixed, permanent sources such as mechanical equipment. Environmental Noise Assessment for St. Vincent de Paul Food Services & Support Facility Relocation 12 May 2011 CSA Project No. 11-0029 Page 5 ENE XISTING OISE NVIRONMENT To quantify the existing noise environment at the project site, we conducted two continuous 48- hour noise measurements (i.e., LT 1 and 2) from 22 February to 24 February 2011. Table 3 shows a summary of the measured data; Figure 1 shows the measurement locations. The dominant noise sources are vehicular traffic along Linden Avenue and occasional aircraft flyovers from San Francisco International Airport (typically departures). Minor noise sources include traffic on US-101 and general city noise. T3:NMD ABLEOISE EASUREMENTATA Monitor Location CNEL At the front gate of project site, approximately 70 feet from the Linden LT 1 64 dBA Avenue centerline. 8 feet above grade. At the southwest corner of the project site, approximately 225 feet from the LT 2 60 dBA Linden Avenue centerline. 8 feet above grade. NS OISE OURCES This section identifies and discusses potential noise sources from the project. In our discussions with SVDP staff, City planning staff, and a review of the Planning documents, we have identified the following noise sources:  Food deliveries  Staff/volunteers prepping and providing food  Patrons picking up food  Vehicle parking  Mechanical equipment (e.g., kitchen exhaust fan) We have addressed these noise sources in the following sections. Food Deliveries Based on our conversation with SVDP staff member Lisa Collins, food deliveries occur around 7:00 or 8:00 a.m. each morning via her personal minivan. About once per month, a medium- sized delivery truck will deliver food from Second Harvest or Costco. Environmental Noise Assessment for St. Vincent de Paul Food Services & Support Facility Relocation 12 May 2011 CSA Project No. 11-0029 Page 6 Staff, Volunteers, and Patrons Each weekday, staff arrive to the facility at around 8:00 a.m. and volunteers begin arriving at 8:30 a.m. Patrons begin lining up at around 9:00 a.m. and the facility is open from 10:00 a.m. to noon. On Saturdays, the facility is open from 11:00 a.m. until noon. Vehicle Parking Per the Sandis parking survey memo dated 28 February 2011; approximately 13 to 16 cars arrive and depart from the facility during weekdays. The majority of people who visit the site (whether patrons or volunteers) arrive on foot. Mechanical Equipment We understand that air conditioning is not planned for the facility, but there will be kitchen exhaust fans. The kitchen exhaust fans will either be located on top of the roof or in the roof- ceiling plenum. For either mounting location, the kitchen exhaust discharge will be a source of noise. C ALCULATIONS We have calculated the expected noise level from the noise sources described in the previous section. Our calculations are based upon the following:  Measurements of patron noise conducted at the existing SVDP facility on 29 March 2011  Parking noise based upon Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) Traffic Noise Model  The new facility will operate on the same schedule as the existing facility  The kitchen exhaust fans will operate from 7:00 a.m. until noon each day, the fan or the discharge of the fan will be no closer than ten feet to any property line; the fans will operate at the maximum noise level allowed by the City’s noise ordinance When patrons were waiting for the kitchen to open and during food service, we measured a noise level of 65 to 70 dBA at a distance of 15 feet from the patrons at the existing facility. This noise occurred from 9:15 a.m. to 10:15 a.m. as the patrons waited outside for the SVDP facility to open. The staff and volunteers did not contribute significantly to the noise environment as their work occurred inside of the facility. Table 4 summarizes our calculation results. Environmental Noise Assessment for St. Vincent de Paul Food Services & Support Facility Relocation 12 May 2011 CSA Project No. 11-0029 Page 7 T4:CSVDPFSN,CNEL(dBA) ABLEALCULATEDOOD ERVICE OISE IN Project Existing Cars Kitchen Location Existing Patron Total plusIncrease Parking Exhaust Project LT 1: Front Gate, West 64 57 31 58 61 66 2 Property Line LT 2: Southwest Corner 60 43 31 44 47 61 1 of Project Site A NALYSIS The project is expected to increase CNEL noise levels by 1 to 2 dBA, primarily due to noise from the kitchen exhaust fans. An increase in noise level of less than 3 dBA is generally not noticeable. The noise level will still be considered “Acceptable” per the City’s General Plan at the adjacent properties. Our calculations assumed that the noise level from the kitchen exhaust fans will be 65 dBA at the 1 west and east property lines. If the noise level from the kitchen exhaust fans was only 60 dBA at the west and east property lines, then the increase in noise level would be 1 dBA or less. C ONCLUSION Noise from the project will increase the overall 24-hour CNEL noise level by 1 to 2 dBA, assuming “worst-case” kitchen exhaust fan noise. This increase is not expected to be noticeable. The noise level at the adjacent properties will still be considered “Acceptable” per the City’s land-use guidelines. 1 This corresponds to a sound power level (PWL) of 82 dBA; PWL levels are typically provided by mechanical equipment manufacturers. BuubdinfouI