Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-19-07 PC e-packet CITY OF SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO REGULAR MEETING OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING 33 ARROYO DRIVE April 19, 2007 7:30 PM WELCOME If this is the first time you have been to a Commission meeting, perhaps you'd like to know a little about our procedure. Under Oral Communications, at the beginning of the meeting, persons wishing to speak on any subject not on the Agenda will have 3 minutes to discuss their item. The Clerk will read the name and type of application to be heard in the order in which it appears on the Agenda. A staff person will then explain the proposal. The first person allowed to speak will be the applicant, followed by persons in favor of the application. Then persons who oppose the project or who wish to ask questions will have their turn. If you wish to speak, please fill out a card (which is available near the entrance door) and give it, as soon as possible, to the Clerk at the front of the room. When it is your turn, she will announce your name for the record. The Commission has adopted a policy that applicants and their representatives have a maximum time limit of 20 minutes to make a presentation on their project. Non-applicants may speak a maximum of 3 minutes on any case. Questions from Commissioners to applicants or non-applicants may be answered by using additional time. When the Commission is not in session, we'll be pleased to answer your questions if you will go to the Planning Division, City Hall, 315 Maple Avenue or telephone (650) 877-8535 or bye-mail at web- [email protected]. John Prouty Chairperson Judith Honan Commissioner Marc C. Teglia Commissioner Wallace M. Moore Commissioner Mary Giusti Vice-Chairperson Eugene Sim Commissioner William Zemke Commissioner Susy Kalkin, Chief Planner Secretary to the Planning Commission Steve Carlson Michael Lappen Senior Planner Senior Planner Gerry Beaudin Associate Planner Chadrick Smalley Associate Planner Bertha Aguilar Clerk Please Turn Cellular Phones And Paaers Off. Individuals with disabilities who require auxiliary aids or services to attend and participate in this meeting should contact the ADA Coordinator at (650) 829-3800, five working days before the meeting. PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING 33 ARROYO DRIVE April 19, 2007 Time 7:30 P.M. CALL TO ORDER / PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ROLL CALL / CHAIR COMMENTS AGENDA REVIEW ORAL COMMUNICATIONS CONSENT CALENDAR 1. Approval of Regular Meeting minutes of February 15, 2007. PUBLIC HEARING 2. Kaiser Medical Office - Time Extension Kaiser/Owner Kaiser/Applicant 230 Oyster Point Blvd. PCA06-0008: UP04-0031, PM04-0003, DR04-0077, & TDM04-0004 (Continue from April 5, 2007) Time Extension for a Use Permit and Design Review to allow the construction of a single-story medical office building on Oyster Point Boulevard in the Planned Commercial (P-C-L) Zoning District in accordance with SSFMC Chapters 20.24 and 20.81. ADMINISTRATIVE BUSINESS 3. 6 MONTH REVIEW KC & L Seafood, Inc. Kin Man "Timmy" Kan - Owner Fumio Suda, Architect - Applicant 390 Swift Ave. #10 P05-0041: UP05-0013 6 Month Review - Use Permit to allow a seafood processing plant to operate in a 5,512 sq. ft. tenant space in the Planned Industrial (P-I) Zoning District in accordance with SSFMC Chapters 20.32 and 20.81 4. 6 MONTH REVIEW First Baptist Church Playground First Baptist Church of SSF/Owner & Applicant 600 Grand Avenue P06-0022: UP06-0007, DR06-0019 6 Month Review - Use Permit and Design Review to allow the relocation of a playground for a private school, including a 4.5 foot tall fence and outdoor play structure, which encroaches into both the public right-of-way and the minimum required 15 foot front setback on a site located at 600 Grand Avenue in the R-3-L Multi-Family Residential Zone District in accordance with SSFMC Chapters 20.20, 20.73, 20.82 & 20.85. Planning Commission Agenda - Cont'd Page 3 of 3 ~ April 19, 2007 I 5. STUDY SESSION Genentech B50 GENENTECH INC/ owner & applicant 680 Forbes Blvd P06-0136: UP06-0032 & DR06-0102 Building 50 - Use Permit application to allow Genentech to demolish an existing surface parking lot adjacent to Building 51 (642 Forbes Boulevard) and construct a new 165,340-square-foot R&D/Manufacturing/Lab/Office Building located at 680 Forbes Boulevard on the Lower Campus within the Genentech R&D Overlay District per SSFMC Chapters 20.39, 20.40 & 20.81 6. STUDY SESSION SSF Conference Center The City of SSF/Owner SSF Conference Center/Applicant 255 S Airport Blvd P07-0030: UPM07-0003 & DR07-0019 Use Permit Modification to expand the existing Conference Center by constructing a 4,100 sf meeting room addition in the Planned Commercial (P-C) Zone District in accordance with SSFMC Chapters 20.81 & 20.24. ITEMS FROM STAFF ITEMS FROM COMMISSION ITEMS FROM THE PUBLIC ADJOURNMENT NEXT MEETING: Regular Meeting May 3, 2007, Municipal Services Building, 33 Arroyo Drive, South San Francisco, CA. SK/bla Staff Reports can now be accessed online at: htlp:/Iwww.ssf.netldepts/comms/plannina/aaenda minutes.asp or via http://weblink.ssf.net s:\Agev\'Gi~.s\Pl~v\'v\"v\'g GoV\;CV\;C,.s.s'Ov\'\::200T\04-~3-0T RPG Agev\'Gi~.Gioc Planning Commission Staff Report DATE: April 19, 2007 TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Time Extension of: 1. Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. 2. Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts. 3. Design Review of a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. Project Location: 230 Oyster Point Boulevard (APN 015-023-390) in the Planned Commercial (P-C) Zone District. Codes: SSFMC Chapters 20.24, 20.81, 20.85 & 20.120. Mitigated Negative Declaration: Previously adopted by the Planning Commission on January 3, 2002. Owner & Applicant: Kaiser Permanante Case Nos.: PCA06-0008 [Original Case Nos.: P04-0131 (UP04-0031, DR04-0077, PM04-0003 & TDM04-0004)] RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission review and approve a One Y ear- Time Extension of a 1) Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces; 2) Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts; and 3) Design Review of a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. BACKGROUND: The Planning Commission reviewed the applicant's time extension request at their meeting of March 15, 2007 and continued the matter so that the applicant could examine providing a Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: Time Extension of: P04-0 131 230 Oyster Point Boulevard April 19, 2007 Page 2 of 2 landscape buffer between the curb and the public sidewalk. The applicant has prepared a streets cape plan that incorporates a landscape buffer. To facilitate the review by the Commission both the proposed and the original approved streetscape plans are attached. The Planning Commission should review the proposed plans and determine whether the proposed changes are in substantial conformance with the original approved plans and determine if the time extension should be approved. RECOMMENDATION: The time extension request appears reasonable and the applicant has indicated their intent to start construction sometime later this year. City Staff supports the granting of the time extension and recommends that the Planning Commission approve the One-Year Time Extension for a 1) Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at- grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces, 2) Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts; and 3) Design Review of a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. Attachments: Planning Commission Applicant's Letter Staff Report January 6,2005 February 15,2007 March 15,2007 Approved Landscape and Streetscape Plan Revised Streetscape Plan "" .---"0'-' '0 \ ..2,.; Q. r/ \..!..c-;r "'" ~ !~)",.......;',: \/, "', ~ -' ~ \I "- j .~.. " :......JG;" ',,-,.'- \...... ,-- ..:....) .-. ~1T~ KAISER PERMANENTE@ Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. December 19, 2006 City of South San Francisco Economic & Community Development Department Planning Division 315 Maple Avenue South San Francisco, CA Re: Use Permit - UP04-0031 230 Oyster Point Request for Extension Kaiser Permanente requests that the City of South San Francisco extend our Use Permit: UP04- 0031 for a Cancer Treatment Center at 230 Oyster Point for one year. To date Kaiser Permanente has been unable to proceed with the construction of this facility due to operational restraints. We now anticipate construction of this facility can begin late in 2007. We would appreciate the Planning Department's consideration and processing of an extension for the next available Planning Commission hearing. S incerel y ~71J 7- /)1 l--t-vJ.;j2i1.M-l M. F. Murphey (1 Sr. Project Manager National Facilities Services, Capital Projects Group 1200 EI Camino Real, CPG Trailer South San Francisco, CA 94080 Tel: (650) 742-2111 Fax: (650) 742-2115 Planning Commission Staff Report DATE: January 6, 2005 TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: 1. Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 SF medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. 2. Tentative Parcel Map to split the existing 3.54-acre lot into two lots with areas of 1.64 acres and 1.9 acres. 3. Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan in conjunction with the Variance to reduce traffic impacts. 4. Design Review of a one-story 19,200 SF medical services treatment facility building with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. Project Location: 3.54 acre site situated at 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard (APN 015-023-010) in the Planned Commercial (P-C) Zone District. SSFMC Chapters: 20.79 and 20.85. Owner: Malcolm Building, LLC Applicant: Hunter Storm, LLC (agent for Kaiser). Case No.: P04-0 131 (UP04-0031, DR04-00n & PM04-0003) Mitigated Negative Declaration certified by the Planning Commission on January 3, 2002. RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission approve 1) Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 SF medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces, 2) Tentative Parcel Map to split the existing 3.54-acre lot into two lots with areas of 1.64 acres and 1.9 acres, 3) Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan in conjunction with the Variance to reduce traffic impacts, and 4) Design Review of a one-story 19,200 SF medical services treatment facility building with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: The Planning Commission previously reviewed the proposed plans for the small medical treatment facility at the Study Session of December 2,2004. The Commission's review focused Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: P04-0131 - 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard January 6, 2005 Page 2 of 9 on the design compatibility of the development. The Commission suggested that the open railing be replaced with a low rise opaque wall to screen views of the automobiles in the parking lot. The Commission also supported the provision of adequate parking but wanted more infonnation regarding patient use ofUCSF treatment facilities that Kaiser patients now use. The applicant has revised the plans to incorporate the Planning Commission's suggestions. The ingress driveway has been relocated farther east and modified to restrict cars from exiting onto Oyster Point Boulevard. The project includes demolition of the remaining building and site improvements, and the construction of a one-story 19,200 SF medical treatment building, with open at-grade parking for as many as 85 parking spaces. The project includes new landscaping and an entry plaza area sheltered from Oyster Point Boulevard noise and westerly winds. A Parcel Map is proposed to split the site into two lots comprised of 1.64 acres (230 Oyster Point Boulevard) and 1.9 acres (200 Oyster Point Boulevard). The proposed project would be situated on the easterly lot of 1.64 acres. The property owner has not proposed a project for the proposed westerly lot. The easterly lot would be conveyed to Kaiser. The proposed project, including the Parcel Map, would supercede the office development previously approved by the Planning Commission. PROJECT SIDTABILITY Medical Service Use The project site's General Plan land use designation is Business Commercial, which allows medical service uses. The medical service project is consistent with several General Plan goals and policies that support expansion of desirable and compatible uses in the Oyster Point Boulevard corridor. The proposed medical treatment facility use is consistent with the plan objectives. A key principle underlying the creation of the Economic Element and especially pertinent to this development proposal is the need for the City to undertake land use decisions that provide for the City's long tenn economic sustainability and diversification, fiscal stability, and optimization of infrastructure capacities. The proposed medical service development is in keeping with these principles. The site is surrounded by other R&D and related uses and is in an area that is set aside for such uses and that should be developed. The proposed medical service project also fulfills two specific Land Use Policies: Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: P04-0 131 - 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard January 6, 2005 Page 3 of9 Policy LU-I . Developments planned for the East of 101 Area shall be evaluated based on their merits and net benefits they provide to the East of 101 Area and the City of South San Francisco. . New development should enhance the net revenues to the City by providing increased sales tax, property tax and other fees. . New development should create quality jobs for South San Francisco residents. Policy LU-2 New East of 101 Area developments should generally meet the following criteria: . New land uses should enhance property values, thereby increasing property tax revenues in the East of 101 Area. . New development should not have a net negative fiscal impact on the City, and should pay for all on~going City services it requires through taxes and fees. This is particularly important for projects with low property improvement values, such as storage yards and parking lots. . New land uses that are similar to or compatible with surrounding development are encouraged. New uses should not be detrimental to the overall economic viability of the East of 101 Area. . New development approvals should reflect market conditions . New development should visually enhance and contribute to the aesthetic character of the East of 101 Area. . The trip generation of new lands uses should be within the projections of the Area Plan. . The demand for sewage treatment for each individual development should remain within the projections of the Area Plan. The revised proposed project complies with the East of 101 Area Plan Design Guidelines especially the following policies: Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: P04-0131 - 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard January 6, 2005 Page 4 of9 . DE-4 Developments should incorporate the natural site topography rather than creating flat development pads. . DE-IS Developments should de-emphasize the visual prominence of parking areas by placing parking areas away from views from the public streets. . DE-20 Developments should minimize circulation spaces by using shared driveway access between adjacent properties. The development incorporates the natural site topography, to a large extent. A major portion of the parking is behind the building and that which would otherwise be visible from the street will be screened from views with a low rise opaque wall. The project includes the use of a shared access. In all other respects, the proposed medical service project generally meets all of the criteria. Vacant Parcel The proposed lot split creating a vacant remainder parcel complies with the General Plan. Neither the General Plan nor City ordinances preclude a lot split without an associated development plan. The Commission has expressed concern over whether it is desirable to leave a significant portion of a site vacant for an unknown periqd of time and for an unknown development. The remaining vacant lot is not only less valuable, but may be less suitable for R&D development, foreclosing greater development options and a future development that is compatible with the adjacent land uses. The applicant has submitted site plan and data to support the feasibility of development of as much as a two-story 50,000 SF R&D building with open at-grade parking. DESIGN COMP ATIBLITTY The Planning Commission has taken extraordinary steps to engage the adjacent land owners at 180 Oyster Point Boulevard and 200-230 Oyster Point Boulevard to propose developments that were compatible in all respects - building set backs, common shared entry driveway, building design, public amenities and landscape plans. Because the proposed developments demonstrate that the projects share common design vocabulary and all of the features desired by the Planning Commissioners, City staff s understanding is that the Planning Commissioners are willing to allow the current proposed development to proceed separately. To maintain the continuity of the overall site planning, a condition of approval has been added that requires the design of the vacant parcel to adhere to the same development standards including minimum building height and size, minimum build-to lines (setbacks), landscape plan, common shared entry, public amenities and exterior building finishes including colors and materials. Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: P04-0 131 - 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard January 6, 2005 Page 5 of9 ZONING COMPLIANCE Medical service uses are currently allowed uses in a Planned Commercial (P-C) Zone District. Medical service uses that operate on a 24-hour basis are allowed subject to an approved Use Permit by the City's Planning Commission [SSFMC Sections 20.24.040]. The building generally complies with current City development standards as displayed in the following table: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS Site Area: Total 3.54 acres [154,202 SF] Lot A 1.64 acres [Project Site - 230 Oyster Point Boulevard] Lot B 1.9 acres [Vacant Lot - 200 Oyster Point Boulevard] Project Site Data Floor Area: 19,200 SF Floor Area Ratio: Maximum: 0.5 to 1.0 Lot Coverage Maximum: 60% Landscaping Minimum: Automobile Parking Minimum: Setbacks Minimum Proposed Front 20 FT 20 FT Side 6 FT 6-100 FT Rear 6 FT 10 FT Notes: 1. 6 foot landscaped side setback required of parking lots. 2. Parking based on a rate of 1 stall per 300 SF. Proposed: 0.27 Proposed: 27% 10% Proposed: 27% 64 Proposed: 85 The proposed parking exceeds the minimum requirements set forth in SSFMC Chapter 20.74 by 21 parking spaces. The Planning Commission may wish to consider reducing the parking closer to the minimum requirement of 64 spaces, and the area converted to a larger on-site entry amenity area and patient drop-off. The facility will be staffed by an estimated 36 employees, will accommodate up to 24 patients per hour and have up to 10 vendors and other visitors - a total of 70 persons on-site at any time except during the middle of the day when patients are not likely to be admitted. By way of Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: P04-0 131 - 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard January 6, 2005 Page 60f9 comparison, Kaiser's other similar facilities have the following parking ratios: FACILITY FLOOR AREA PARKING RATIO SSF (4 Vaults) 19,200 SF Santa Clara (3 Vaults) 17,300 SF Rancho Cordova (2 Vaults) 10,300 SF 3.6/1,000 SF 4.4/1,000 SF 5.0/1,000 SF Kaiser representatives indicate that as the size of the facility increases the number of patients increases proportionately, but the staffing increases at a slower rate. The SSF facility would have the lowest parking ratio of the three facilities. At the Commission meeting City staffhas requested that the applicant provide additional data regarding staffing and patient census at the other two facilities and the adequacy of parking supply and demand. Because the average lot depth is less than 150 feet, the rear setback need only be 6 feet in depth. TRANSPORTATION DEMAND MANAGEMENT PLAN The SSFMC Chapter 20.120 requires that all uses generating in excess of 100 average daily vehicle trips is required to develop a Transportation Demand Management Plan (TDM) to reduce daily single occupant trips by 28%. Because the proposed development has a Floor Area Ratio (FAR) of less than the 0.5 maximum base ratio allowed, the project is only required to comply with the minimum core TDM requirements (comprised of 15 elements). The Planning Commission previously approved a TDM associated with the approved larger office project O. The applicant, with the assistance ofFehr and Peers Associates, a qualified Traffic Engineering firm, has completed the PTDM Plan consisting of a table of the plan and a site plan showing general location of on-site facilities that are attached to this staff report [SSFMC Section 20.120.060 Submittal Requirements]. The Transportation Demand Management Ordinance, SSFMC Chapter 20.120, requires that developments that are less than the maximum allowed base Floor Area Ratio [FAR] of 0.50 include in the PTDM Plan only the 15 basic elements delineated in SSFMC Sections Schedule 20.120.030-B Summary of Program Requirements and 20.120.060. The applicant's project FAR of 0.27 does not exceed the base maximum FAR of 0.50. The applicant's PTDM Plan includes the 15 basic elements. The TDM Ordinance also requires that prior to the issuance of Building Permit, the applicant submit a [mal TDM Plan to the Chief Planner for review and approval. The plan is subject to a formal Annual Review by City staff [SSFMC 20.120.100]. The Annual review consisting of Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: P04-0 131 - 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard January 6, 2005 Page 70f9 surveys prepared by the City staff or consultant is intended to monitor the success of the TDM Plan and make any adjustments [i.e. add/or substitute program elements] to achieve the intended TDM Plan objectives. The TDM Plan is not subject to the review and approval by the San Mateo City/County Association of Government because the project generates less than a 100 vehicle trips in the peak commute hours. The proposed TDM Plan is comparable to other recent developments approved by the City. The site's proximity to the Caltrain station increases the probability of success of the TDM Plan. The potential for parking spillover does not exist since parking is not allowed on Oyster Point Boulevard. As the Planning Commission observed at the December 2, 2004 Study Session, the TDM applied to the patients arriving for treatment is challenging at best. Staff will review the Final TDM with that in mind. Therefore, it is recommended that the Planning Commission approve the PTDM Plan, based on the attached findings. TENTATIVE PARCEL MAP The project includes splitting the 3.54 acre site into two lots with areas of 1.9 acres (to be retained by Malcolm) and 1.64 acres (Kaiser project site). The proposed lot split is conforming to the General Plan policies and the development standards and requirements of both SSFMC Title 19 Subdivision Regulations and Title 20 Zoning Regulations. Easements are required for public pedestrian access along Oyster Point Boulevard and vehicle circulation over the future Malcolm parcel providing vehicular access to and from the shared main entry/exit driveway. The City Engineer has reviewed the map and determined that it complies with the requirements of SSFMC Title 19. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD The project design was reviewed by the Design Review Board at its meeting of October 19, 2004. The Board offered the following comments: 1. Revise the planting plan to include plants that are better suited for the area. Blackwood Acacia is acceptable if available; otherwise a plant substitution is required. River birch, Crate Myrtle, and Columbia London Plane trees are acceptable. Rockrose and Australian bluebell shrubs are not acceptable because they do not thrive in the area. Acacia Redilines are not acceptable because they are too invasive. Monterey Carpet in large quantity is not preferred in large planting areas. An evergreen tree such as in the pine or conifer family should be considered. Fremont Poplars are acceptable, but care must be taken as they can be disruptive to infrastructure. The Pittosporum tobira Variegata shrub is okay, but the tree form is not likely to perform well in the area. Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: P04-0131 - 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard January 6, 2005 Page 80f9 2. Revise the plans taking into account the East of 101 Area Plan Design Guidelines. 3. Relocate the sidewalk so that it ramps up the slope to the building. 4. Provide a minimum 5-foot wide planting strip between the street and the sidewalk. S. Revise the plans and resubmit to the Design Review Board. The plans have been revised to incorporate both the Design Review Board's and the Planning Commission's comments. The minutes of the Design Review Board are attached to this staff report. The Board concurred that the landscaping should be continuous from 180 to 230 Oyster Point and that the plan should provide a fmished frontage for the new vacant lot that adequately screens view of the vacant site. A decorative opaque wall and/or graded 3 foot to 4 foot tall landscaped berm in the location of the proposed future building will need to be designed in conjunction with the landscaping until the vacant site is developed to obscure views of the vacant lot. The vacant lot should also be hydro seeded to minimize erosion and improve the visual aesthetics. A condition of approval has be included the requires these landscape improvements. City staff believes that the shared entry (opposite Veterans Boulevard) adjacent to 180 and 200 Oyster Point Boulevard should have a more generous landscape area at the southerly terminus than is shown on the sheet A9 of the applicant's plans. A condition of approval has been added to require a larger landscape area. The applicant will construct a roadway across the vacant site to link with the shared common entry/exit. The applicant has provided an easement for this purpose. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW As provided by the California Environmental Quality Act, because the proposed project is a compatible type of development, but is smaller in size and has fewer impacts than the previous development approved by the Planning Commission, the previous Commission-approved Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) adequately addresses the impacts. The environmental document is not required to be revised nor re-circulated and the Planning Commission is not required to take any further action. The key potential impacts identified in the previous MND were traffic, storm water drainage, sanitary sewer, removal of hazardous material from the site, and construction impacts. A TDM Plan and the payment of Traffic Fees for future traffic improvements in East of 101 Area, including the East of 101 Area Transportation Implementation Plan and the Oyster Point Interchange Fee will be required to help reduce traffic impacts. A sanitary sewer line impact fee is required to help reduce the costs associated with the sewer line and pump upgrade project. Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: P04-0 131 - 200 & 230 Oyster Point Boulevard January 6, 2005 Page 90f9 RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission approve 1) Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 SF medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces, 2) Tentative Parcel Map to split the existing 3.54-acre lot into two lots with areas of 1.64 acres and 1.9 acres, 3) Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan in conjunction with the Variance to reduce traffic impacts, and 4) Design Review of a one-story 19,200 SF medical services treatment facility building with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. Is/Steve Carlson Steve Carlson, Senior Planner ATTACHMENTS: Draft Use Permit Findings of Approval Draft Parcel Map Findings of Approval Draft Transportation Demand Management Plan Draft Conditions of Approval Planning Commission Draft Minutes - December 2, 2004 Design Review Board Minutes - October 19,2004 TDM Plan Plans Planning Commission Staff Report DATE: February 15, 2007 TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Time Extension of: 1. Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. 2. Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts. 3. Design Review of a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. Project Location: 230 Oyster Point Boulevard (APN 015-023-390) in the Planned Commercial (P-C) Zone District. Codes: SSFMC Chapters 20.24, 20.81, 20.85 & 20.120. Mitigated Negative Declaration: Previously adopted by the Planning Commission on January 3, 2002. Owner & Applicant: Kaiser Permanante Case Nos.: P04-0131 (up04-0031, DR04-0077, PM04-0003 & TDM04- 0004) RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission review and approve a One Y ear- Time Extension of a 1) Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces; 2) Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts; and 3) Design Review of a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. BACKGROUND: The Planning Commission approved the proposed project, UP04-0031, at their meeting of January 6,2005. The project consists of a one-story medical building with a floor area of 19,200 Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: Time Extension of: P04-013l 230 Oyster Point Boulevard February 15,2007 Page 2 of 3 square feet and open at-grade parking for up to 85 passenger vehicle spaces. This project will convert one of the last remaining former industrial sites along Oyster Point Boulevard to a use that will be consistent with the newer research and development buildings. The original proposed development also included a split of the then existing 3.54 acre site into a 1.64 acre lot and a 1.9 acre lot. The Final Parcel Map has been approved by the City Engineer and recorded with San Mateo County - so no time extension is required for the Parcel Map. A copy of the original Planning Commission Staff Report of January 6, 2005 and a copy of the proj ect plans are attached. As stated in the project sponsor's letter, they cannot proceed with construction at this time due to operational constraints. The SSFMC Section 20.81.090 (a) provides that Use Permit is approved for a term of two years from the effective date of the Planning Commission action - in this case the effective date being January 21,2005 (January 6, 2005 meeting + the appeal period of 15 calendar days) and the expiration date being January 21, 2007. The same code section also provides that the Planning Commission may grant up to a one-year time extension - in this case, if approved by the Commission, the new expiration date would become January 21,2008. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW A Mitigated Negative Declaration was previously approved by the Planning Commission on January 3,2002 and does not require any action to be extended. RECOMMENDATION: The request appears reasonable and the applicant has indicated their intent to start construction sometime later this year. City staff supports the granting of the time extension and recommends that the Planning Commission approve the One-Year Time Extension for a 1) Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces, 2) Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts; and 3) Design Review ofa one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. ~~~ eve C . n, Semor Planner c: Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: Time Extension - P04-0131 February 15, 2007 Page 3 of 3 Attachments: Planning Commission Staff Report January 6, 2005 Adopted Conditions of Approval Approved Plans Applicant's Letter CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL P04-0131 Kaiser Medical Office Building 230 Oyster Point Blvd. (As approved by the Planning Commission on January 6, 2005) A. PLANNING DIVISION 1. The applicant shall comply with the City's Standard Conditions and with all the requirements of all affected City Divisions and Departments as contained in the attached conditions, except as amended by the conditions of approval. 2. The construction drawings shall substantially comply with the Planning Commission approved plans, as amended by the conditions of approval including the plans prepared The Hagman Group, dated December 21, 2004 and Kier & Wright dated December 2004, in association with P04-0031. 3. The landscape plan shall include more mature shrubs, trees shall have a minimum size of 24 inch box and 15% of the total number of proposed trees shall be a minimum size of 36 inch box. The landscape plan shall be subject to the review and approval by the City's Chief Planner. 4. Prior to the final inspection the applicant shall have a Final Transportation Demand Management Program (TDM) prepared by a qualified and licensed traffic engineer that incorporates the provisions of the City of South San Francisco SSFMC 20.120 Transportation Demand Management. The Final TDM Plan shall closely follow the PTDM Plan approved by the Planning Commission on January 6, 2005 in association with P04-0035 and shall be subject to the review and approval by the City's Chief Planner. The Final TDM shall also be subject to the review and approval by the San Mateo City/County Association of Governments. 5. Prior to the issuance of the building pennit the applicant shall pay the Child Care Impact Fees estimated to be $ 9,600.00 based on the following calculation [19,200 SQ. FT. X $O.SO/SQ. FT. = $ 9,600.00]. 6. Prior to the issuance of the Building Permit the applicant shall submit the results of the soils tests in association with the tank removal and the final site remediation plan. The final site remediation plan shall be subj ect to the review and approval by the City's Chief Planner. 7. The applicant shall comply with all mitigation measures associated with :Mitigated Negative Declaration 00-014. (planning Division contact: Steve Carlson, 650/877-8535) Conditions of Approval Page 2 of8 ENGINEERING DIVISION 1. The applicant shall comply with the requirements of the Engineering Division's "Standard Conditions for Tentative parcel Maps" section of the "Standard Conditions for Subdivisions and Private Developments" booklet dated January 1998. 2. The applicant shall pay the City's actual plan check costs to retain a land surveyor to plan check the preliminary map and to sign the parcel map as the City's Technical Reviewer. 3. Any appropriate access easements between the two parcels shall be provided in a form and content acceptable to the City Engineer and the City Attorney. 4. The main entry roadway into the site from Oyster Point Boulevard shall be designed with 4 lanes with two lanes into and two lanes out of the site. The applicant shall be responsible for the cost of the construction of this entry way and all modifications to the Veterans Boulevard/Oyster Point Boulevard intersection and traffic signal improvements necessary to accommodate this development, in accordance with plans approved by the City Engineer. The design of the access driveways shall conform to the City Standards Drawing Number 1. 5. The project's grading, drainage, roadway, utility and other infrastructure design shall comply with the requirements of the Engineering Division's "Standard Conditions for Commercial and Industrial Developments" section of the "Standard Development Conditions" booklet, dated January 1998. The design. of these improvements shall be prepared by the Applicants civil engineering consultants and submitted to the City Engineer for review and approval. 6. Entrance from Oyster Point Boulevard shall be designed to prevent vehicles from exiting the site. fustall a City standard driveway at this location. 7. Install wheel stops on parking spaces flush with the walkway adjacent to the building. 8. Oyster Point Boulevard has been recently repaved. No trenching will be allowed in the roadway. 9. Storm Drain Pipe in the right-of-way shall be Class III RCP. 10. The following fees shall be paid by the developer: OYSTER POINT OVERPASS CONTRIBUTION FEE Prior to receiving a Building Permit for the proposed new office building, the applicant shall pay the Oyster Point Overpass fee, as determined by the City Engineer, in accordance with City Council Resolutions 102-96 and 152-96. The fee will be calculated upon reviewing the information shown on the applicant's construction plans and the latest Engineering News Record San Francisco Construction Cost Index at the time of payment. The estimated fee for the subject 19,200 GSF office is calculated below. (The number in the calculation, "8194.52", is the October 2004 Engineering Conditions of Approval Page 3 of8 News Record San Francisco construction cost index, which is revised each month to reflect local inflation changes in the construction industry.) Trip Calculation 19.2 gsfOffice!R&D use @ 12.3 trips per 1000 gsf = 236 new vehicle trips Contribution Calculation 236 trips X $154 X (8194.52/6552.16) = $ 45,454 lV. EAST OF 101 TRAFFIC IMPACT FEES Prior to the issuance of a Building Permit for any building within the proposed proj ect, the applicant shall pay the East of 101 Traffic Impact fee, In accordance with the resolution adopted by the City Council at their meeting of September 26, 2001, or as the fee may be amended in the future. Fee Calculation (as of July 2004) 19,200 gsf Office@ $1.51 per each square foot = $ 28,992 (please note that the traffic impact fee is proposed to be increased early next year. If the applicant has not obtained a building permit and begun construction prior to the date on which the fee is increased, the applicant will be required to pay the revised fee.) V. SEWER SYSTEM CAPACITY STUDY .A.ND IMPROVEMENT FEE The City of South San Francisco has identified the need to investigate the condition and capacity of the sewer system within the East of 101 area, downstream of the proposed office/R&D development. The existing sewer collection system was originally designed many years ago to accommodate warehouse and industrial use and is now proposed to accommodate uses, such as offices and biotech facilities, with a much greater sewage flow. These additional flows, plus groundwater infiltration into the existing sewers, due to ground settlement and the age of the system, have resulted in pumping and collection capacity constraints. A study and flow model is proposed to analyze the problem and recommend solutions and improvements. The applicant shall pay the East of 101 Sewer Facility Development Impact Fee, as adopted by the City Council at their meeting of October 22,2002. The adopted fee is $3.19 per gallon of discharge per day. The applicant shall meet with the Director of Public Works to determine the proj ected discharge from the project. The Director of Public V.,T orks will determine the amount of capacity required in accordance with the criteria established in the Resolution adopted by the City Council on October 22,2002. The Carollo Study, which forms thehasis for the system upgrades, calculated Office/R&D uses to require a capacity of 400 gallons per day per 1000 square feet of development. Based upon this calculation, the potential fee would be, if paid this year: 0.4 Conditions of Approval Page 4 of8 gallons per square foot (400 gpd/lOOO sq. ft.) x $3.19 per gallon x 19,200 sq. ft. = $19,201. The sewer contribution shall be due and payable prior to receiving a building permit for each phase of the development. (Engineering Division contact: Dennis Chuck 650/ 829-6652) POLICE DEPARTMENT A. Municipal Code Compliance The applicant shall comply with the provisions of Chapter 15.48 of the Municipal Code, "Minimum Building Security Standards" Ordinance revised May 1995. The Police Department reserves the right to make additional security and. safety conditions, if necessary, upon receipt of detailed/revised building plans. B. Building Security 1. Doors a. The jamb on all aluminum frame-swinging doors shall be so constructed or protected to withstand 1600 Ibs. of pressure in both a vertical distance of three (3) inches and a horizontal distance of one (1) inch each side of the strike. b. Glass doors shall be secured with a deadbolt lock! with minimum throw of one (1) inch. The outside ring should be free moving and case hardened. c. Employee/pedestrian doors shall be of solid core wood or hollow sheet metal with a J11inimum thickness of 1-3/4 inches and shall be secured by a deadbolt lock! with minimum throw of one (1) inch. Locking hardware shall be installed so that both deadbolt and deadlocking latch can be retracted by a single action of the inside knob, handle, or turn. piece. d. Outside binges on all exterior doors shall be provided with non-removable pins when pin-type binges are used or shall be provided with hinge studs, to prevent removal of the door. 1 The locks shall be so constructed that both the deadbolt and deadlocking latch can be retracted by a single action of the inside door knobllever/turnpiece. A double-cylinder deadbolt lock or a single-cylinder deadbolt lock without a tumpiece may be used :in "Group B" occupancies as defined by the Uniform Building Code. When used., there must be a readily visible durable sign on or adjacent to the door stating ''This door to remain unlocked during business hours", employing letters not less than one inch high on a contrasting background. The locking device must be of type that will be readily distinguishable as locked., and its use may be revoked by the Building Official for due cause. ConmtionsofApprov~ Page 5 of8 e. Doors with glass panels and doors with glass panels adjacent to the doorframe shall be secured with burglary-resistant glazing2 or the equivalent, if double-cylinder deadbo1t locks are not installed. f. Doors with panic bars will have vertic~ rod panic hardware with top and bottom latch bolts. No secondary locks should be installed on panic-equipped doors, and no exterior surface-mounted hardware should be used. A 2" wide and 6" long steel astragal shall be installed on the door exterior to protect the latch. No surface-mounted exterior hardware need be used on panic-equipped doors. g. On pairs of doors, the active leaf shall be secured with the type oflock required for single doors in this section. The inactive leaf shall be equipped with automatic flush extension bolts protected by hardened material with a minimum throw oftbree-fourths inch at head and foot and shall have no doorlmob or surface-mounted hardware. Multiple point locks, cylinder activated from the active leaf and satisfying the requirements, may be used instead of flush bolts. h. Any single or pair of doors requiring locking at the bottom or top rail shall have locks with a minimum of one throw bolt at both the top and bottom rails. 2. Windows a. Louvered windows shall not be used as they pose a significant security problem. b. Accessible rear and side windows not viewable from the street shall consist of rated burglary resistant glazing or its equivalent. Such windows that are capable of being opened shall be secured on the inside with a locking device capable of withstanding a force of two hundred- (200) 1bs. applied in any direction. c. Secondary locking devices are recommended on all accessible windows that open. 3. Roof Openings a. All glass skylights on the roof of any building shall be provided with: 1) Rated burglary-resistant glass or glass-like acrylic material? or: 2) Iron bars of at least 1/2" round or one by one-fourth inch flat steel materi~ spaced no more than five inches apart under the skylight and securely 25/16" security laminate, 1/4" po1ycarbonate, or approved security:film treatment, minimum. Conditions of Approval Page 6 of8 fastened. or: 3) A steel grill of at least 1/8" material or two inch mesh under skylight and securely fastened. b. All hatchway openings on the roof of any building shall be secured as follows: 1) If the hatchway is of wooden material, it shall be covered on the outside with at least 16 gauge sheet steel or its equivalent attached with screws. 2) The hatchway shall be secured from the inside with a slide bar or slide bolts. The use of crossbar or padlock must be approved by the Fire Marshal. 3) Outside hinges on all hatchway openings shall be provided with non- removable pins when using pin-type hinges. c. All air duct or air vent openings exceeding 8" x 12" on the roof or exterior walls of any building shall be secured by covering the same with either of the following: 1) Iron bars of at least 1/2" round or one by one-fourth inch flat steel material, spaced no more than five inches apart and securely fastened. or: 2) A steel grill of at least 1/8" material or two inch mesh and securely . fastened and 3) If the barrier is on the outside, it shall be secured with galvanized rounded head flush bolts of at least 3/8" diameter on the outside. 4. Lighting a All exterior doors shall be provided with their own light source and shall be adequately illuminated at all hours to make clearly visible the presence of any person on or about the premises and provide adequate illumination for persons exiting the building. b. The premises, while closed for business after dark, must be sufficiently lighted by use of interior night -lights. c. E:h.'terior door, perimeter, parking area, and canopy lights shall be controlled by photocell and shall be left on during hours of darkness or rliminished lighting. 5. Numbering of Buildings Conditions of Approval Page 7 of8 a. The address number of every commercial building shall be illuminated during the hours of darlmess so that it shall be easily visible from the street: The numerals in these numbers shall be no less than four to six inches in height and of a color contrasting with the background. b. In addition, any business, which affords vehicular access to the rear through any driveway, alleyway, or parking lot, shall also display the same numbers on the rear of the building. 6. Alarms a. The business shall be equipped with at least a central station silent intrusion alarm system. NOTE: To avoid delays in occupancy, alarm installation steps should be taken well in advance of the final inspection. 7. Traffic, Parking, and Site Plan a. Handicapped parking spaces shall be clearly marked and properly sign posted. NOTE:For additional details, contact the Traffic Bureau at 829-3934. 8. Misc. Security Measures a. Commercial establishments having one hundred dollars or more in cash on the premises after closing hours shall lock such money in an approved type money safe with a minimum rating ofTL-15. (police Department contact, Sgt. E. Alan Normandy (650) 877-8927) WATER QUALITY CONTROL 1. The onsite catch basins are to be stenciled with the approved San Mateo Countywide Stormwater Logo. 2. Stormwater pollution preventions devices are to be installed. A combination oflandscape based controls and manufactured controls are preferred. Existing catch basins are to be retrofitted with catch basin inserts or equivalent. 3. The applicant must submit a signed maintenance schedule for the stormwater pollution prevention devices installed. Conditions of Approval Page 8 of8 4. A plan showing the location of all storm drains and sanitary sewers must be submitted. 5. Roof condensate needs to be routed to sanitary sewer. 6. Trash handling area must be covered and enclosed and must drain to sanitary sewer. This must be shown on the plans. 7. Loading dock area must be covered and any storm drains must include stormwater pollution prevention devices. 8. Install a sampling point prior to the addition of domestic waste. 9. Fire sprinkler system test/drainage valve should be plumbed into the sanitary sewer system. 10. A construction Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan must be submitted. 11. Plans must include location of concrete wash out area and location of entrance/outlet of tire wash. 12. A grading and drainage plan must be submitted. 13. An erosion control plan must be submitted. 14. Applicant must pay sewer connection fee at a later time based on anticipated flow, BOD and TSS. 15. Applicant may be required to obtain a wastewater discharge permit. (Water Quality Control contact: Cassie Prudhel (650) 849-3840) Planning Commission Staff Report DATE: March 15, 2007 TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Time Extension of: 1. Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. 2. Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts. 3. Design Review of a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. Project Location: 230 Oyster Point Boulevard (APN 015-023-390) in the Planned Commercial (P-C) Zone District. Codes: SSFMC Chapters 20.24, 20.81, 20.85 & 20.120. Mitigated Negative Declaration: Previously adopted by the Planning Commission on January 3,2002. Owner & Applicant: Kaiser Permanante Case Nos.: PCA06-0008 [Original Case Nos.: P04-0131 (UP04-0031, DR04-0077, PM04-0003 & TDM04-0004)] RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission review and approve a One Y ear- Time Extension of a 1) Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces; 2) Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts; and 3) Design Review of a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. BACKGROUND: The Planning Commission reviewed the applicant's request and their meeting of February 15, 2007 and continued the matter off-calendar so that City Staff could contact the applicant and Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: Time Extension of: P04-0131 230 Oyster Point Boulevard March 15,2007 Page 2 of 3 discuss the possibility of modifying the approved Use Permit to alter the treatment of the sidewalk and street frontage. The applicant's response to the Planning Commission's request is attached. The Planning Commission approved the proposed project, UP04-0031, at their meeting of January 6, 2005. The project consists of a one-story medical building with a floor area of 19,200 square feet and open at-grade parking for up to 85 passenger vehicle spaces. This project will convert one of the last remaining former industrial sites along Oyster Point Boulevard to a use that will be consistent with the newer research and development buildings. The original proposed development also included a split of the then existing 3.54 acre site into a 1.64 acre lot and a 1.9 acre lot. The Final Parcel Map has been approved by the City Engineer and recorded with San Mateo County - so no time extension is required for the Parcel Map. A copy of the original Planning Commission Staff Report of January 6, 2005 and a copy of the project plans are attached. As stated in the project sponsor's letter, they cannot proceed with construction at this time due to operational constraints. The SSFMC Section 20.81.090 (a) provides that Use Permit is approved for a term of two years from the effective date of the Planning Commission action - in this case the effective date being January 21,2005 (January 6, 2005 meeting + the appeal period of 15 calendar days) and the expiration date being January 21,2007. The same code section also provides that the Planning Commission may grant up to a one-year time extension - in this case, if approved by the Commission, the new expiration date would become January 21,2008. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: A Mitigated Negative Declaration was previously approved by the Planning Commission on January 3,2002 and does not require any action to be extended. RECOMMENDATION: The request appears reasonable and the applicant has indicated their intent to start construction sometime later this year. City Staff supports the granting of the time extension and recommends that the Planning Commission approve the One-Year Time Extension for a 1) Use Permit allowing a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility with open at-grade parking accommodating up to 85 parking spaces, 2) Preliminary Transportation Demand Management Plan to reduce traffic impacts; and 3) Design Review of a one-story 19,200 square foot medical services treatment facility building with landscaping and open at-grade parking Staff Report To: Planning Commission Subject: Time Extension of: P04.0131 230 Oyster Point Boulevard March 15,2007 Page 3 of 3 accommodating up to 85 parking spaces. ~~~~ Steve Carlson, emor Planner Attachments: Planning Commission Staff Report January 6,2005 February 15,2007 Adopted Conditions of Approval Approved Plans Applicant's Letter If ~[~ ~.. ~2. : =lil t~t !;e: r~ tli ~i' : i i ~i o ~m ~< ~m rr hlO Gi-o film ~o o ;;oeD g-< ~I ~c ~z 0-1 ~m ~;o !'"cn rri-l ~O ~;o 'P===", ~===- ;r 8r () - -; 0 I g;-=- -"!. ~ 0> q en o C -I I (fJ )> Z II ~ Z () (fJ () p () )> r - " o ;0 z 5> o -< en -I m ::u -0 o - Z -I o II " - () m OJ c - r CJ - Z G) ~ (/ r ~ ~?J :T~Otn :J ~ (I ii'~' c- ~S=2.5' :% 3.0 5'~ -<~ CIt-o.atl- en 00 en g ;-~ ~ ifo~~ g ~~'-g ~. ~ 2. 11) ~ S' GO- o~-@5' MI tt -a'tO " ~g.~~ .w~ ~ :;~~~ 8.g 0- o..l,Qcr+ ~"O n 3:t~~. UJC b 00..-'- g~ "j 'g 5.g-~ =0. Q. p-~g G ~ ~ i g ~t l!! 0' ~ ~..~ itS: ~ 29..~ ~~ :7 ~Q~ g'~"& ... e" g:~' ~ et~~ "2.~'~' g -00 c;g; ~t;;"~ ~bg- ~~ ~. ~g~ ~?~ " et- n.- c en m "'0 m ::0 5: -i r )> Z o en (") )> "'0 m "'0 s;: Z S-3 _s. '" et [~ ~.. 3~ 0= "cr ~et .,," , C ~Ul .. o~ v'Q o~ ;:." S'{It '" ~ og ,?<" ~~ b~ ",0 0.'" ..~ " .gg "'~ )>'~ ~g: :rOJ ~~ a-~ ~~ if r+ :t:2 '" '" a. S. ~ so !'-> g:: ,,' ~ cr~ "'- e ClIO " OC IF e.~ 8 [(I ~ g ~ 8 Q a..~ 3 ct o-:J ~ ~ Rl 0 In W g ~ ~ [ 5: <t cr ['3 ~ all () () CD o 0.3. 0 c trCII 0- [ -;~ ~ g. ~~. i o' ~Q. ~ 3 a .0' ~. g!. ~ ~. ~:; g 9. ::1 ~ CD . ~ if !l- et a. C " a ti" ~ ~ ~ g: a. et 6" ~ 3 ii' et et if [ _ 0' o " " ; ~ !l- ~ " 3" o:r 0 00 ci:) <-i ~~ 0- ~.~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ".. cr ct.g- 0 ~.. ;I- ~ ~ g -g 0- ~ ?" 3 .. " r- ? g:[!D _,0 ~ [:~ 0" [-~ 1 'g ~ !3-~ .... a.'" ",OJ : !l _OJ ~~ .?'~ OJ cr'" ca. ~R1 n. ~'g ~<> e.a. :-n. ~3 .g~ et OJ ~g' ~-~ ,.. ~P! -0 vO ~ > .. " ~ Z a.~ , ...... et- et Z 0 il 00 (;) 00 o~ 0 a ~r ~ z " OJ - S 0 Q fT1 cr Ul .. .. .; OJ 0- cr 7C '" et o n. n. 0 ~. OJ ~ OJ ~ ~ o " OJ :r '" .. ~ o ::r :J: et g ~ '< ~ r+ 5" o '" OJ a. Q o' ~ tg '" 0 ~ ~ (to ~ OJ o '" I ~ " 1J 2. s cr ~ o ~ ~ ?- .. n. '" .. ~ 5' a. o of OJ ~ii:P' ~ ~Q.:::O r ~ .. 0 ~g i. ~ . Do:E ~ ~o 0 s.~ ~ g~ ~ OJ 0 0 3- ;<- ce. ;- '<~ !l- 0"0 r.& ~~ ~ '" 0 nO -. ..v et UI lit <; UI cD" 0'" " ~[ fl) ~ ~~ ~ Q. ~ 9- ~s: a o ~ 0- ~i ~ 5'~ "z \l.. c 0' "," " 3 ~~ _OJ :r a '" , 0'" ..~ ",0 a3 v~ :;:3" 0'" o =:1 "<~ o~ ~ cr" :r (l, g. :f ,0 ~o~ ~ ~ > if Q.(; ~ ~~ ~ ....0 ..g ::r~ .. "'." 0- r:J. ~ g Q Cl a. 0 J 0 ~ 0_, ."" " OJ !i ~ 15' ? 0- o !' I R ~ 00> ~ (J) 9 =ro rt' f11 B -< ~ .. -.00 ~Il ~i~~ ~ ! ~~~~ ~. g ej~~ \~~ ~i~li ~ ~ ,; ""- t}.. ~ -4- a~ . .~ ~ ~~ 8 7 Iii d ~ ..E..o..J "'~--...-L .. --iL._./ I 8 ,:~ ~!~'~i ~!.- '<'; J' )'~~ .. ; , " -- 1 ; " " <3 ~~ ;~ ~g ~ ~ ,., I I' I I-~ ~ ~ ;, \ 'i" \.~} \ .-..\ ~~ %-< ..,<> ",0 ~~ "'c .s ~;\ 1;0 z.lA <Iii. \'l '" (j ~ <> tl::g ~" c:: ll2 ~a ~~ ~ ~ ~ <I '" :\ \ o I , _ Vl. ~' 21> ~l!!~! ~~~; . ~(lp.J ! - ~: ~( ~ \ , " i. f "\ , '\, [ I~~, 'J ..,. \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ -0' .1 i~ Z CJ en ~ -0 m en .--- o -0 m en m (') -i o Z o .. b ~ , ~ '" ~ ~ (i) (tJ Q$J . .pr 0 is ,,~ Ii "i 1 :n ,. 5 _ ' , ~ c5. ,.~ S. gi :15 a. g. ~ ~I: DD d'ir ,,1 . w. ii l' H d i~ ' ~ g i~ f i .,. I~II" . " . lno t~ ff ~[ Ii I~ Ii n H 1: ~a f[ J fl ..~ i;!' ~! sf i afa [~~ ~ ~ij~" . , f,i: r, nH OUs(f ~ n~ ~ I,~t a dfHJ l!fiJi i~ l~ff a21~i; if:l~ i g~ i1 [I ~ll~tf 1: ~ II' ~ if. . ~ '< ~ij- f ~~ xoi. ill'W Ih ~.f; ~ ;l!l;'ifllO !g"ll~ il'[~.t~ o !f:J ..~ ~ [Ins 13~J f if i i~b:Of int~ "9~:PtIJ::::I i.i'~ , i[~ 1 (' , . " ,- HE " " / C) ~ M ::0 II ~ 'I t j1~ ~ ~ \ f.. fl-.i \ '~!. t IF/loCI <j,n 1.1"'. g Ii "U > z ...... Z (;) r Vi -t r !( "T1"O rng:-i )> """0 S:O "T1"O ;u"'OZ "T1"O J~~ ~ 0 ~ g o. g ~5 ~ '" D1 Ql ~g ~glg:i ::tI a. "'"'0 c: lir ~ (') ::r_ .. ::> :IE -l '" 0 ~o. !!l !'! 15' ~ !'! ID III !'! o ~. !!!. ~ !'! ~G)~ Z iil .' rD' os. g :J: !!!.g. 8.::> "0 - ::> ID G) "T1 m :::j :- 0 ~ . ID::ll " o CI .2. ;;r g.~ !!l. e ~ m ::> ~~ ~~~ __Ill 'CDm -. 0 '" Q ~Ji;: 8m'" 0. ?<" (') "'''''< ::< -g: ~ ~ . < CIl III (') ~~ -"0 0101 ...... eo r "0 ss ~m~ -I ..9..9 o -' iir $~ ~?- ~. 0 .2. "'''' ~-a ;.; ~ .2. "'''' )>::> G) '" ~~ ::> iii II "'''' $'" ID "'''' ~ ~ g ~ ",3:lil ::I: z "'''' "'ll "'''' g ~ -0 S. ~~ ... ID )> ID -I tt $ $ s: ~t g ~ iil III 3: '" CIl g g:~ 50 III ~g '" '" III "''' e '" (n ~ OJ "0 ::> ~ (}1 ~ ~'" it ~ ....0 3' III iil ~ co ID .::> !!l g r- ID :;- < ~ fl "'0 r )> Z Z - z )>Q -uO ;00 r~ -lo~ CO- (/) N(/} 0- 00 -....IZ ~ m m -I - Z G) () ::t> Zen ()O~ ~C- t1AJ-Ien -IIm -n , ^'. .'......;0.. .....~.'.-. '..."-...'."...'.'. t1AJm ~i....~...,,? /;.............."..'...",....'..........,..........'.........;.....:.;..~....\ y ..,....iu~.\c?,(;;d;? )> z 111' .... ;,;. ;~:'~,' :;.' -I.. .~.-<;. . ,/. ~ -n :::t;t~ m ~.~\;\I Z ;';":2:' \, <"'......:,.:; , ~. "~- ,'; - : Z -10m ()-z men-l zOm -10 m ;0 !! "T1"O CIl~~ m ~"O "T1"O 3:"'0 s: ""o"03:~ ;u"';u (') IDO "T1"O 0"'0 en ~g o ... r ...._ e!. g ~5 [~~ fl!!!.::T III ID '" e 0 =g ~::T l"')> -I e .... m 0.0c. or'{'CIl ':Tlf.. m t;!iilS- .. ::> (') ..~~ ~ ~ :IE 00 z o~ .. g ;:0 !'! (') ~ ~ g. !'! 003; o CIl-o III !'! a~~ c CIl""m "O""ID :J: o ID ::r -I iil .. ~ 8 -I III 3 is: CIl" C.1ll1ll ~ :r" . ::ro (') ::> ::tI 2. CIl ~-o 3: )> s- Q-g 5- .!!l (lCll", -I ~ ""::>1- g. ~ z 0)0)0) ~ )> @ !e. "U mm OJ CIl . c=; mm (ll5ID c=; <<::1 CIl UiUi ~!Po <g C "0 ~~ ::> c;- )> -':T "'''' )>=g. 988 F- . ID!a -I 1" 8S ~ ;;0 .2. S. $ r ~:= .9.8 ~~~ )> ~~l! 0 gJiYi3- 0 ID "'''' ~ - 3 "0 "'''' ~!" ~. C "'........ "0 . '" "0 ...... -"g~ r II "'''' ~ .2. ~~ ~lf ~.2. 'f' ::> ;:0 ::>. "'''' '!'C{' ",g> ::> "'''' c.... 3: ~ '" - "\l Q. tb<b ~t:) co II ~.... N(}'J t\) CD 8;: -0 m III ....'" r ~'" CJ1 II "'''' ::> ",co co rn coO C ;j~ tr !!!. ........ () "" "'0 ~~ "'... '" "'0 ~ ... s: 01 )( 0 '" 0 -i '" ~ g OJ g '" 0 '" g~ z _. '" < tJ (;) '" v $- ;;0 s: m ~ () !S -i )> (l "T1"O g>::~ mo ..,,-0 ~~c (') ~g>i'~;>g;~ ::!} 0 "T1"O CIl "'"00 s;: ;;0 ~::T gcn~~ 0 ~::r III 0 ~~ -, g (i) i .. g ::>...)> ~i? ::J C1I g: <: '- ~ .. g [::I: ~ ::tI -< !'! S'3:=s, m !'! afl? z III lirOJlo r= III II (II -. "T1 m rc~ f,{ &' z g. 0 cnn QW~ c .. to 5. g ca' en ::r .. en .. _::r =r "\l (') s: 3 ~ a :1. o (lCll'" ~~$~ iii g: '" CIl::> (') i:'l .0) CD tg. 9 --;)> i a ::tI mm OJ ~ ~ CIl ~~ Jl,. )> ~~ 0<:-- ~ ~~~~at 0 "'01 en III ~~ "\l ee )>p.(l -I ::>::> III !!!. 8..9 Q.e ::> OCll m ~m~ "" ~~ ~ II m "'''' "'ID .." "0 ...... ~fa: ........ 3 c.nc.n....... 0' (') "'''' Jl ii1 III ~~ )> "',.., oa:m m (,a)W ::J coco i ~~ ~i 01 co ::> Q 6~ -I 0,0, ~ ::> ~~ ;:0 ~. co 0 Q, "'0 (') ~ i" (l)'" en en en en ~o "'.... '" 8l~ ~<n wm z "'0 ~ 8 :J: ID 0 :::j Cil )> '" m Jlo Z 0 (') CIl 0 e -I < ~ ID ~ ::tI jil m :;- )> fl s;: ::tI ~ r ae~ "\l tttt ~ ttt~~ ?n 0 0 !1!;J1: ::tI z () ~ (') ~~~ 0 ~n~ ~ ~~~ra~ ~ ~ c.... ~ .n m ~H~~ rri 0> (') '"'''' ~ :.- z 0 ~~ -I aaa ~ " ~U)(l)im ~ (i) Z g~ 'U""'OG') rn ~ii1ii1, c og 0 ~~~~ ~H~ ~ z ~ :tm m )> m", en a!~-;j; 0 ~~ (') "tl"'''1l~ /.o!jl!jl~ m "\l ~H% X 22 ......~ 1:~ ~o~~ ~~~ 0;0 "\l ..~~ ~~ -I "," ~ 0 ~~~... ~ ..~-~ ..'" Z ~ 0... ~ ~~ 3 ~ 8z - I = II II f;; il 7Jf ,).,,) I I J r III. I .llr . . i ~ ~ I JI; ,~ . lit . I III' 1;1 I.. IS I... I' II .. iii I! 'II ~~ '=0 -'m 0) -, , II I I III Ih I!I ., Ii i .3 I 12: I I I r I. · · . I I . , I)> I o I r I I I , . il f o r lilt 11111I I I I I I I ) IJ L ~aa 1/1 _1' o r 1I11I1 o " ,2' 1,,,1111 I III I III I":. j'-fi o t' L......I I t I 711 , I t .1'-cr L..,....,I t ~"~I,J j""",,,,J " 'J ,.-. t' I I L"","'" I t I l-t)r .1'..0" o I, r "J T-t J -'If flf I II I dl f I "'II 1:1 I~ I!I I :t 0 ~ 0 " I I J 1..........,1 ,-,}or.,.) I.",. I"., I) ,.. " T-t ~~ l:rrl II '--" ~(f) .. -I rrl -0 ~ · Z I I' I I \ I' r-------i J::I I L_____~~ ----1- ,I r - - -- - ---- -- -- - -1-- - - - - - --.....11 I ~ I I cj. \ !II mill iJ : I I I be I I I I .-3" ~~ <J1)] )00 om )]r- m)o en ~ '\ "- \. ~ \~ '\. () ''[Tl ~\ -0 '\\ ~ '\., o '\,. P '\ L_ o -0 ---1 o Z I I ~ (., ~ J J---' '~ I "j iii 1 'J J "'eI ~~ . . :. ~ ~ 8 1fI . I III [] 81 r m J I . Gl l . . I II I m I I z I I I I 0 ! ~ II I I , I I I i t . 82 ,:,\ ,." , , r I r I l ~ IJ . IIf r · · . 1:( I I ji I. - I I ~ ~ !II., . Ilr (E) . r ( 1m . 111"-' II . I; 'ft i I'l=r A I~ :::11 ~l )> · f n I ' ~ ,11 il ... -I. .. ,1-1 L.......,I I ~ I I ~ ':.1 ... " t"".,,,,,J o " 12" 1,..1 I I I 1 I 1 I ~ I !) f.- - I o:t /JI! 11I11I I I , I I I J 1:.1 ....., !DI.It 1/1 . " o :t 0 t 11111 I I o " r L~~J I , I I · I }or' I I 1 . ,...0" r- :? ;/ ;1 'I .::~ I -g= -- ~ 0 g- " VI < g 0 rr1 l: g,- 8 /I :::0 I )> g~ I - ~ ~ r- g I g r---i- -' (f) tt - g:= -f fT1 g~ lJ ~ Z r r 0 il ~ ~ lJ " g -I - 0 \ z N \ J II III': r l~tI :", . I' ~ ,; ; II.. f s ~ ~ "Ii I · I ~ r i~ ~)! II )> · i III ~II I . I jI I '" I I' ~ - ~ II ir J IIIf 1;1 ilQ I.. a llr I 11 i.. , f; , ~ - i 1f ~~ . -" O' .. -, I II I I . . . . I t . t I ,.'. ,.) I . .. . .. . . . . . I I-,}r. ,.) . Ir f . . . . G " 11 0 " ~ G to,' 1.,.1 I I I I 1 I I,~,,'.,I.) 1...,.....1 I 1 I I I I ,}r~,I.) 1"".,,,.,,1 I I 't".',,) 1...........1 . rI f11f '" rI 1111I 1 I I I I I ; lei 1II1II 1fII: DlI!I: 1(1 - " Ilf i!, iif : I ir' . " 1"""""1) ~.I r ~ ~o g ~< g= ~rrl g II :::0 g- 1 - )> g= ~ r .. g -j-{, r (f) g J g - -1 fT1 -0 ~ Z ~ ;/' 8 0 0 ~ ;D ~ -0 ~ -1 - \ 0 Z GJ I I J J 'r' I . · , I .' · ,I J . , , 1'1'1" ' I~ .~~: w ' o " r L.........I, I , I · I,j.)"l) . ~ 1.....,.....1 I I I ~ .) ~ -,' f 1If' 1:( lie!) I.. . fir I II I.. , I' '~i II ~~ . -.. ,.. I L , . . , o " 12' 1,..1 1 I I I I I I ~ I I I 1 4"' -1-4' . r ... 11I111111111)11 L _XIlD 1/1 .,'-<1' o r 0 . 111111 I 1 ~ I 1 .,'-fI \ I I' I I, I i' .1 " I ,I J r / . I' 1""""..,1 r 1 ':J ,. -,' -'I . II I I . II f j, , , .. , , , , , , I flf rh I!I ~ I i 1:5 I t ,)jr . "J . " I , , . . , I , , ',.'.,1) .J . r o .....(0 ~c . - Dr o .....- t"Z ~G1 (J) 1'1 () --I o Z I o -0 -I o Z ~ )> z o N 0) .....(0 ~C . - "r 0 .....- ,. Z ~G) (J) 1'1 ~ .. "! I 0 Ol, z I J 0 J -0 -t 0 J Z tN ..: i i i i i i i ----4------'~----~~-~ I ~'"t , I I ?<~ , .<s~ 'Jb ~ . ~ -"l , !i I I I I I' I..~ ! I · . ':t I . I , IIIi' r)> · ! · JI l,. I r '_. 1'1; I ~ ~ I I f .r fit 111I1 I 1 I I I 1 J U ......SOIa '/1 . . r 111111 f . I'> r . -' i --L---- ---- I i i i i i i I"l''''' r.1:" 0" ", 6", I .. i , i ___~---__~-_w---------3~-- , I I, ; , I I 7'-0. , t 1 , , I I , , I I , , I I , . I I , f? I' :-I f? I :-I o 0 oti~ ~i~ 6", b,~ ~ . -' 16'-0' lil ~ f!li~ ~S!2 ~I . I i i i i i i i ----4------,.~-----.~-~ I ~'"t , ~ I ! ?<~ 'S~ I~ ~ i . ~t , ~i c: I :z ~ :!j' i I ~i i . , i I mj:-l f?i:'" P ~SQ Ol=" b1 ~i! ., J . .. I III 1:( ii fr . IS I I! CD l.. ' · i 'r ~~ . II ... ," ~, J Ilf I II fh ~ I { 12: I f I~I .. . I ;1 f 7 . r . I 'oJ 1".",.....1 1-I>r - r) I, , , , , , , , , , , 1-"" 7_"-<1' ~ o ~. t' \..,,,,..,,,1 , I , ~ J:J 1.....,.....1 f" -,' o " 12' D " r 1.,.1 I I 1 I 1 I I ,~)-U 1.,.,,,,.1, I , I I I ,>rI_~J @ 0 0 c Ii ;:0 --I ~ ~ -< )> . ~ ;:0 ~ ~ ~ ... i:! 0 , '" r:; ., fT1 Z ~ ;:0 C) fT1 s: fT1 Z --I ~ .. ~~ ~ U: ~ ~ ~~~ \! alii ~ z ;ll ~ g ~ilil :i! '" ~ ~ ~~ a ~ ~ ~ . ~ <l~> i:l iI !J)~ ~ ~~ In 6 :~ ~ ~3i ~ ~ ~ is''' ~ i'i~'" ill r:: - ~~ r- . ~~ g ~ F ~; ~ ~~ ~ (:! ~ ~e c:. ~ ~ I~ ~ ~~ i {3 i !:a ~ ~f'l a Q>. :~ % e~ ~ ~ ~ In ~ 1"'1 * a ,,~~ ~ a ~~; g ~ ~ ~ iI: ~ ~ 8 1m i m~ ~ Iii ~ i~ ~ ~; i r7l.~ ~a Ii "'z ~ ~ 'i'''' ~ f;::~:d ~ Mi! ~ i~: ;; "'~ i:l ll;~ f z ~ ~ g~ g g~ "N 8 ::<x a ~r'l ~'il ~'il ~ ~s ~ ~~ ~ \l~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ UJ fTl fTl UJ I fTl fTl -I ,. (J1 N '1l o ;:0 LJ s;: Z ;:j Z C) o fT1 -I ;!:: ,. UJ ~ I~ '. ~ ~ .~ ,.~ I I ~ f s> s> i ~ , ~ . ~ ~ il' Ii' " Q ~ i ~ ~ ~ ' i 1 ~ 1 i i' If ~ ~ t ~ 8 g "; ir ~ -"" o f 50' !!.oW 1 I I \/1,[. k.! 10 Z~l>> ~ ~g~ g n" :;!>l:t '\ i;l ~ ~IIJ ~ ~~ i~ ~~ ~; ~~ ~" f i -c ~ z ::! z G) -c ~ z n ,. z n Cl~ ,., z-< -<;0 ,.,'" ;0" -< J: ,., ~ 1'1111 r i~~ ~~F R~~~ ~n ~" ~~~ z~ ~~~ ~:i!~ l::J~~ ~~~ ~ilIii1 ~~~ ~~~ ~~~ ~!i~ 'i'\l~ i~~ ~~~ ~~~ ffitn!!! ~~~ ~~ll; . ilj~ ~z ~" t:~ ~~ ~'i' ~i ~~~ ,,~~ ~...z ~~'" c ~.., !5~ ~~g ~:;J.., ~~6 ~~~ ~,,~ Cl~' ~~~ ~~g ~! it'll ~~ 001 ~ n $-" e!'" ~ !~ ~ ~!8 ~F ~ g~ ~. ~ ~ '''~ a IJl 0 ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~; ~! ~~ s (1l~ F 0 ~o .... ~l; m c: ~g ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ g ~ ~: a \'l~::: 8 ~ 5~ ~ ~ ~ ~" 0~ ~ ~ ~ x ~ ~ ~~: i ~ !i PI ~x '!I 8 ~~... ~ 'll g ~ g~ m'" i "'~. ~ g ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ -u ~ ~ ~ d~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ S i'l ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ,,; \1 ~ ~~ ~ i "OM ~ ~~ ~ " >-~ ~! \l~ ~~ ~~ S<l I~ z z ~:S ~'l; -r. ;IV! ~'H~'i~ c;) ~;;~~U~ III "0" - n J: en Gl ~ ~ " " ~ ;a g !(l ~ ~~~ 'i ~ z 58~ ~~~ il!~'" E~~ ~~~ z " a ~R- ~ ~ eO '" c: e z 8R !; 0 ;ij ::0 '" iI'i' ~ ~ > " '" ~ ,. ~ ~~ r;! c z '" &~ ~ '" lil ~ ~ ~ i ~ '" 8 '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ III ~ ~ ~ g: ;u - g ; ~ -.. ! ~ ~ ~ " " - ~- ~ ~~ ~~ ~ " > ~D-~-~--;um~~~ ~ ~-~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~s~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ z ~ ~~N. ~~ ~ ~~~ ~h ~ { "'[ ,.~ '" Vi 0"',., co;o :;;0 '" ",00 ,,"C: :];.~ ...' a"tJ~ [5-2 ~-.., $~~ n~Q ,. II> Cl o ,~ o. . - ~ ~~ - 3 ~ i i; :: (')i' " ,.~ o il ,,' I I 1/80",,'-00 ~j -~ -.. ~g ,,~ l1" i' \J , ~ ~-~' ~" m 1] :z Hg i f!l~ ~ --; 2;2;~ x~ z :z :::::! G) ~~~ ~"! I ~ q~OJ. bb ~ ".I Z ggg fglS ~ ~~~ i~ rl (fl ll;M M ~~S ~~ aa~ aa ~~~~jjE~~~B~~ ~~::l:~~~g~~~~ !:rl;:Uz CD> 811lzn ~ ~ ~ ~ ji E ~ ~ ~ P: 2 ~ atP ~~~~~i~g~~~~ U ~~" ~'l:S!">a~g >1>- ~ ~ ~ e ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e d g ~~ ~i~;~~i~~~2~ m~ 6~;~~~ ~~"':~ '" ~~~~: ~~ ~ ~ 0 z c: /'Ol ~ ~ . ~ ~ /'Ol . ~ ~ ~~ffl~~~~~!;~2~ ; ~::iE>roI:!!.~Olllj$j6~~ ~~e;~~~~~~~~ ~~~z~~~~~~2a ~ i~~~~ ~1~(!!5.~ ~ ~8~C! I >~,., to .~ Ie ~ 5 In 5i 8 ~~~.fro:.~U!.~9.~.fro:.l.!.U!. ~ hhh~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ [ f ~ I { ~~ ~ ;r i 11 f ti l 1.1 i~ , r h I 1 I I I I"i 1/40", \'-0" I o I fll UJ () I rrl o c: I Jrrl c' m ~ >- (J) ~ ~o~~:r: g qi" ~ f"" l'T1 ~ CD '" !ii" r. ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ I ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~h81'~ ~"~ I!i G ~ ~ ~ ~ I~ ~ ~ ~ m~ 5 ~ ~ ~~ /'Ol ~ J ~~ ill ~ " ~ " ~ ~ '-"!. ~ 01. ~ ~ h I~""" ,.r , I , 0.. 0.. ~ ~ ~ i;1 -~ l1e c =:; ~~ ~ ~ ~~~ig ~ :a -0 ~ ;} ~ ;&:: "0 M ~ M >l'T10~j!: '" Z --l ~~ ~ a ~ >- I i!~ ~ ~ ~ e c ~~ Vi ~ ~ ~ (fl ~,. il ~ <' ~ --l ~~ ~ ~ ~ 2- I ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .> - !ti i i~~ii ! _ z> ~gE~: I € ~ Vi i ~ S ~ ~ ~ ~c;t;~~ ~ Cl"C)CDIIl ~ r:: ~ ~ e ""{1II_U!. O!. O!. ~ J.!.. ~ i i .~ . ~ ~ .. .""1.Jl U. ! ,. f f Z- 1- Ul CI!. t.!.~ .fro:. j;&~,.)t " ~ c . ~ . 0;; I i! '" p ,; ~ " A . ~ ~ ~ q "'~ I , I ,'i lj'/''''l'-lt I~ ",,' "",I ::~ e '" 1 C' , :'1 ~E ~:{ ':\ I: I I I I I I 1\ I U '\1 , , \ - ~ , . -------- } ty:; ./ : / I ( : I I I I I \1 \I} I \i, I; I I I '1 ,,~ l1G i: o p u;~ ~6 . if C?~ 0:, ... -~ l12 '" -~ ~If;? ; l1 i~ . ~::~ l1 e . <: -- ~i ~~ , _I! -~ ~e _:. it UlE ~." . 'l;-- " "'fj l1c l1 - ~ f uf ; I o..:z; o " 0 ~~g: , 0 ' !'-::~ ("') n""", ft~~ ~ ~ i , ~ a;;:; ~ CD ~ . gm~ .. : '" o iA ~ ." .. 3 o " .. ~ .. I , 'i 3/4-",1'-0" s> ~ ~~ f I', ",'," ,I I , r I JO.. 1'-00 J' , I ,0 = 1'-0- I'",,,,,,, ,r ,. , I 1-1/2-.. ,'-0- t , ? ~ " ~ l r I .::. t..J fIt I; < ,f n S g n . . ~ .if if m Z ): ~ m o ." ): ~ Z G'l ." ): Z , ",' ~' ;.,:~' (/0 Vi 0",,,, C 0:<> -0 "" V> (/000 D~C =,!:1-i oX ~, o ""t)~ =' Q.Z 9.~ .-.., o '" o CD>> . <z nP-Q ,. V> '" o z ( I, 0 G) ill C1 co N '" 0 [f) " 01 ro ,~ 0 , ~ ~~ ~~ 0" .~ ii co o " ;E. ~~ 1 ..._..~.m_"_.'-""'""_.'-"'---'--"T~:~~:'i~-i-~::'''-;"--'fiT1TTJ~ f c.:-~_ni.nrTgT-Tit l'p=!Ja 11I1. ! . , "jl"'I.1 - ":r-' ~t\\ ~ \1 h\'\;!\\\ ~I:I ilP \1 ~~ Ocn om ,- ;0 0;0 Wp -<0 ~~ z- -<0 rnZ :.u '0 o o \1 1 o -< (fI -< ", ;U " o Z -< OJ ~ o ~ f >u ;t.- cr: il 0 'If iJ. of If ~' ::J o ,. "lli.,_LJ L._: ~f>~I':: ~'.;::~ 50 , I ! ~S. l' -;:." '" >> z ~ ,"", '" z~ ~'" "'''' "'~ " M :<'; o lL! 1 ~ i; i~ ~ .-, J~ ~ J/l" ~ o -< (fI -< m ;U u o Z n~ OJ r. < o -'5' i:' ! ~ g " g w ~ ~ : ~ 0' '\,l In <D ~ ~ ~ 01 ;:j' .. : '" o ~. ~ I 1:1 G ~ " ~ " m '3 o , m , .. o Lu.-J.LLl I." " j__....Ll-'--_~..,_.>. ~_..L _ J 'I I-I/l" ~ 1 J: ,. , '- -"__M~_..~___.^",.._,__L._.--'-__._' --'-__. -'--_.J J"",,'_Jo z q Gl iiJ ." N "" ii Cl (J) 0 '" iD N 0 co Cl TTTrrrT[fJI~~1 +- J) . o -< (J) -< en ;;] " o Z -< C1J < o -----)> 10 -< (J) Iffi " o z I ~.J < o ~. wW!lqr'1Tfi[!rrlr'- __jJJ.lJJ.1i.l1t....UJJJliiu ,L._ t ..I '" o , --} Jt ~== r o -< ({I -< en ;;] " o Z -< <JJ < o ~._-------------------------> " /'> ~~ ! 0 I ~ g !'- ^ <> ~ Q 0 ~' g '" n ~ 0 0 1:1 ii' , - . " 0- " V> .. '" '" . 3 '" a; ~ Q 0> a' 0 , .. .. " it . __.1 j 1- 1,':;' ~ " ,. ~ ~ ~ w i; l' l E ~ r- I 1:0- ~ Ii ~ 8 , ~ m Z ); ~ m o ..., ); ~ Z " ..., ); Z '" () ,. z n ,., ~'" z--< -i'" ,.,,., "'~ !l: ,., z --< "'~: ,.. Vl Vi 0",,,, ~g::tl os Ul VlOO o~ C :J~--1 .r ..,' , Ul 0",. ~ S!.z .., ~ -.., o '" o ~p.. , < z o!J-!2 ,. Ul () o o ~' !lULl 0" Z:l> o(i) om r:u O:u Gl)> -<0 8~ ~O rnZ :u N 8 /-\ ('~;:2;_: \~:,:,. ,\\.~<\\ ~~ \\~~\. f..> \. ~~"\,\", _<.' \'tV i! '\>\ )),>- \ct" \..A~ 11\ \\'. '( '>),.-' -' ,-',\~'\M>~. \ '. ,~, 'Y().<. A ..'" '. \-<,<:;: ~"'..-1 . '. ~ \ /\ ,\, ... ,~. . \\ y/\,/{".>--'~<\ ~~.. i\J '\ \'\\,(" Y ',\ \>~.\ .\/;:/<'~\/:\ ,;".... ~\ \?"'\//\ >', J:.( \:\\ '\.,/" \ /,,/'\\ }- -\~\>, \" '~ \,?,\ \,"\ \.\ ':., '\. \,Y\";-<. > );,' '\.,'~./ \,\' \. \.",,\ \~\'\y\/\< . \,/ \.,' \. \. Y \ / 'y-'\ '{::~~\~\:",>/y,:/::v>,' ' \\ doV'\ \' \ ! \~.,-," "/',/i .. .<: x \ \;.-,A ~ )'/" \\:r f ".."",~ V~ 00 ~m ~~ ~~ ~~ 3:; }'"<:1 U ;Iif "t i ~l .. ~' ~ "l I P '/ ~ u ;:... if ~ It ~ fi ~: ~ . Ii " " \ ~: " . S ~ " ,j , U,l 1_,.1 L1L1J1.1 ',-.;" ,'vO ~ /~. l)ij:' "O~ u L",,~j LJ "7. I;~(/ J,- ',) r I i~- -..~; Q" l__l.-~.LJ_L-,-,.,-<J u i ,"",1. ,,,~, I ~ l' , [ .. - - .. -7 - - - -}> I /i " I( /I 1/ <D a !J ;/ { ,1 / 1/ i I ill III Ii III II Inl i' I11I r I ,i J I III! t I' i U !I P I, I II I 'I j I II 1 ! ,; I If f / II I I il {I I / I " !, U II I II ~ II I II ( 1\ ! "'DE""'''' 1:,,,.11.,,/ / "~I[ijN"'''''''~~ll II! l f I $ ;/ I? II ,J ../;/ ;ll if JjI ? i,! R $ 'I ),; I INi l 1/ I 1/1 ! I II I # I 1/ Iii Ii' ,;I ! 1/ I I / i/ I l t :I l /! 1,,,,,,1.' I z ~;; 0", Om 5'" Cl~ g "0 OJ; ~6 mz :(J '?, o -< '" iYI :(J 7] o 2 --< J!! 6 '" G) Qi -0 ." " C5 q '" Iii if> -I tv o '" o ? r f i f > :1 ;t '" '" ~ ~ 1 l ~ 1j , &'R ,- . VI ij; }> 0",,.., 'j ~ n ~g; ~ 1 . ! ,. .' :l; .., ~ 2: Pi' ii' n ",00 11 :::;,,., "" ,.., ~~~ ., . , n", f f ~ ~ "' i; 'I ~~ l 2:.... .." '..' :z ....'" ~?f ; !Z r .. l it f ~ ~~ n .1 r- , i' -., {! t,; ~ ~ -.., , l;) "' &ttJ: . ., g ./:l. ;!l 2: {i'l .... ~ :;Cz ,':- -~ .A }> n~~ '.1: t ii. :z ,. '" n w 0 o -<; '" -I rn '" " o 2 --< OJ ~ '" a , , . .------------------------. ~ ',1,1 (E flJ ", '1 h II I ". ,r fI "~ "' .~ : 0" '" Q Q Q ~!:g: .~ g ~ f:f o. ::; VI ~:Z1 " 0 .. . F I i/~ If Planning Commission Staff Report DATE: April 19, 2007 TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Fumio Suda - KC & L Seafood, Inc. - 6-month review of Use Permit to allow a seafood processing plant to operate in a 5,512 sq. ft. tenant space in the Planned Industrial (P-I) Zoning District in accordance with SSFMC Chapters 20.32 and 20.81 Owner: Applicant: Site Address: Case No. Kin Man "Timmy" Kan Fumio Suda, Architect 390 Swift Ave. #10 P05-0041nJP05-0013 RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the Planning Commission defer the six month review to allow the applicant time to commence full operations at the facility. BACKGROUND / DISCUSSION: In May 2005 the Planning Commission approved a use permit to establish a seafood processing use within a 5,512 SF warehouse space at 390 Swift Avenue Unit No. 10, with a requirement for a six- month review of operations. The business license was issued in April 2004, as the applicant was operating from Unit 11 prior to applying to expand the business into Unit 10. Since that time there have been no complaints or concerns about the operations at either site. In May 2006 staff attempted to conduct the six-month review and found that operation of the processing plant in Unit 10 had not commenced, and a building permit was pending for the tenant improvements to accommodate the use. This permit was finaled in December 2006. Staff conducted a site inspection on April 2, 2007 to verify compliance with the conditions of approval. This inspection revealed that the expansion of the use into Unit 10 remains incomplete, since seafood processing functions have yet to take place in this unit. The applicant states that only the freezers and dry storage space are currently in use. Staff verified that exhaust fans are installed and operable, plastic sheeting is installed and a trash enclosure with a sealed door is installed within the tenant space. The applicant has also submitted a letter (attached) that confirms installation of the exhaust fans and attests to the current status of the operation. While the site is in substantial compliance with the use permit conditions of approval, staff recommends revisiting the site in six months to determine whether processing operations, once they commence, are compliant. No modifications to the conditions of approval are required, since Staff Report RE: Fumido Suda, KC&L Seafood - P05-0041/UP05-00 13 Date: April 19, 2007 Page 2 condition No. 7 does not specify when the six month review period begins. It is logical that the use should be in full operation for six months prior to review. By: ATTACHMENTS: Original Conditions of Approval Letter from Applicant dated April 6, 2007 RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL SEAFOOD PROCESSING PLANT P05-0041/UP05-00 13 (As approved by the Planning Commission on May 5, 2005) PLANNING DIVISION conditions of approval are as follows: 1. The applicant shall comply with the City's Standard Conditions and with all the requirements of all affected City Divisions and Departments as contained in the attached conditions of approval. 2. The construction drawings shall substantially comply with the tenant improvement plans prepared by the applicant dated March 20,2005. 3. The applicant shall establish a garbage collection program to have trash removed from the site at the close of every business day. Evidence of this program shall be submitted to the Planning Division prior to the issuance of a business license. Trash containers shall be stored indoors at all times. 4. The exhaust system installed by the applicant shall have odor-reducing capabilities. 5. The applicant shall install a plastic curtain over openings too all rooms where seafood is processed or stored to prevent odors from escaping when any doors are opened. 6. No outside storage of any kind shall be permitted without approval of a separate use permit. 7. This use shall be subject to a 6-month review period, during which time the City will monitor the use. If any problems are detected or complaints are received, the Planning Commission reserves the right to modify the use permit as deemed necessary. Planning Division contact: Steve Kowalski, Associate Planner, (650) 829-6630 FIRE PREVENTION DIVISION conditions of approval are as follows: I. A fire sprinkler system is required per NFP A 13/SSFFD Municipal Code. 2. A hood and duct extinguishing system is required for cooking of grease-laden vapors. 3. Fire extinguishers shall be required. Fire Prevention Division contact: Bryan Niswonger, Fire Marshal, (650) 829-6645. POLICE DEPARTMENT conditions of approval are as follows: 1. The applicant shall comply with the provisions of Chapter 15.48 of the South San Francisco Municipal Code, "Minimum Building Security Standards" Ordinance revised May 1995. The Police Department reserves the right to make additional security and safety conditions, if necessary, upon receipt of detailed/revised building plans. Conditions of Approval RE: Fumido Suda Date: April 19, 2007 Page 2 of5 Police Department contact: Sergeant Alan Normandy (650) 877-8927 WATER QUALITY CONTROL PLANT conditions of approval are as follows: I. The applicant must install a grease interceptor. The interceptor must be connected to all three wash sinks and must be upstream of the domestic waste stream. Sizing of the interceptor must be in accordance with the uniform plumbing code. This must be shown on the plans prior to the issuance of a permit. 2. Applicant must provide a signed maintenance schedule for the grease interceptor prior to the issuance of a permit 3. Install a clean-out effluent side (downstream) of the grease interceptor for sampling. This must be shown on the plans prior to the issuance of a permit. 4. Applicant must apply for a food-processing permit with the Office of Environmental Compliance prior to the beginning of operation. Contact Craig Lustenberger at 650-829-3882. 5. Any water that collects at the base of the roll-up door or directly outside of the tenant space must be conveyed to the sanitary sewer system, not the stormwater drainage system. 6. The floor drain in trash enclosure must be connected to a grease interceptor before discharging to the sanitary sewer. This must be shown on the plans prior to the issuance of a permit. 7. Install a separate process line for sample monitoring before mixing with domestic waste in sanitary sewer. This must be shown on plans prior to the issuance of a permit. 8. Install a separate water meter for the unit. This must be shown on the plans prior to the issuance of a permit. 9. The fire sprinkler system test/drainage valve should be plumbed into the sanitary sewer system. This must be shown on the plans prior to issuance of a permit. 10. The plans must demonstrate the protection of the storm drains during construction. This must be shown prior to the issuance of a permit. II. Applicant must pay an additional sewer connection fee at a later time based on anticipated flow, BOD and TSS calculations. Please provide estimated flows to the Environmental Compliance Coordinator. WQCP Contact: Cassie Prudhel, Interim Environmental Compliance Coordinator, (650) 829-3840 APR-06-2007 FRI 12:36 AM DANNY K. CHENG 415 387 8002 P. 01 PACIFIC SEAFOOD TRADING 390 SWIFT A VB., UNIT 10, SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94080. Tel: (415)989-8338 Mr. Chadrick N. Smalley, Associate Planner, Planning Division, City Hall, 315 Maple Avenue, South San Francisco, CA 94083. Dear Mr. Smalley, Thank you for stopping by our office. We have just got the PG&E hooked up our gas supply last week and has not been in operation yet. For Item Number 3 in the conditional approval pennit, we have already contacted the garbage company to pickup every business day and we will submit a copy of the garbage bill as soon as we start the operation. For Item Number 4, we have installed the odor-reducing exhaust system reconunended and installed by CAPTIVEAIRE. The exhaust system is manufactured by Champion (Model No. 4001DD and MUA-l) with rated capacity of2880 CFM. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have further question. Yours truly, ?/ C7' ~/6p", 1 DANNY CHENG Planning Commission Staff Report DATE: April 19,2007 TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: First Baptist Church of South San Francisco - 6 month review of Use Permit and Design Review to allow relocation of a playground for a private school, including a 4.5 foot tall fence which encroaches into both the public right-of-way and the minimum required 15 foot front setback, on a site located at 600 Grand Avenue in the R-3-L Multi-Family Residential Zone District in accordance with SSFMC Chapters 20.20, 20.73 & 20.85. Owner: Applicant: Case Nos.: First Baptist Church of South San Francisco First Baptist Church of South San Francisco P06-0022, UP06-0007, DR06-00l9 RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the Planning Commission defer the six month review for an additional three months, to allow the applicant time to raise funds to complete the required work. BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: On October 6, 2006, the Planning Commission approved the subject use permit for a 4.5 foot tall fence in the front yard setback, subject to several conditions of approval which would require the applicant to relocate the fence out of the City's right-of-way and submit a redesigned fence to the Design Review Board and the Planning Commission for review ofthe fence's aesthetic and structural characteristics. Since October, the applicant has yet to submit a redesigned fence per the Commission's requirements. According to the applicant's correspondence (attached), a fundraising effort is underway to allow the applicant to complete the work. The applicant continues to search for grant funding for the project and has agreed to keep staff abreast of their progress. In order to remedy the code compliance issue posed by the existing unpermitted fence, the applicant has also indicated in the attached correspondence that, in the interim, they will shorten the fence to three feet and relocate it out of the City's right-of-way. This action would obviate the need for a use permit for fence height, but the applicant would also be required to remove all playground equipment and replace all landscaping removed as part of the unpermitted relocation of the playground. Additionally, the applicant would be required to agree to prohibit the use of the area behind a shortened fence as a playground, in order to assure the children's safety. Staff Report Re: First Baptist Church of SSF - P06-0022/UP06-0007 Date: April 19, 2007 Page 2 CONCLUSION/RECOMMENDA TION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission defer the six month review for three months to allow the applicant additional time to either secure funding for the project and proceed with the 4.5 foot tall fence as permitted, or to rectify the code compliance issues at the site through removal of the illegal fence and playground and replacement of the landscaped area. ATTACHMENTS: Original Conditions of Approval Applicant Correspondence CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL P06-0022: UP06-0007 FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO 600 Grand Avenue (As approved by the Planning Commission on October 5, 2006) A. Planning Division requirements shall be as follows: I. The applicant shall comply with the Planning Division's "Standard Conditions and Limitations for Commercial Industrial and Multi-family Residential Projects" as revised February 1999. 2. The construction drawings shall substantially comply with the Planning Commission approved plans, as amended by the conditions of approval including the plans received September 15, 2006, submitted in Association with P06-0022. 3. The plans shall be revised to relocate the proposed fence to the south property line of the subject property and the 1 foot 9 inches from the Magnolia Avenue right-of-way, consistent with the "Staff Recommended Alignment", attached. 4. The applicant shall install landscaping in the area between the fence and the sidewalk and in the planter boxes that effectively screens the fence. A landscape plan shall be submitted for approval by the Chief Planner, and the landscaping shall be installed according to the approved plan. 5. Prior to pouring footings for the relocated fence, the applicant shall schedule an inspection by Planning Division staff to ensure footings are consistent with the approved design. 6. In accordance with SSFMC Chapter 20. 76 Sign Regulations, the owner shall obtain sign permits for all exterior signs. Prior to the 6-month review (see no. 9, below), the applicant shall remove all non-permitted signs from the property. 7. No additional uses, including new or expanded buildings shall be established or constructed beyond those identified on the approved site plan without prior approval of a new permit or revision to the Use Permit and applicable environmental review. 8. The applicant shall take all necessary measures to prevent noise, light, glare, or other objectionable elements from adversely affecting the surrounding area beyond acceptable limits. 9. Prior to expansion of the parking area into the location of the relocated playground, the applicant shall submit plans to upgrade the entire parking lot to current development standards, including, but not limited to, surfacing, lighting, landscaping and drainage. 10. The use shall be subject to a 6-month review period, during which time the City will monitor the use. If any problems are detected or complaints are received, the Planning Commission reserves the right to modify the use permit as deemed necessary. 11. Prior to commencement of construction, the applicant shall submit the proposed fence design to the Design Review Board for evaluation. Subsequent to Design Review Board consideration, the fence design shall be subject to Planning Commission review and approval. Conditions of Approval Re: First Baptist Church of SSF Date: April 19, 2007 Page 2 of 4 (Planning Division: Chadrick Smalley, Associate Planner, (650) 877-8353, Fax (650) 829-6639) B. Engineering Division requirements shall be as follows: I. STANDARD CONDITIONS The developer shall comply with the applicable conditions of approval detailed in the Engineering Division's "Standard Conditions for Commercial and Industrial Developments", contained in our "Standard Development Conditions for Subdivisions and Private Developments" booklet, dated January 1998. This booklet is available at no cost to the applicant from the Engineering Division. (Engineering Division: Sam Bautista, Senior Civil Engineer (650) 829-6652) C. Police Department requirements shall be as follows: 1. MUNICIPAL CODE COMPLIANCE The applicant shall comply with the provisions of Chapter 15.48 of the Municipal Code, "Minimum Building Security Standards" Ordinance revised May 1995. The Police Department reserves the right to make additional security and safety conditions, if necessary, upon receipt of detailed/revised building plans. 2. BUILDING SECURITY a) Video/digital surveillance cameras shall be mounted in a location that records all activity on exterior portions of the yard during business hours. All recordings shall be stored onsite for 30 days. Video/digital surveillance cameras shall not take the place of adult supervision while children are using exterior play areas. b) Adult supervision shall be in place at all times. Play areas that are separated by fences or other barriers shall have adult supervision assigned to each area. (Police Department: Lieutenant Jim Thane (650) 877-8936) 04/11/2007 23:17 5508714194 COREY, LUZAICH PAGE 01/01 ~ George R. Corey Stevan N. Luzaich Dario de Ghetaldi Jerry E. Nasuri Amanda L. Riddle Edward A. Daniels Janet M. Li COREY, LUZAICH, PLISKA, DE GHETALDI & NASTARI LLP Attorneys at Law 700 EL CAMINO REAL, P.O. Box 669 MILLBRAE , CALIFORNIA 94030 (650) 871-5666. FAX (650) 871-4l44 'i-/~-07 Ron. Edward W. Pliska (Ret.) Xenophon TragoulSis (Ret.) - ~ Ft4W1: Go.,t. ~ QJ.-( ~;~~-~ ~~. ~f~C-~F~ ~.~- .fr-.JL - 11 ~ rJ 1 '-d- ~~ . · j , D. -- f~ <t /'--1 )y ~. ~Lf. h ~~" 1'.1 ~...-- D ~ I Planning Commission Staff Report DATE: April 19, 2007 TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Study Session: Use Permit to allow the construction of a new 165,340-square- foot R&D/Manufacturing/Lab/Office Building adjacent to Building 51 (642 Forbes Boulevard) at 680 Forbes Boulevard on the Lower Campus of the Genentech R&D Overlay District per SSFMC Chapters 20.39, 20.40 & 20.81. Applicant/Owner: Architect: Case Nos.: Address: Genentech, Inc. Flad & Associates P06-0136 - Use Permit UP06-0032 & DR06-0102 680 Forbes Boulevard i- RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission conduct a Study Session. BACKGROUNDIDISCUSSION: II The applicant, Genentech Inc., is proposing to construct a five-story building containing 165,340 square feet of gross floor area on the .Genentech Lower Campus. Building 50 (B50) would replace a surface parking lot located between Building 7 and Building 51. The site area is 53.6- acres and currently houses Buildings 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 9 and Building 51 as well as several surface parking lots. Previous Planning Commission Input This site was discussed during the September 7, 2006 Study Session and comments made at that meeting were summarized in the September 21, 2006 Study Session Staff Report: "The building next to the fill facility looks congested and the building looks large. The Planning Commission would like to see different "artistic" views of the project." I Proposed Building Architecture and Site Plan Building 50 is designed to tie into the manufacturing and processing portion of Genentech's Lower Campus facilities. The first level of the proposed building is a combination of manufacturing facilities, lab space, service areas, offices, and entry areas. This portion of the building is proposed to be wrapped with pre-cast concrete, metal panel, and vision glass. STAFF REPORT TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Study Session: Genentech, Building B50 DATE: April 19, 2007 Page 2 The second, third, and fourth levels are wrapped in a combination of textured pre-cast concrete and vision glass on the northeast and southwest comers of the building and spandrel, fritted, and vision glass on the northwest and southeast comers of the building. The result is a hybrid building with functional lab spaces in the pre-cast concrete portions of the building coupled with office spaces in the portions of the building that are wrapped with glazing. The top floor is proposed to be office space and as such, the exterior materials proposed are vision glass and metal panels. The building is topped by a curvilinear mechanical penthouse screen proposed to be constructed from corrugated and perforated metal panel. The trash and service area are located at grade, at the southwest comer of the building. This area is enclosed with Genentech's standard trash enclosure system. The site is designed so that Kaufman Court maintains public vehicular access from Forbes Boulevard back to the building's main entrance (near the overhead pedestrian bridge). Beyond that point, vehicular access will be limited to Genentech shuttles and authorized vehicles. A pedestrian plaza will be created adjacent to the southeast comer of the building. The pedestrian plaza will be supported with layered landscape planting, outdoor furniture to create a seating area, and a "grab-and-go" food service area at grade level. Design Review Board Comments The Design Review Board commented on the project at three previous meetings: December 19, 2006, March 20, 2007, and on April 17, 2007. Copies of the comment letters from the first two meetings are attached to the Staff Report, and comments from the April 17, 2007 meeting will be presented orally by staff at the Study Session. In summary, the Design Review Board (DRB) had comments on the following topics at the December 19, 2006 meeting: Building & Site Design The DRB believes that this building is too large relative to the size of the site and the scale of the buildings facing Forbes Boulevard. The Board requested that the applicant consider reducing the scale of the building. Their suggestions included modifying the Forbes Boulevard elevation by stepping it back from the street, reducing the overall height of the building, and recessing, stepping back, or breaking the solid glazing that is proposed for the west elevation. The DRB also recommended: that the glass portion of the building be better integrated with the building and the surrounding buildings by using materials that are found on other portions of the proposed building; that the exhaust stacks proposed for the top of the building be screened and that a shade study be included to clearly show how much sunlight would reach the proposed pedestrian/courtyard areas. STAFF REPORT TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Study Session: Genentech, Building B50 DATE: April 19, 2007 Page 3 To more clearly show the proposed building and landscaping proposed for the site, the DRB also asked the applicant to revise their renderings. At the March 20, 2007 DRB meeting, the Board had similar comments about the project's size and relationship with adjacent buildings when the applicant returned with plans that reduced the floor area ratio by 1.9% or approximately 3,000 square feet. They also had some more specific landscaping and building detail comments. Specifically, Board still felt that the building is too large and tall for the site and that the west elevation still needs more articulation. The Board also requested additional information about the materials and design being proposed for the roof top mechanical screens. The attached revised plans, dated April 11, 2007 include the proposed changes to the building architecture and site plan. The most recent changes include: . A curvilinear paneled screen for the rooftop mechanical screens around the stacks; . Taller trees in Kaufman Court as well as along the front of the building; . More trees and landscape features, such as large boulders to protect the pedestrian plaza area adjacent to the "grab-and-go"; . A smaller eyebrow overhang on the fifth floor - the depth of the overhang has been reduced by 50% compared to the March 20th DRB submittal; and . The color of the glazing has been changed from green to grey/blue on the recessed areas of the west elevation. The applicant is trying to accentuate the details on the west elevation to address the articulation issues raised by the DRB on March 20, 2007. The building height has not been changed. The applicant will discuss this issue with the Commission during the Study Session. A final issue that staff has discussed with the applicant is the predominant building setback pattern along Forbes Boulevard. The minimum setback along Forbes Boulevard is 20 feet; however the actual building setback is 35 to 40 feet for buildings in the vicinity of the subject site. The proposed design has a 40-foot setback at grade, but the second story to the fourth story on the northwest corner of the building projects 11 feet beyond the building footprint, resulting in a building setback of 29 feet. Genentech will summarize the site and building design process, as well as present the current iteration of the project to the Planning Commission during the Study Session. STAFF REPORT TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Study Session: Genentech, Building B50 DATE: April 19, 2007 Page 4 Respectfully submitted, //)tz --- Ger& Beaudin, Associate Planner Attachments: 1. DRB Comment Letters (December 19, 2006 and March 20, 2007) 2. Plans, revision date April 11, 2007 CITY COUNCIL 2006-2007 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD APPROVAL RICHARD A. GARBARINO, MAYOR PEDRO GONZALEZ, VICE MAYOR MARK N. ADDIEGO, COUNCILMEMBER JOSEPH A. FERNEKES, COUNCILMEMBER KARYL MATSUMOTO, COUNCILMEMBER BARRY M. NAGEL. CITY MANAGER Date: Applicant: January 2, 2007 GENENTECHINC 1 Dna Way #MS24 South San Francisco, CA 94080 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PLANNING DIVISION (650) 877-8535 FAX (650) 829-6639 Site Address: Project No.: 680 Forbes Blvd P06-0 136 On December 19, 2006 the Design Review Board completed a Preliminary Review of the plans associated with a Use Permit application to allow Genentech to demolish an existing surface parking lot adjacent to Building 51 (642 Forbes) and construct a new 168,000 sq ft R&D/Manufacturing/Lab Building located at 680 Forbes Blvd in the lower campus area of the Genentech R&D Overlay district per SSFMC Chapters 20.39, 20.40 & 20.81 At this time, the Board has the following comments: 1. The building is too large for the site; consider modifying scale of the building. 2. Forbes Boulevard elevation too massive and vertical. The elevation needs to be stepped back. 3. The exhaust stacks on the roof of the building should be screened. 4. The west elevation is massive and vertical, with a long blank wall. Recess, or step back, recess the west elevation so it is not in one plane/vertical. 5. Provide a shade and shadow study for the new courtyard area to see how much sunlight will reach the area. 6. Revise the renderings to more accurately depict the front setback, as well as the existing and proposed landscaping. 7. Integrate the glass (office) portion of the building into the design by using more materials from the other parts of the building and neighboring buildings. Please include these comments and any others into your next Design Review submittal. Attached for your information is a copy of the Police Department and Water Quality Control Divisions comments on the project at this time. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact the Planning Division at (650) 877-8535. Attachments: Police and Water Quality comments \\SCULL Y\CRWASSOC\DA T A\Attachments\Projects\P06-0136\7 -680FORB_0701 02.DOC 315 MAPLE AVENUE. P.O. BOX 711 . SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94083 CITY COUNCIL 2006-2007 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD COMMENTS RICHARD A. GARBARINO, MAYOR PEDRO GONZALEZ, VICE MAYOR MARK N. ADDIEGO, COUNCILMEMBER JOSEPH A. FERN EKES, COUNCILMEMBER KARYL MATSUMOTO, COUNCILMEMBER BARRY M. NAGEL, CITY MANAGER Date: Applicant: March 29, 2007 GENENTECHINC 1 Dna Way #MS24 South San Francisco, CA 94080 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PLANNING DIVISION (650) 877-8535 FAX (650) 829-6639 Site Address: Project No.: 680 Forbes Blvd P06-0 136 On March 20, 2007 the Design Review Board completed a second preliminary review of your plans for a Use Permit to allow Genentech to demolish an existing surface parking lot adjacent to Building 51 (642 Forbes) and construct a new 168,000 square foot Research & Development/Manufacturing/Lab Building with an office component located at 680 Forbes Blvd. in the lower campus area of the Genentech R&D Overlay district per South San Francisco Municipal Code Chapters 20.39, 20.40 & 20.81. The Board reiterated their concern about the height, massing, and scale proposed for the building in relation to its surrounding building context and offered the following suggestions to improve the building aesthetic, site plan and landscape plan: 1. Screen the three exhaust/smoke stacks shown at the top of the building - these chimneys will be visible from the Bay Trail, Oyster Point, as well as surrounding sites. [Views from public park areas, such as Oyster Point and other Bay front amentity areas are to be protected as part of the East of 101 Design Element Policies.] 2. Include more articulation on the west building elevation. Articulation should include significant (4-6 foot) offsets in the building fayade. [This comment is also consistent with the policies outlined in the East of 101 Design Element and the Genentech Master Plan, whereby the intent is to break-up long elements of the building with articulation.] 3. Reduce the building height so it is more compatible with adjacent buildings fronting Forbes Boulevard. 4. Create more separation from the street by adding more landscape (trees and shrubs) between the south plaza and the vehicular path of travel. The Board recommends Deciduous trees, such as London Plane, to create a buffer, Also, as the pedestrian plaza is developed, the Board recommends including trees that are smaller in scale at maturity within the plaza area, 5, Use a taller species of tree at the north entry to the site. 6. The eyebrow/sunscreen trellis detail attached to the top of the building is too large and accentuates the height of the building. The trellis detail should be removed or modified (consider reducing the size and/or changing the angles so the eyebrow tapers as it extends away from the northwest corner of the building). The comments must be address in your Planning Commission Study Session plan submittal package. Also, attached is a copy of the Police and Fire Department, Engineering and Geotechnical, and Water Quality Control Divisions' conditions of approval for your reference and to include into your future submittals. In addition to the DRB comments, there are other issues that must be addressed in the next submittal package: \\SCULL Y\CRWASSOC\DA T A \Attachments\Projects\P06-0136\FORB ESBOU _ 070322.DOC 315 MAPLE AVENUE . P.O. BOX 711 . SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94083 P06-0136 - Genentech. J - 680 Forbes Boulevard Page 2 of 2 7. Floor Area Ratio - the parcel area, as well as the building floor area for the entire parcel must be included in the next project submittal. 8. The project complies with the East of 101 Guidelines setback standards however; the building setback is not consistent with buildings on the adjacent sites. The Genentech Master Plan states: "use building setbacks to create rhythm and repetition with adjacent buildings". The setback should be measured from the portion of the building overhang/projection on the northwest corner of the building that comes closest to Forbes Boulevard, since this is where the building will be perceived from Forbes Boulevard. In addition to the specific concerns outlined above, staff has observed that there seems be a lack of consistency between the proposed project and the Lower Campus description for the Genentech Master Plan. In the Neighborhood Growth section of the Master Plan, the subject site is slated for a 165,000 square foot building with 140,000 square feet of laboratory space and 25,000 square feet of office space. The subject application shows nearly 50% of the proposed 168,000 square feet of floor area being dedicated to office uses. The additional office space may have parking implications that should be explored further, and the additional 3,000 square feet proposed for this site may not be feasible based on the comments outlined above. Finally, the Fire Department has indicated that they have a number of questions about the project. A meeting should occur with staff (Planning, Building, and Fire) and the applicant, prior to the next plan submittal. Please contact me at your convenience to discuss the timing of your re-submittal. To provide staff the necessary time to review the project and confirm that the ORB and staff comments have been incorporated into the re-submittal package, the materials must be submitted a minimum of two weeks prior to the study session date you are targeting for this project. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact the Planning Division at (650) 877-8535. Attachments: Police, Fire, Engineering, Geotechnical, and Water Quality Control comments o .. 0: .. % o o c> lD ~ ~ ~ i~:! f . .1 ~ ; lSlLQ . - _'_'-'_'_'~ i ! iU ;5:. u> GHl 1-0 H "U5. ~ !,p 3 'l: 'l: )> ~ "' e; ;0 ~ ~ Cll p~ Oil '" 0 "'--I-~ ~. !!i Cll ,. ~ ." 10 !e. ~ ~ n ? ~ <g ~ .03' c..... -- - ~ ~ 5' m C ~ \l " 0 ~ -i en ex> en i 0 0 () .. ;0 "Tl - 11 ~ m --I i .. .. CIl..... "TI CJl i uu>m~,. 0 0 H~ g: 02 f f ~ g: g -i .., -< ~ 5' w (..,l,,:p CD ~ ~~~~~ ~ 0- iil .......... ~ i = iiJ 0 0-- =660[1) -- ~--no ~ CD lJ I I ~, ~88~Ig;Ji U~ ~. ~~ ;0 0 ~ " g: i ~ - u> "to."' en G) ,. (fl' \l ~ - ~ -< -; S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i OJ 11 11 OJ!j ,~ m m ~ '. '" 0 - I I co , l ~ i :r ~ ~ C Z (J) :::0 Cll 0 ~ .3 0 -II I y> ~ CD m "Tl 0 5' ~ < " Z m C ~ It Q) I en m." toW ~ () iU E ~ ~ .., --I OJ --I g:::g g ~ _. s ~ ~ a. ;0 :: ~ ~ ~ !! :5: en m 1O!'4~ .., '< . m - i~~$j~~. 1ii o '" , I :: !e. CD ~r C -I i~~~~ II f ;; C/) :3 .." I>> Q) <Q. ~ '" !!) () )> ~ l: i.i 3 I co ~ 0 (J) -. g ~ ~ i6 ~ c I ;0 NlIi g> Cll "' :x> )> i< CiJ~ r-+ -< ~ 8 i :::::r ~ OJ Z N C/) ~ lJ i Q) C w 11 - ~ - ~ r ~ :::0 lJ c: "Tl 0 0 :x> c: it~111 a" .., 0 r I} w -fl: Q) - ........, Z ~ "' "' 0 n 5 .., -0 ~ Z h:~t~~J.; c c () 0 ~ [; ;= () 2 :E"' --< ;0 - 0 0 c (fl m,. n () () (Jl z z ~ --< ~~ ~~ ~ n ;lJ 0 G) () Jrdll :Jf ~ Gl Gl C 2 en 0: ~ I n () ~~ z c c..... - m -< --< Gl ;: 0: Ci ~ 6 "' () (J) tJ ..:~ I 2 "' m m ::< " c ;c 0 CJ1 )> m ::;1 ;= () " 0 () m z -i - 0 -JJI;I~ Gl - 0 0 -I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t: --< --< "!! ~ "' ::;1 <5 .... ~ 0 ;lJ Z 0 I ...... "" )> '" ;lJ ,- "f" "'''' ~ c; ~ --< ~ (fl 0> m .... ~ 0 T1 :E ~ --< .- - 8 0 c; =< "' ." ." --< 33~ )> '" < 0 - .. I C 8 r 0 n ~ m 8 " ill ;lJ <0 z ;= '; ;0 0 --< 0 ;c ~ ~ (Jl I Z -< ~ ~ m Gl ;: r ~ m 0 d ~ n )> ----- =< ~ -i ex> Z c= ~ Q n c= :E m~~~~~ ~ 0 0 0 ~ UU~ ~ ;lJ " z s: r D:J:J OC)G')G)QC)m ~~~~~~~ -". .. o -ijl c: iH ~ _ ft ftft ., - :r :r' ~iMil.!l D ~i ~~~~, < mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmoooooooooooo Z ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ p pp CatI'onC, ~ ~ () OOOOOO~OOOOOOOOO~OOOOO~gOO~O~ 0 '....i t PJrt9 WI-..^ .. ~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~N~o~~~g ~8N~8 ~~ ~ ~CJ.. .., .j m 1 Z c= .~ .... f X c= ~ -i ~CJ)on 0 ~~~ "'Tl-l"'Tl~>~~CJ)mG)>"m 0 CJJg 0 -H -< ~~~~ m ~~~o~oo~~~~~~ .... --< ~-1S 81 ~~ '.. :r.cn-l-l )> ::I:O-lC/J(f)CJ)CJ)o~Q;"::! T1 l!:Imm " mmI 6~~n~~n~~~~~~ 0.. ~ nE;~~ u> ~~~ 0 m ooo1;;"..,1;;on,,'1oo 0 I >0"''' )> >0"" n ~~~ I ~~S~ --< ;:O"'TlCJ)mmmmro~ < 0 ~ '--- 5 l!:OPl"~C~"i~ ~S?m ;0 0; 0 p-. -"\ -0 ~C'&J&l 2 co=:! ~o~m~~;:o m~ 0; 0 )> 220 )> 2 0--<2;:--< 0 ~ ,,0 ;:o:r.O-lmz ~r ~r-r l! (Jl-< 8"'~~~Gl "mr~ ~ Pt; 'c~ --< "'Tl88~(n" ~ ~~n1 c "ll ~ ~""21 ~ ~~ C 4,. ",,~ ~ Z n '\ (JlH G) ~ ~ (Jl(Jl ~ .., ~ (J) 0 i ~ z n , f I t ~ -~. I g~ 2; !l . ~ !l 0 .. 0: .. 0 c> ~ r o ~ ~ ~@ ~ ! i . . I ~ JRZ ~ I:~ii ~ ~I ~ r h ~.. ~ ------ i ! !I ------ - ~ "_____1 ~ II .111--- -; ; : - I I: i o i ~: B - ~ a :: !I ="'T"j"--- Nljl__~ _____1 ~ ~ -- It~ft : !Ill.."i -I -II i t:r:~w:w .: Jl~d4Jf tJ ...~ - j j j I ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;; ~ I I. CI ------ ;; ~ I - It QgQQ ". .. =- =-=- :I!'l:! 0 -eo - -Ii!! =- !,=-=- .. i 'I i :: :'.:r g.g. . i!i . . . - j! I; ;"!!rT;,,;,, pPPpp ;; ~ lj8l " fi]o ~ 51@ - 8l lOll'!! o O"'ll I ~ ~ - 8 -a- ..... :~ toi!; ~"'ll "'ll~ ~ 5~ :z: ~ T !:I L o ,. 8- ;:' ,. "' " % .. . G o n m X en -l z G) o < m ~ r r en -l m ""{J r ::x> z ~ ", ", ~-'............ ", -"'...... " -............... --...... -"'......-- -'- ---... --- -'- ", -"'...... ----... " .. :: N ~ .: ;; ;; " ;; ;; !:I "' " G o .. . .J r " II: " " " " lD . ! ~ : 9- ~ :RZ ," is!'il! ~ . .I:i!!~' 1Ilhdil .. ~ ------ co i ! ... ------ ~ ~ I ~ ~ . ------ I -; ; - I ~ o " _ i I :: ~ ------ =: ~ - , I: N . !! ------ ~ I ~ c: - i)J: !lii JI~ .tfwJ! .: Jll] :!:IJi ItJ ~ ~ -JJJI;~ ~~~~~p. I~ m . 0: ____.il_ .. ~ I I I I I - Ih Q QQ i iI :n:: ig e Ill:: - s....... ~ i ; ~ J ~JJ - ~! ;'5T;';' ,. pPPpp - ~ 'tlg! lD I ~o ~ ;gg -g! tlll.'!l 0 ~'tl I ]1 0 ;; 2 :~ tll'tl ;J~ l! 'tllj ~Ii ~ !I L " ~ z t '" o g; 8 c i ~ ~@ I 1- .. n "U ;U o "U o en m o o < m ;U )> r r en .., m "U r )> Z ~~-- "-"-- --- --"--, --"- 7 . lD \::. g :: N c: .: 0: .. :; ;; .. l! !I z II: " " " . n lD " I z I ~ ~ ~ 9- ~~g~ t e~g;, ~. Cl ~." , in~ i - ~ ;0 -----li --- --- 'z p "ii~ S1 S1 ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l:: ~ ~ ~ ?o ?o 2 - 0 0 o ~ i$I ~ ~ ~ !; ~ w 18 o !; 2 - Z l!l 2 :: -- I~ -;-~~--i - ~ t;: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ - -1- --- ~ ;li I~ ;;: -ZQ.Qg:::l2.;f ~~oo~~~~r>" :t ~ i~ !l G ii':i ~ a ~-,,9.:!.~8'&!; ! ! h~ a g ~~ [HH~; ..~: .'tI-o..!.&.~Pi · ~~~~iS.~f;t"5l III !7'~_ '< -It-8 i3':'~ ~~ 4 -~~~!ii~~ ;0 ;ll ill i S1 r.> ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;; 0; !ii'~tIl 0; i og ~ ::Sc ~ ;]Ul - tIl ("Jt'l g; ~~ b ::0::0 - 0 F:!5 co C,.r,) en ""'3 :=31:0 t'l"O "Oc ~8 o z ~ o ~ ~ L o ~ 'Ill 12 ~ i~ I ~ ~ ~ i r- I . ')> ;0 o I --i m o --i C ;0 )> r "1J r )> Z I z p :~ i~ " ,~ ,,, i~ ~ I" ,~ ----, /" @ ! '/ I / ..' / .:. """-""1" " f.!!. If j&dt ,it .,.' '" ~~q 0; " CJ>' ~ - /1 1/ I II o '" j -..,' r~~ ... ~-"",-,.J ./ I I j ~ '- I~ ,I'>-.. ' " ,.,. I / ~ -'J 'v I ' I ) !) ...., ,\ # ~;il ~, " (J ........ I J I' '. I " / ,,", .y , f' , ,~, ,,\ / ;;;-' II - --,.......... / \ . \ f / y::: /, ./ kl ,f, ~ : <~"" ':::-- f ' ('Y, .] I I I f I. /fIJ ~" c) /--- /1 -;-) \ 0 ; If/~/O, 61 I. / ill I '7)(n I '_~ ~nl I, I. \ I '{D. . " ", --- I I _<;> r:,,\, / ~ \ ~ '< "'- :ijf' 1 I, " ", " ,S';>6:J "-: ';>09" 38?,s.;>-:--!!: " v.. it ? \fI I.", 'V ~$ l . 0, '. . -*- @ -+- r Ie }> "' " 1) ~ ~ ~ x " ill -0 '2i 0 1) " 0 z 0 8 "' s " g: r x ;= 0 ['Tl '2i ~ ~ V> CJ z c; z " ~ " :!; ~ ['Tl '> '" Z l:: 0 1) .., 1) .., ~ 8 0 ~ c ~ ~ ,n', f " ! :) )' o :: '(is t 1/ / I , / ;:; t:: i / ! . rf :;: ~ ( ;>,) ;; ;; ::; 0; P. \~l~\Q6.1JI-OO o \U.:I\p'lO__l\C'W1I r J)fleJ"'O<AGI:_2\1~-0> c:: 4~ 2-21--Q1,..Ol04,)l"'" ~41 I i ~ . ~ ~ ~ . i . l! · ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .~i ~:I; h~ ; ~" . 9~ ' ~( l's- i .lit. -2 . .,. ~ , ~ " . ~ Pl - ~ ; ~ 9 ;II ! ~ ~ n " ;; ~ :I I $' : ~. ~ ~ ,,: " -~7~ ~ ! .~ ~ 2 = i S w - ~ =oi-- ~ ~ ~ :.. - !l ~ ~ " ~ ~ iFHp g" _ i'~:rl~~;~"" ~.i-Q,- Q~~ ~ ~lU!.,:d: f 1 i- ~!t ! i. f j: . .~~ ; 11o~!ai~~; 'iH}"Jf,,; ~..~ ;;-i"! ji j ~ ~ ~~ aI aI ~ l ~ ;:; :: .~ ."1- .~ ~. Cl . ..... .1 ~ ;;; g. ~ g i>~ Ci)f!f ~ ~~ ;t'D::;:; ijlll ::I:H~uru ~ ~ ....S'..::I::I og.o~()~ 8 . n;rn n ~ _ . ~:r E"";T;T o ~ ~ - . ~ -0'- ~.n:i;- i I. :- ;; i Qt:I1"g---' ~ ~~ ~ b 0 z~ Pt"1 o"tl :ot"1 >:0 -;;c: z- >-,j a t"1> "0 >"tl zr- on c~ -,j- _0 cz ...; -< "tl ~ Z - ~ I :0 ~ ~ " ;lI ;-: ~ . o 7 P ~- go :1$( ..... ~ ;;; -~'""-. - (r,~ , . I , ;lI ~ 2 ~ ~ ,I ~ i Iii - F I I I I ~ ,;' !'~ f- I I " i :' I' J/ ' 1/ a .., k " '" ~ ~ z p ! .. I ) I e : = /' h '.'.1- j I /'~ / 1 ;;: .. , .. I I. ; ~ , /....................... I ..........'1 / / / \ ("" /1 ';. ....'-...", o ' ,.^- ~"'''- /' / ~r < "'" "'~ Z $' ~;('" ' ~ "" / ' .. .. ,:j"< ,~ ",,; , , /' '~ ~~j _/ I /'" ." ... c>C i~ ZZ mm ~ ~ .. I / ~ , I / ;; I I 1 !I ! I ,I / ;' ! , ;:; /1 I I I Q'>t. '-" l' " . '" ;; ;:. : : ;; N CI I I I I 0 I I i ~ If. N <> .... ... m ... Z CI ~$ --~ ~ , , :0 c " ~ ~ '!J 2 ~C:;i~~~ Q% c~l~ ~~~z'l~ ~z i~i':J :2 0 . ~ ~ ~ e ~ ; i ':! 1 * <> r ~~_\OIolJ'~OOV""'V---I\["'O)l)..L'AH-"'''O( r A(l[~-/);}'\"...t "-I~-Oft I1"C~-n~... I ~ '"-"flf'll! ~ --T~ '" )0 \. o ! " % . ~ . ~ ~ . ! ~ ~ A I - .Ill ! J:r dl- . ....U1 ! ~~ ~ ....11'1 ~~~~I-< ~ L i.. _28 .... I I ~ i '" - !il '" ~ ~ '" .. l!i " ~ g: 0 ~ : '" g; ~ .. ~ -~ ~ " g ~ )0 Q o >- rl Q I 1--; '" o 5 9 ~ o r = ~ ;:; 0 ~ i '" ;; r-o~!P !'!." i'~:rU~:'H; ~~~'!.a30fl~ i~h~!'~..~" ,'.;0 Q il ').3 C if' ; Xh~!.iH:; l:;~1~~f . I~"'_ .._t~ ".1. ~-i: ~ 1 i i ~ ~ ~ : : = } ~ ~ :: ;< ;~ ,.c ~ CI .... .~ 1'; ;;; 8 a go ^^ r,., tt ib" ~."'" ,^~:J..,.019 ;:; !=!!l tt ill:r :lI ::; i1!il :r 2.~ ~ ; !=!= :!l!--"'" ~ ~ n;TX g : _ ~ ~? :r~~ n ~ 5"'- ,. ~r> g:;-:;- i ~ ~~~--- Ii i ~ f, [Il III '" ~ ::0 (]l " 00 Ul. offi Z[Il n-c O[ll Z::o ~~ O~ r- > -c-c t""-c >c Zn ~ >- Z ;!a :oj ~ ~ ~ , 9: ~ i - ~ I ;; ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ o ~ !' If, s 9 :<. ~ i II /I/~"'--' / / -.I / ~ / / ,;; ~ I /1/'/ · j/ I " / / / I.... ' ,/' 8 .I /'---...., .~ / "'--l '--- \1 / "'~ /~>,~ j?'--- / ' / / Q ,I ,/ t .~~ <! ~ :\ ::/ I I r . I i / / 1Zt---. ' .,. .~(.i::____ ","-- - ;; ... (1" i "')"f '1 . I I I Ie f I I I~ /1 / / /- I --..... / ;;; ~ -....... '-.... ; / II // // ,/ I j:ij , ; I I ': i I ~ l 1 I <5 / - o ! I / I , , ,:/ / I ::; ; / 1 / I " I ,. / , I I I 0 '. J ~ ~ (,'-... I '-.... / ./ ! /\ (...<...... ,/ ........... /" \ ~ . ~.~.~~~~"',. ~~ '- :; I:lIl m c:)C ~~ ZZ C)C) =II: ..... ;;. a .. 1 I / ~ \ 1 .~ :: 1 h ;; Q o ~ ~ ;;; I I ,/ \ \ ~~q -"~-J>:/) 1'-' , ;' / ;. ~ ~, / ;: r "v--.. ~ " I 1 " .. N I:) I r- ;;; '" 0 C) '" :z 1:1I GJ 0 ~ ~..~u_ -CP-"- - I : I : I I : I I : I : I I : ~~l'3!1':';'" I;t . - i! Y ~ ~ ~ K ~! ~ I A ~ ~~ i ~ ;. j~.; ;;j~ p .. . '" ~ ~ A c . ~ i ~ ) ~ '" n < <> o , 06. "" ~ t1t--.n.of1 '-'1-01 ~O I JlI'8 ~,,:<AQ( _'\'~-006 ~.~ oe.2J1-:JO"'d"""__'\C1'Cl1U - C ".\9_'.c-\ Z o talIl -0> [;10 cC ['lta s::t':I 0"'0 Ct':I -3;0 -3: 0_ Z-3 ~ -0> 0 r--o >-0 Zr- ~ ~ n . . > ~ -l 0 , r- Z ~ R ~ i " 0 " % . 5 . . l!. _ ~ ~ ~ ~ i . ~IJI . ~~ . >'1'1 b~ ~ ~ H~ ~ .... Us ~., ! I . , ! " . , ;;I --- --- Z P j;l - ~ ~ 2 III ,. ~ " ~ ;; : ~ - 8 ; ~ .. ~ -~ * !: ~ i.l . ~ 2 ~ ~ = :2 ~ 0 . ~ -.. ~ ~ e ~ ~ ~~--- ~ ;:; -;m.~!lt: ~:i'1~ ,.'H~ i' ~~Q,.~!~ ~ - ~!: CT S ~.o ! O_p ..... 1i!;; iHl 0; ~! i H "} f ~~ 1'3: ~ ~.{ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :! ,. ," 1 51 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; I I , I g a (;)Q "ff ~ ~ 4iI ~.::r::r ~~ =<D::rUtit ~ ~ ~ = a: :I ;:.. iI il ""lJ! -: <0 q ~;T~ n n ~ ~:!I' :rrrrr . Z 5"__ - ~ >i :..O~;"~ ". :I. n~.- i:' .. ~ . ; ~ " ~ - lli o I 8 '" ~ ~ ~ '. - :' ";. I , ,/' Q / 7' I . ! ,,' /.,j I ') 17 "1 ~.<t, ': (~7 / "",!, j ~t~ . ) ,~ Q K I, / , / / 'rfr", I ~;, '-~ I ~":"'.......... , '0-"' .:n . j 'q - - -- - '- '~.... ^' " r; "/ y;~ ---- ,. , ">") , , ..... .... ..' \, ( , .1i ~ ~ ~ .. ~ I ~ ~ , . . I$] - ( " -. , , '" ~ L._ 1-1 , ' iI, [lJ_,- f) "u! ""t '''...; '<' " '....... " ~ , " , , , ., ' 'V , " , "-, ~,~~ " -~' " , '" 5 9 ! '1 , '0 "d "~, " G)~ ~. "''- ~ " " '" ~ "" ;S,,'...... :tJ I .' ) ~/ / Vi' I l2I,/ '1/ \ ' ''--/ '" ~ r,. ( . .. ....~.~ f J h /~ / / \ .~ /Y / ('/ ,,~ / ~'.". ;f - I .~ r-t- - _ m m c!:S -en :;:::1 -z ~ln :It: ..., / I / l', / ./,: / " / " I " ,/ /f) / " .{ l' Ii. , /1 .' ':: I , "' / ,I' / /., / / , / // o ~ >_-G"", .- -,/'>/ 0' / !:::; ':r "" ,/ ! / / / I ( , ,~. j , .z:~ " ". ;! I if' "';" .~~. '-, .../ !> z o ~ m en --"l !>' ,., n ?" ~ ~ gJ I +--..-. - ~ :-- ~ r- n ~ VI Ci !:; '; ~ ~ 0 ]> ]> ;;; :r: n n ;;; '" :<l ., ... :I: VI :<l 'C 'U ~ 1) ... ,., .., ~ ~ z >< ~ r- 0 ~ VI 0 Vi 0 ~ ,., ,., ... ~ ". ;$I Z .;;: z ,., Z 0 ,., ., 1) ~ ~ C) :<l ,., z b 1) < '" ", z ,., ~ ~ lD ,., ,., :<l :<l ,., n C. c ~ ;r:: ;u lD ]> C VI 0 ~ =l ,., ;u Q c --I I '- - ~ __. I '. _I II I r . .s., ~<: .:. . ~'''\..;'. I -1-.- T ;'. 1 . I II ,. f ,~ " I' I,' /1 I t: I. I . D~ I / \:.,) Ii ----- ;; I " , ;; = -; /~ / I r ;; " (J ;: I I . I I r- ;r:: ~ !l? "'" c ~ 2 ~ ~ ;u :.: '" ,., R- n ,., ~ ,., ;u ~ r- Z ,., 0 Z I: :r " I ~ 0 ~ I " .. (f)'r . ~ . ' . .... ,. ~ .. '.': . - ..... 0)> . 1 ~, ..... :J> ~z t::J fI:10 (t) :7(f) . en ~() ...... Otl )> - ~ -0 m ~lfl U -0 i !~ II ~ lD ----- r 0 Z ----- 0 / ~ ----- lD ----- r 0 / ~ 0 '--. - ----- <D / ----- .. . i ~ ~ . i /, - ..... ------ i/ ~ .. -< 0 ~ 0> j ~ lD "0 r ----- '-.. :>J 0 ~ c;) 0 o . ,. l<l ;;l (}l .80 ------ ~ .. ------ S; i - ~ ; ~ : (; i i : i i ~ .. I C i - ~ 1a ~ ! - i l ~ i / (; = , . ---- ~ = -;:i"i--- ;:; ~ I:l w ~ ~ ~ ~ ;;l ----- _____1 0 "'s'l?Oo (",<,,'IOr:JtO ;:; 0 'ttl'.vr ;:: ~ lD r 0 i!.O ft ,l~5' 0 _ lr!&,~r '" h,t.: .~-i / ;:: ji ~f~:"~" . . · JrJJ!j :;; ............, Lt ..: ! -jj~I;~ . ;; ~~~~~~ ... - . . . $ .. ~ ~ 0 .. .~ ,. b -~ , .' ~ .' . . 0 \ . <: "" ,tJ'. .' ;: . 0 ,. ;;l .' I I I ,'<. 1 I - ~.. C) C)C) '" u . . ~ el) (Gel) el) . ':tt ;: 3! :J <b:J:J II- el) :JCl)Cl) @ _ ~g:J ;g::l:J ~ P c;- -~(i)(b 3-snoo :r ::r ::r - ~! ~ifi~~ ~ :Ii ~ o . 00 rn @. ~:0' G> 00 0 DO ~ ~ ~ Oo~ oO~ <:; , SOB I " I ~ iO ~g; ~ 0 .." III 1!1 ~ ~ :r ::;) -!- ~ I a } ~ i "l) zo ~ n B ;il '" u l';'I:;O .' ~ ~ Ii ~ 0 c C ... 0 ~ U~ ~ c;: ~ '" ~ cnc a c: 0 ~~ ~o~ ~ Hinp~ ~ H ~ i g I~ ~ ~ c !:l!; ~ j ~ ~ ~ I ,. n 11 I -OJ nUl 0 :::J iJ! z "' I_ ~'" ~ Sii ~ 20['; to ~ ~;~ .. 3 ~ c.n ~ '" i.l qR~~~~' s~ s~ ~~ ~ i~ i ! ~ ;; 0 ~ ~ '" ~8 f1;l:'" rill ~ I t'l"O ~ 8 ~- 5 ~! ~ ~S'I'i5.: <l 0 "tl~ ~ III ! ~~ E~I i ,,~~ ,. .. .~ H ~ -. c ~ ~ ., ~ .. ~ >- - 0 i; ~~~i ii.8: .. --I t""3:: ~ i ill J~ ... (f) )>- ~ ~~ '" 3~~ ~ ~ ~ -1- z.... 'a .. ~ ;;1;1 I: ~ ~........ ~ ,. ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ )> ~, .. ~ -! <i!. fi~~I~~~~ ~ ~ "C . ~ '" ill ~:;l ~ ~~ g ~ "C Cl ~ z if !2 (\ i iI ~ ~ r- 2 ~~ I: Cl ~ ;;; n ~ ~a ~~ ~.. '" )> .. 0 R ~~ ~ 'nl I~.i:! .... .0 0 ~ 5 i ~ :; 6 H~ ~~ ~lll .. .. ~ '-' el ~ z ~ ~ u u '" ~ q n~ ~ o. "0 . N f ~ ~ ~ ~ H ~ ... '" ~ ~ g ~ i ....- ~- ~ I ~~ ~ ~ ~ z ~~ ~ iJ ~ "\!! S~ g~o .. ~ ,.~ MMM ~ <> -CJl- P'I ~ ~o ~~~ = . u - M 0 <> '" ;;l 3 I: 8 '" '" ~ ,. I ~ "lj ~ u (1) UJ ....... O'Q ~ i I ilf ;1 PJ i ~-;-'i~ III ~ z ~ z Z - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s: ~ ~ @ - ~ ~ ~ o 1 7 ~ j ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ 2 :: -;-~ ~ ~ ~ N t: r;l - 0 !" ~ '" ~ 8 ~ __ ~~-- ~ ;Jl 0: - a.QO 5'2.:;1 [~:!i~~~!~ ::t~:s.x.!l~~!~ ~ !h~g ~g ~~ ~::i s:p!.lI ii'. ii' ~!8.n!7~~~!7 -"O_~~.!~ . · ~~ ~ ~.i3.~t;l~ '.~~- "<eG'Q i3;~ ~Q. ~ !i1 0 l'l -~~~i~~ ~~~~~; s: N ~ : ~ ~ "1 ~ .. !~ fi~~t @ , ~ ~ i J~J~! I, ~ -~ ir5"~ ,~ ~_. 9. n <= . ~ ~ '" . !i1 f;5: ~ ;; i zo " 5lc: p Ow ;l>t"l '1:l t"l'1:l t"l C:tl (l;S:: :r:::J ..., z~ (l'1:l '1:lC t""n ;l>;l> z::J o Z tD (J1 o I o - 0 ~ CD N o ~ ~ L z p ~ '" 2 ~ ~ =' 2 '" '" o ~ ~ ~ ;;I z p ~ III ~ ~ 'jj =' ~ '" '" o ~ o ~ i ~ ~ 9,: o , o o '" " ~ 'r )> Z o Cf) o )> "'U m r G) I -l Z G) "'U r )> Z """,\~"'" ,.~".~\\"~ ~. ..:.' ~ ~tr J, ".r \, ~~ /; I r <DJg 'i;~ ~ ~ :>~A c> ::? CUi:") () ""':l ~~~ ~ ~ ~ :j~.~ ~~ ~ ~ ~;Q.., T~ ~ =l~t: "'-J c . Zl/I::j C) ~~~ ~ ~ 'i> 0 < C) lD~c , M8~ ~ ;:':eo g;~ :(:l::C') -c':l~ !""~~ , ; I '{ J, ;f.l '-:"~ ~i.> / I / / '. 'f I I" / II " ~ / I / ~ ..1. , '. Ji'f;"t 1'/ , ..1 ~. ' ~' ,V;; . / I ~~ ~ . iy' /~ 1~';'.: I~. ,.,e .,' ~,~ . . ..l -f 10 LI --r . ,(- ,.. / Ti, I \, ~ t' ~ \ , I.~.." " ~'~.... >> \ "l., 1/ " . ~, ~ ;iI i 'j to/.f ,'" / r It /1' \)} -t!~i~ ! " /j //// 1 /! ; r,(~'( ,,' ,if 0 > / ! :: / I ;:; "! rom ~x r- - ocn ---l z- G)~ -oJ " 11..,'0: '. , :;: ," 'j ;e I I / 4) )_: I / 'J f / ~, I 0,~ ,...,~~."'.. t- ~'. I .j < J. \\~ / /, ;' ;( ;j, I / ! 0' I I .. . " " \ \..) >; ( / <0 ~i- Ii " :.r I ::; o .. .. ~ '" 0 l ~ '0 , ~2~~Hj ~~~ ~ )> III " 0 ;;:: ~ ~~~"'~ ~ ,J 'i VI 'D c, ;; ';' ~ l5 15 :;0. ~~o g ,~, " ~ , ;;; 1\ "" f"Tl '0 ~~~M~~ ~~~ 0 ~ Gl ~ ~:e:~~", :b~ i f"Tl 0 Z VI ~~~~~~ :t~1 0 ~ ,. ~~~g~~ ~~ , ~ S~~_I i:: f'Tl:!:. > '" " ~~8bo.~ t " ~ N I~~~~ 5l 0 12 fi8U'l. ;:;:j <D 0 :J:;u~t""lO '0 ~ ;g~~~~ 0 '0 ~ !""'102 :u 8~ I. _~'. ~;;. ..~.: '-'" ~ '" S6 ~ ~ ~ C\ " ~ I~~ ~ ~2'l'~5 ~ ~i;;, F:^ ~ ~~~"~~.:.! ~o' ~ "'~~~~6 g;'j'H ~ ~"'O~f'Tlz,..<;: ~2:; ~ 8 FfT1;u;c:)> I I ~ ~-~o "'T'I "'O:E_ .-i;; ;f~{; ~ VI-o 'f ~~~~;;c: ~I ~~~OC'io ".,? ~~E-:d t1' ~.I~ 'A ~ ~~!~~ VI C)o:r' ~ ~ ~~~88 ~ ~ ~2? ~ Sti ~8 r~m'- ..>" " . ' I, i !:~a) ~~~ .'. ~ ~ z '" [;1 ~ n I 0 ~ zr f-"(j 0)> ~ cnZ d ~O (1) F;;en CIl 0 ....... O'Q )> ~ "U m ~n~ a m i !i It r m ~ m z -., en z p ------ i ~ I ~ ~====Jl I ~ ~====J~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ " ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ !f ~ ill ~ al I ~ " ~ " iZ 'i! iZ - 'if \3 'if 'if :: c I~ l~ I 'if i '" '0( ~TTT--~ -----11 -----I~ <: i~:!~~~!2.~ - ~~~h:ih f![2.~~:["; .H~i'~:..j~ !l- .3~.Q- . ~loa~a&~~~ o h}_~"~f;l'll !!.~oa _ '< el>>-8 9.Jii"p ~Q. ~ - j ~ lQ ~ ~ ~ ;g i ~ F. ~ ~ ~ ?; ~ ~ > al al ~ ;:e: <; ~ ~ 0; ~ H [fill ~ ~~ ~-~~~ Q c ~ 8 > -;T ir-- - - ~ ~ -. ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ .. i - > ~ ;o! z " z p -OJ <:Jl o I o ;; g " ~~ ~ zo o we:: ow :>>t'1 "'0 t'1"'O t'1t'1 r-::O t'1e:: :::-3 t'1:>> Z-o Ul-o r- n :>> -3 ~ ~ f. ~ o ~ ~ ~ l/l 'if ~ ;; " 'if ~ l/l 'if c ~ ~ ~ <5 :: ~ <: ;: "-.. .. 0; \ ::; '\ \\ " ~ ~ ~. ;; 0; ~ o ~ L I ~ zr 'lj 0)> :P ClJz U ~o (]) ~cn C/l () ,...,. )> (JQ ~ '"U m !JIU a '"U i i~ r n )> u Pf Z -i ~! s:: t )> -i Iz m p ---- :::0 )> r ~ III 2 0 ~ !i =' 2 ~> ~~ co -< ---- 0 > I'" ------ . ====~ li .~ i" p ---- "jj~ 2 2 '!; z - ~ ~ ~ '5 0 ~~ ~~ ~ ~ l:: f~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r ~ ~ 2 III i I 0 I~ L ~ ill ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i! Ia :: - 2 ~ 2 ,=' 2 12 :: ----I 'co ,-< I ~~~--Io N N .... I ... 0 (.,I "" I> N ~ ~ ~ ~ ---,~ 100 ---I~ ;;: ~~o~~~~!2.~ ~~:i'll!t~..~h ~;:i;:io&~~ ~?:g.-'C 1( :r~~l ~!l~~!;clt~ii" ~~ o~~. i~r if :;: p ~o ;'~~[!;;l~ !!.iCl- '< ~lt-8 g.ii'~ ~1It ! , ~ - ~ ~ 1; c c l'J 00 '" .. > III ~ ,. ,. I 2 co co co ~ co Z " " " " 0 ;;. ~ ~ > c III !t a; c > '" I , , , - H [fIll ~ u ~J~~~ -q ~5"' ~~ ~ ~ p ~ . ; i " z P -1:0 CJ1 o I o ;; 0 .., o ~ ~ L :r-:' l' _ ' . '~~""".' : "'\:; ;",,~' ,loI.'~'. ~.~.~~~' ..~<, ,:~' -/~ ,'.. :~~ 'I :'-'-"i r-a.',:,",Jj.; ~~~ J..~ '~""\"'R'-~" ~" _ ir~:'1".~~-l.f'.;o '."- ..r ,.J 'Y-',~,;. \ ." , ~.oIf : ,-~'fk.~l(f, ..,.~.' ,.x -'~~~'~~" ",~.~:GI ~ ,.J. ~~~:..,\.....~., ",....1,. Co ~~,~"t:. .;\~::~~. ",'Jf.t.~: ~" ~i h ~ :.. :--::,';, ~-;1>>?Y:^(~~.\(f{f'.:')!)~~ _._,~~..,;.\.. ' I.-e,"~~~',~,,~ . .. .j;~?' .',~i~~;~l . ! y: ;t;hf?:;ijSb', ~..) .\~.:., .t'\?~f.~~}_.;\: (~,I '." ,'~'f., ~::.t'i~~'::-~J!.f . ' -<, -:; _ (," ~ ,~~ ~.~~r 1't,~ .~.~' :- "... ';>' '~""'~"'''i 1>~ ., ,~ :', ~~.';'" ,1;{;,,;\ '~~H '.) ~ ',,',. Iy .,-'......~ ,":..~.:. ,~~ -".....-..:;.:.~ ~~~.,..~;1;,.;<~i': --'1 " ! ~::;.:r~t'i1~~":, , , \' / ~:;...!. ;jJ9"" :~ ./ I ~!lV'); ,-;.:,,<,;t!~!fr'.~:;,., ( . i"'\ j' . ~~~~;,::;.~ ~'~~lt /, " y~ '\'..i:~~!:fi- ~fr. ':' ...;"J, ~ \~~<:'i,';',,~"'" tr ; - . '. .,~;:J~~~:?>.1~~-.d-'~~~~{~~' =' ---, t""1:O ~ ;l>CJ1 zo ~ 0 ~~ we: ow ~~ ~ ~! ;l>t'l "0 ~ ~ !~ t'l"O " t'l ~ "O::<l ~ "; t"";;:: ;1>_ 3 z-3 -3;1> i ;;::"0 ~ ;1>"0 -3C t'lo ::<l;l> --3 '" ~ ;1>_ ~ t""o Z > ~ ~ f 0 I~ ~~ 'i :-i:" ';~~~~~l-.~.... j) ~,-~y .;...,:r.~ ~/": < r i';-';;;'-,,~ ,~.~~~., _ _.~ ~(;J.,""~"'~.fI':. "'O:"'U...".. ",' '9'l.;,1,~ . ,#'.",,, -it ~':;:.: ~~... , ,,- ,.\11 " I" _~~.,~. , J~\~~\.... 1~1.. ';;:;-(/t ~ . :"~;~;';':~I~.... ,/,;,,('c,. '. -'l!fl,",~", ~;;~~ ;'~; :;:';;<!i~~1 ' ;. ,.,.+'_.....,~/(. ir.,. ~,.-~";~'N-: " -~~~:il~(k! . ~.: ....~)J~ :" .: 't-Y.fI,~~. 'f~..}.' , ,'; "~. .:.:... '- : ~..:};t,~t.~i" ~~, . ~.~......., ~I i~ E; S i ,-f..,., ~~.;.I~:';r~.: 1 ~:f' :~~ OJ ,...c~r,...::.. .~1>.~"~~,.".... r /;~; . .: 'f1' : f'-- 'to ..' jt;'..~.:'; '".~, .;:. J,r' 'i,-t 1,~' I"~, .,,~ ':"'.,';... ~ ",,:.[ ~t~~ >.. ~.!'f':_.:"'~~'., ~~ ~ -~;"'~- ~, 'J'~ :l'i di', ,'~i . ',.':0'<"1\\ 't'(..j,t.r,"tiJ'<':,,~ ';. ~, .: """"~"'\'~'~-:!~"'.i;",i'"~"'." ~'~) r .~ ' .~_r, .,t~"'.".- ',~':(.f. 'l.' ';~. ."'..r:':~tl~.-,..-;..'"',,'~':f.... l:)-~' ',- 1" 'S.l~~ '11 ,r. l '.' -{~ -I~"r J~:"Q , ~,,": ,.':;.." .11- ..., "'. .p\,,,:,,,,~.,~..., '~~.. ~.. L.., ". f-;.f" \);J, ,.", ", ' . ... '.t,/" < ~" :.t..~" 1, ~ '"'" ~ t, t ~"\ '-,).,~,~~.. t,.(i 1~ ..... :'" ", "'!,"""'~'r.I.1' .~. ,:","""#.. .' 's.,l'~ _ .~',.' - '.-.4 " t._ ,;. ~~ ~~ ~i i \" "16'). i.~~.. ....:::;". _ ',..~,..}'i\.. ':;"', . ~ - ':Jf,rt.,:V3~, ,,). },; ;;~-l~}~: .f~. . '"), ~M~~' So' '..J. .. ).:1" :,f~ ~, ' ;'J ''-'''"l5 "" .b''':'" t~ ",,'~.--:;;, ""'" "~ "" :-., . OX1. ,d . '. ~ C',.~. "f -- :-~.::~:!.} "/, .,.-;' . t, ~ ;;: ;;; .. ;;. a; ~ ~; ~1 I .., o ;; ;; ~ r o n ~ : ~ %~ , ~ \Z::J ! "~ i ., . .. ~ i ! ~ ~ i ~ ~ . ------ IP il II: i ~ ~ I m If If i = ~ ----- - = J ~ ~ N ; j i ij ~ ----- - i ~ i: _ it;ilIH~i Ii .~I.rw~ 0: '11] !:I'I It, " ~ -JJJ;IS ~~~~~p. ~ I . i ____1._ ;; ;; ~ I I I I - IS.. Q QQQ ilOlJ .JJ reI' 0 :~~ _ ~~:J .:J:J ... ~ r" ....... . - .-- A AAA ~ 2' 2' - ~I ~"~~ ;; I' ~m ~ ~@ - 8l Sl'il o "'ll . ~ ~~ ?J~ ~t3 00 ~!j ~ 0 Z ~ ---, ~ f !i J 8 ;:' ~ ,. '" It; @ ::; A ~ e K :I: o 1 @ @ - . "", 8 .., , '" ~ <:J 8 .. "Tl ::0 (f) -i "Tl r o o ::0 "'U r )> Z --r -< o ...- i:j] I I ~ I III III ~ 000 ~] ,,~v?LJ~,J _____ ____ I I Nt,- I JV::l- II 1>-" .. ,>" ~.. · ~vu l .'ll 1 I I ... rvL-.....lll I.{ 1 I I ~ ; 1 ~-1Yl ~ '~~~>: -: : !, ~ (1 ~7 1 ~d----a c,~~IU/J~cr:.R~ >- I ~ I ~r i'1fTl i ' V-~-~~ I i I ~ I l I I X\:'r^JI~, L a II:-~ I ~~J , " ~=:n;l V-J _ ~ I:;, t!! I JJ'-(f 1,0'-6' l 22'-4' JJ'-rf I JJ'-rf 1 1 1 ,u I I I 286'-rf I e .., ~ ~ ~ co -',- -@ (]) ~ ~ 'I e ~ I~ I I ~ ~ -}., -@ 10. - .6.,,~ ,- e .. il = N - 0 ,_,0, -8 i: ... III "" . ~ ~ -<:J ~.- -8 0: ... 1 >- >- >- ",FIlIIIIllIIIl1 C \\1 II - [lllIIllIIIIIl.'l l'i, I~ ~' · \\i ~ III III III '~~I T - I " , ,) 'I I \~~"I I r- 'I 1 I; .7 i .., ~ I I '" '" -",-- @ (]) ~ ~ ~. e ;; V II III I J III ~..J . ~ .J" II I ;; ;; . ~ !i L o ~ " "II II , ~ ,,'-rf J , I ,U j @ <D 22'-rf 1 f I I e JJ'-rf JJ'-(f 22'-(f JJ'-(f e o (0 e G <6 e (f) m () o z o "Tl r o o ::0 "'U r )> Z I=-=-~~- .. - I .. r--t 11I-[:'7 'yf'~ .. 'xl I .. .11,1 S/" __J II. II irH' ?'U · · ~ I ~'t II II-,j I I '" I/~ U >- i -:Lf'f B [ r ' ~Il l , I ~-.;l :-..-, '- ~ .:~ ; " : I -"r,r I - .-1 ]TI~/, ? r~ II III .. III ..,... "'T'" .. .. p ~ I l1'-rf I JJ'-rf JJ'-(f I 22'-rf J3'-rf J3' -(f 22' rf 22'-4' @J <6 I e I I I I <0 ~ ! 286'-rf I o e I 8 e e (0 K o " :I: o n .. I o I ~ o q. !l ~gl ~f . ~I ~~ r hill ~ II co i ! .., ------ ~ ~ I ~ II . ------ I I I i -III : 0111- i ~ ~ i - ~ ~ ~ ! :: ~ ="T'j"'j"-- Nlljl_~ I ~ 0: _ '1;1I:! "i' I!:!l.:'-Ir~ii i l'II'..Jt.. : J"lrj :!:IJ f tJ!f ~ - fffff~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ .. I 0: 0: ~ 0: I"I~ ~ 53 - m i!:lWJ o Oou . ~ I! S~ 00 ~!j ~~ l!l T !I L . o z z :5 N U, 8 '-I I ;U o "T1 r o o ;U "'U r )> Z "T1 o c ;U -I I "T1 r o o ;U "'U s;: Z 0: 0: " % CJ r u a.-.u Il ~J j = 1 - r--~~ I I ~ _'-----'"' r I oJ 9/""~ .., .., ~ .... /~ r ~,~, ; X_lf~ 1-.-1 ' "<, _ --vr ~I---li~ ~'" :>- II ----,ft..!.. ...Irl..J'I'~ ,.J,,--,f ~ .." :c. I I ~11'-0" l I I ~ <6 I I 1,0,-6' l 1 1 I I 8 6 22'-0" I 1~ I e 12'-4" I JJ'--O" ," I 285'-0" I e JJ'-O" 33'-0" JJ' -0" 1 I e l' , G o d..__ ___ _ _ __ __ ___ _ r .: I~ II ~}\ ~ --!..1 ~ -.!J, f (II l_ " · aJJX" I -1:< i-I J:S ~/c-----"'-~ _ -< ~ ell ,... ; 11'-0" "1'--0" ; 11'-0" I , 1,0'-6' 1 JJ'--O" 33'--0" o II i'i]; ... -",-.\- 0 \:: ~ - -~ "j) - - - -@ ,I ~~, e i ~ IZ:: ~ ~ ~ ! ~fS '" I- I I , , I , II 1''\1... - l:I JJ'-O" 33'-0" 22'-0" 1~ l' , .{ 11:I ~( ..@ I -0 \:: ~ - ~,- .-8 \:: ~ - -},! --@ --{:!....... e -1<-", - 0 \:: .- q ~ - -@ e ~ ~ "' ~ .. ~- -@ o 8 e <w ~ ~ ~ 'I - -~, e ~ r~ ~ ~ ~ I ...J'[? I I = ..,... \:: ,- q @ ..'....... e 1- I I I ~ @ c:> e 1 I G ~ 22'-4" JJ'-O" 33'-0" JJ'-O" 33'-0" 266'-0" I I I e e 0 8 e 0 ~ e " % CJ i ~ z~ ! ~ i . . o ... .. > . .. o :: N 0: : 0: 0: :< 0: ;;; l!l !I .. > .J I o z , '11 I ~ . 9- ,,:RS ;~ &S!ii ;. ~I ; h ~! 11 -l I 11 r o o ;0 '1J r )> Z Ii ------ i ! z " % D '" o n .. > .. " .... ------ !I ----- - I I I I I I I ~ 1 I 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 ------ 0 0 e co I ----- - ~ ----- - Ii . ------ I I i - ; ; ~ I I i g o . - ! - - . 1& = = ----- - !I =1'"f"f-- Nl111_~ N I , ;0 ----- - 0 ~ 0 .. 11 .. - It:y: ~rj '1J @ r )> h.11ii,; z ; 1J!/! ~ ; . . . . . - I I I I ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;; t I ;;; . I ------ ;;; .. ~ - I" Q QQ ill · if. · 0 I I I ~ ~~ I -rg. ~.. 1 1 1 1 .1 1 1 1 1 1 ; ~m~ ::; ~ -;... ..... -. I :: '" e R'>?? v. - ~! 5'aJ5'5' ft ftft .1' ~g ~---, :,g . ~ ~g -gl ol:'!l 0 :I:l"tl 1 ~~ 0 - ... .. .. CD ~~ :3 O"tl 'zJt:: ~ "tIO I!l 5~ .., ~ I!l . z@) :z: , ! ~ ; ~ - i . !:f !:f . I 0 Z Z " % D '" 0 n .. > -.J L I o I. ~ : 9- i~~~ f. . ~I'~ ; h.lI.. II co i ! ~ ~ I ~ II . ------ I I -; . I I I - I I = ~ :ljj-- Nll11_~ I ~ 0: 'Iltl'illj"i _ ~.lr! w Ii . -I..t It :t:~ arwJw 0: '1ltdlllJf t, "I~ -jjjl;~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i: ~ I .. ;; i:l ;; ~ I I I I I - I. Q QQ ~ .m. III 11I11I ~ig. ,. ;:j ~ -I::' I.::.::. ~ -: II ~;.7..7 - ~ S :r!rT:r:r .. pPPpp iii ~I ~m ~ ~~ -! ~i ;; ~ ~~ :z: ~ "ll ~ ~ I!l 0 :z: ~ , ~ ! ~ i . . ~ !:I L o .. 0: z o :::0 -., I m r m < )> -., o z ~r c [7.1 ~ 0: " % Cl -.- n --- t . I I I ~ I ~ p "" s ~ " =l - 8 ~ s ill ~ ~ ~ < " ~ dl . I~ I 1-,,-1_; _\ I L~_, ~ ~ - I-'-f- '7 :=l' -! !I' ~ --~- -.- ~ ~ ~ p / / ~ z ... -e ----@ ----e ~ ~ ---e n o '~ ;lI ~ i==== i 'I = ~ I JI= I ~_____"~::==_m ;;;; ,:;:;~,~~-',~;; I ~ ~~~ ~ I ~ ~i: ; " ~ ~ 1-::: 2[ [Lii ~ ~ ~ I I I p~ p~ y ~ I :~~ ~~ I pi i!;~ ~ p~ l'! ~ I p~ ~ p~ y Cl -e -----@ -@ ----e I s:l P!;1 ~ ... " n lD . . co is = N 0: 0: ;; ;; ;:j iii ;; I!l !:I n . I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~[!l :.. :!:P(')~ ~~~:t , ~:i;l 8~~~ <<ooll -==f '" S II! ~ o ~ '" '0 ;j ~ m -< o ~ ~ - -- ~~ -- -t p 0 0 0 .. '" '" '" i ~ ~ !i ~ '" ~ ~ ~ ~ 'i ~ ~ ~ ~ '" m m m ~ S c; ~ c; e: \1 II! e: \1 0 ~ ill ill ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ in '" '" ~ ~ '0 0 in in ~ - z II! II! 0 0 z z ::: m -< ~ ~ ; ~ ~ e ~ ~ ~ ~!~..::._-;- - ~ o ~ o ~ ;;I 0: a-!o~~:&~~~ 3 g:;'8 :; . iil ~ ~ ~ rH~~iHH it~~:~:[l~~ : ~ ~ : ~ [~g g. ;t-g , H~; ~[.! g ~ '" ~ . ~ n .. .. i II! ~ .. .. .. !i .. '" '" '" ~ m ~ '" '" ~ -< -< -< z " ~ ~ .. ~ ~ ~ 0 ;;; ~ ~ (;)(;1> :r g ~ ill ~lQiIl g i!~:r g~o 0 ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~~ ::; . '" ";>_#Oo@ @ ~~~O~<O ~ ~ ~ n g.~~ 8 " ~ '?f'7. . . s ~ -:r:i':i':i' Ii. ~~ ~n!D!t~ ;j g UJto F' ~ a; ~ OCJ1 .. co ~ "'lc z p :I:UJ to t"lt"l CJ1 ~"O 0 I <t"l 0 >:<l .... ...,;;:: ;;; CJ1 0=3 z ~ "0 t"" n > ..., ~ 0 0 z '" ~ '" ~ 0 L :oJ !;; z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o 'Cf) o C -l I m r m ~ -l o Z i!: " '" ~ ~ " ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t 11 z ~ ~ ~ --, =\ ~ " ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~, ~ "- -----~ ~ , ~ - - -----=:: :::: 0> 1 -----; -. . " :q !~ I:TrrmT] ~ ~ ~p ~ !;i;,;o <;;.;~ .!>!~ -e -----e ~--8 ~ ~~ " .. .. g p~ Pg ~~ ~~ '" ~'i! p~ g:~ .. x n '1';0 .;~ "Iz ~ p~ ~e: . ;0 .;~ 0 "';0 ~~ 0 ;;0 .;~ 0 .;~ 0 0 ~ -=~II"'I -- I~- " [3 ~ ,. o -----@ ::: ;:; --8 0: . " '" ::; a; ;;; ~ o ~ I ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~B~~ t uo n z ~ is~~:r J . ~~~~ 8&li:!2; i z p " ~ ~ ~ ~ ;; " 'l '" -< " ~ ~ ~ " ~ z " ~ ~ ~ \1 ~ ~ ~ - ~ ., '" " l; <5 " ~ Vi III - 'l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;:; g :IE :IE ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'l ~ ~ ~ I I " ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " ~ '" III 'l g '" Q ;; " }1 :: '" -< :: B ~ ~ ;." ;." :..:- 0 ..... 0 (.0 .... t.oo ~ ~!111_ ~ " ~ <:: i~:~~~~[~~ g.. 'g -.. ii"~! Q. ~-g,;J.:ta_2.~o i~~:~~ ~g:[l ~~ [;:~;~ ~~ii' . ~"Xoa~~~~!'~ fI ~.~~.g."'~~;r~ ~.~~.~ ~.[..! ->>->)>O~~ ~ ~ j i 2 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ @ .. ~ ~ ~ ;;; " ~ - 8 ~ ~Q"f~ G>~~ :3=:: g~~::>lD;::>," ..... i-.J )3 '::>::)II'OO~~~ ~ ~~~ ~f~~~ ~ ~ ~ ?-~?'?~ ' . ~ --""-- , - nC :i:J-:i:i ~,.., !'P1'!'!t " ------, ~ '" " ~ ~ 9.: < " ~ :< ~ 'm )> (J) -I m r m < )> -I o Z ? ~ ~ ~ ~ -;; /1 .,.', 1..- " ~. H- II 7"~I.' '.,." /' ,Ii q:;~~'~ -- :11- , - Z5 ~ :- ~ I ,-+1 , i "1_ I - i~. _ Ii Ii I ~= I ..... ............ - L'-l'''- ~ -- ~ =-1' ! ~, I-- .-- '7." _ ~ =':=_ J1,'__ .i.' :-- ~l. 1_ 1.1-1- ~ ~ c " ~ / Ii ~J1 ,~"I - I --r .-'_':1'1 -- I I, +-- -@ ----@ -----e -e n ~ ----8 ~ o ~ ------ I-- 11 -h I- ""1 ,J, -; ~ .- , 'j - ~ : -i-- - - ___,I :v/ ~ /' - - w I p~ ~ n ~ " ,. ~ ,,\z $ ----@ -----e <5 :: -e ;:; ----e <:: :; 8 " --e ;;; ~ .., " ~ -- --- , ~ \I I-< hi -11-1 ,- - f- t? - If.-;- -- -- --l ....- -iI- ,-- .-- f-- -----@) ;:; '~ I I .' I ;';.-~--.'- .i~ . ~- -" '-'-I -r-'-'-f--'- - I -!'fi ~ car J:1' ~ .' I,t' ., :Rj ,:c.,~ ',' <,:'l,~ ;~ -": _ '- - I i- ~ , ~, !I : =-= 1\' , I ! ~ ~ \I ~ ~ I " ~ p~ f~ "\,, ~ _. ;k " f- -.-- c; == ~~I ..~, - --- \ 1"!1: =,-l I I -8 0; I 'il p~ ih.'l , /'; "'~ ~ ;;; -,-....--..j - 1111-11- · i; .. ,l ' II":' 41 J . II I II ill- ~, I II .~ jl i----' ill: ' :.L..H ~i:! - ! -! 'II'; ! I ~ ~............... ' -- o z -p I ,/ i-f-- < ,~ " ,....::;::. ~~ 'I ~ ;~~ Ii :: .~ '~i I-- _ I\=LW ~ !ll' V/ I "---', :, ~, 11 L- , -~ .." \ ~ I' d '::;0 ~~ ~ rg ~~ ~ '" o ~ ~ L ~" ... 1-1:- I I :1, _ - - - - - f-.- - - ,-' - :r o f-.- , "1 f--~ II-- '1- L-lL ~_ -~.~ ~ f-.- ..1, illl : - :. , ! 1--' _! I- 1= ,'-- 'iri;~ ~ l .. 1"1:H- II ~ N U, I ij II ~ ~ i'l OJ ~~iJI ~ ~; r&~ 18 p~ 0;;0 ~ p~ ~;o ,- 8 "\" ~ I ~ ~ ~ q.. - .~~~ ~'" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~~~;J ; ~ 8~f~-~ z p " ~ " '" !f ~ <;J 'ij 2 '" -< " ~ M ~ " " ~ M z p <C"i~g~ !l! !lI !a z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ::u ~ Cl -~~~~ 11 11 ::E I: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ... 0 C C o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ OJ !!I I: J: >- _ ~ ~ ~ r- , !f!f " ~ " '" ~ Ii: ~ ~ :: '" -< -;-s- ~ ~ 0 ~ E ~ 2 ~ ~ ~!!~- j " ~ <;: ~~o~~g~?:~~ ~ g~~ ~~ ur~ ~ a [HH~HH . '0... a. ~ . :t g f' ; ; ~~.;~.[~~f~a ~,~.g"- ~g."~ g.. ii'~ :l - ~ - )0. ,. )0. ~ g ~ :g :g il ~ '" '" ~ ~ ;0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " " 8 .. ~ ~ u; '" " ~ - ill li;'j &l~ ~ ~ @ QjQ@ @ i!~ ;:'3g~~ ....,It~ If!ICDU::::i'~1 ~ ~ .... ~a.~.o.fIOo ::: ~:<i\l@(I)O@@ ~>~ nonftn~ 8 ~ : ?;r:r?;B 8;$; ____ , - ~ ~ ;";J g :i ~ !" r1 fb r>. !,:Q ----, ~'::l1tIl ; i E;5 g; " ~ z c:: 9 t'1(J) - tIl ~t"l CJ1 <"0 'j' >t"l _ 8 g~ '" -J z:=3 " ~ ~ " 20 "0 c: () > ~ o Z ~ ~ ~ " ill f: L " ; "-11 f- iil f-: U - I: t-------cl I"i~ "'1:11,11' = - ~ .. I ~ , rrm.. I ~ II ~ Ifl'li'lll! ~II 11 c= r1 ;,,~, ,~- '~ m en ~ m r m ~ ~ o z ~ ,. ~ B z a; ~ c-> ~ ~ ~ r---. f- , .1 lmo I- 17 B z ~ " z ~ ---- o tt. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~p ~ '<0 ;:: :"'~8 ;~ " t l - ~ I ~ j , I~ ~ H I,J I , i I tl1t C1 ?~ ift~ I"\! I I i: +-, I ;- I :<J p~ ~~ "I" ~ p~ ~~ "I" ~ ~I~ ~I ,~ JJlk f- ~ 1 I~ R ~ ~ -- I- ~ "I- , m:~1 .~ ~ ~ I., -TJ I Jl'_ _'-' l& _ _J - -11._ ,_,_ '\ ; ~ I a p~ ~~ ~ ,/ 1--11 ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ h.,- /. . ~-- ," ---I I -== -- --1 ~f- -- tfu= == 11- ~ -- f-- f-- -- I": -- f-- f-- f-- f-- -- L_ ..,,1 ;:,:~, ~~:~_ .rt'-~..__~_ -- ~~~ -- I -- -- -- " -- f-- L 11"'1 ..J \ ~ C\ ~ ~ p~ ~~ "I" ~ PS h ~ rr- o =~~ ,. / r -=:~ ~ ~ ~ I~. ,I ---.J f- ===:::J - -~ c ~ 8 p~ , ~ ~ n (rJ "Iz ~ ---G -@ ----e --e ~ ----e o ----8 :: ---e ~ ---@ <;: --e ~ --e u; '" --e ::: --@ -@ ;;; ;;; r.l p ~ ~~ ~ ~ " " -1 I o I ~ JR! ~ · iUs J' .. --j .-- ~ ; ---- -dP g I I I ~ ~ - ~ · i ~ - . i ; ~ ; I Z Z i :: ~ ~J"f"f-- Nlll1_: __1 c: _ Jt:jil!i"i It 'r~:!ii ; J~~d!lIJi tJ "I~ -JJJI;S - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .. ~ m . Id --- .. ~ i ! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ z - !s f fQ 11.!l.'! lUg! _ Ii!l::r ~::r::r ..., ,. 8'" :;...... ii:81 II IS :..1" 1"':6' - ~ S !i'!W-:' ppp~~ .. I' ~~ ~ -, ~ ~ rJ.Ig - 81 ~I:".l o ::!"I:l - g ~~ . CD ~ ~ "I:l ~ ~ o Z 1!I , r ! !:I i I L 0 ~ 9- 'en -I m en m o -I o z en i5 N v, 8 To ~ "' " % o o n .. m )( iij z Cl ~ 95'-6" " 16'-6" ,~~~, 16'--0' = ~ E; s: [~-- --1 , ~ 1-1 I~B.._ ~ .- !i " co ,~ c:----- [r==~L [---- - - ----= - D- -- , .. - eft '1'~5': L 3'-6" r [========='f :::J ~~ [=,: ----.; - - - : ~~~ :: g 1- =-4 [=-:: == == == ===r;:~ i "' " [---------- N :-n -=----,~ -,-~ c: ~ [ =::::;:: =_ _ _ I. TI - -----.- --- ' ; iB- -=-:----T-.i~ CD ;; c--~-. , L"-' -~ C- ---- - - - - -- - I ~ ~--::::-::- z f~ g ~ :0 .3 -l =~] " :<g /,2; ~rii >0 -<m ~ :0 ~ .. LL=c=cn I: ~, 1 ,'1 1- N ,,'" C-' s: eft "'ll ill i~' 16'-0' 16' 0' :II 8' "~~~ 16'--0' ,15'--0' (J> I" '--""-"-; ~ L ~ ~ 95'-{) -l :0 ill (J> ~ I I II~ ;; m )( iij z Cl ~ ~ ~ .. 1!I m )( en -l z Cl 8i !:I z o n .. .. .J % 0 r " E " m r m < )> -i 0 Z 0 m E ~ -i )> ;111 f r I 0 C allJ ;0 Ii -i Z ~ ~ € co )> ~ " c r z II i r I! ~ ~ ~ < ~ ~ " ! ~ ~ m ^ (J) ^ I~~ Y' -i - v ~v ." I )> ...--- --- 0 '"~ / ~ )> Vl7 ~ 0 1/1/ ~ m - 1 f--- co " n . . ~ ~ ~ ~ :f ~ Vl~ ~ -..r ~~ ~~ a2;c ~i II~ ~~ ~~ //" ~/! ~- n ~ " ~ ~ " ~ ~ ~ " " " ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ co A-~illl' V I - - ~_.. ~ ~ I I ~ -IIi-= - ; ;; , .lId I :iiP I I ===-:- ~ _ L\~,:J Ii ---- I ---.-------.- (; :: I -' - ^ Y ^ v ^ v :: --- ~ -:;-....,. j" . N ; ; i j ~ ---'----1 ---- - N ~ w 0 'Iltft 1 ..~ 0- p ~ .lrU ~ J ~ ~ e~~~ ~~i" ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ I !l..:' "4" ~ ~ i:l F 'e '-"'ffi "I; r if ..r.. .. t,~ 8 ~~ " p~ "I i!; z~ .. .1 Jf ; i'i ~~'i1!'l .ill;::; ~~ · ,}ltt ! " "~51"l~ -~~ 1". I ;1 ! i'] 1-"]1 ~ i:l/li2l~'" n~ I "-8JO: '~J' J~.' '.J' J ~ ., N- ~--.- '= '4-' - HilI! dc" _ ____ · n I I n " '_0' ~- - ,l- '1_ O"t ~ . iL ;;; --- i ~ : : ~ n I I " I I . . , . , ~ ! ----1-+-1 - ,Hf~[--------h' v' ;< p - 8'" So.. - 8= ftc. ~-..7 ..7 - ~ S S!WSS ~ ..Pp.... . . . i I I I I I I ,I ____ - -r- - t-m - J' w ~ $;, t& ~5! h . H -~ .l,~ .l,1;j ;; ;;; ~ ;< ;;; I ~g ~ l=g - 51 to toil f ~'ll ;;; ~ ~! >~ 'll ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;;; o L r"" I I il .1 ~ t · J I, ~ !I N V. ;r- !I L " " E " % o n . . ..J r o z IE % o o n lD > i ~ ~hJ 'I'i . .;11, ~ .. i I' !~ ~, ...- M IJ In i DI II i ~I -~ _~.'=~ -dJ~ - ::1- -, @ I, I --.1- I --- I --- 'I! I -1:- ---@ , ' I Q "I I V ----1---8 I I I /' II m r m - < )> --i o Z - o m --i )> r - I --i -< . "'U o )> r "'U ::0 m o )> (j) --i - G) r )> (j) (j) )> --l r - )> OJ (j) lD __ !l_, ~ __~~~~ 1'1 'i~l<, ' , .~g, 6'-0' il\!E ' I ill J ;;! ?i'~/'c~, ,3 -0' ,3'-6' l ~ p~" p'l ~~!!l ~ U ~ ~ ~~ ~ ------ ~ ';'~ ~ ~ f'l pj ~~ ~ ~ ~ f'l p~ a ~ p~ I!; J;~ ~ - ~ ;;-1--- - ; ; g I I I I ~ i - i ~ i I g :: < ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ g , n Z oS~ '" ~" i'i ~ ft~ ~ ~~ ~ ~'" <;l ~ z c " " F ~ oS ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~8 < ~ !! ~ , oS'" ~" 6- zB; "'c ~~ ~8 " ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ '" ~ ~ I :: !l I .J N - . - ~ : . N B . ; _....:.. . ~ I ~ .. .. _ 't;a !i~i ! s..: Itt J ! ~tr.... . J It} IIJr _ J"J! 1 J J J ; ; s ;: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I .. . ~~ " ~ - -- "",.,.,., Val ;: _ _ 0 ___ ..........._ b N N CI ;: ~ ;: . . . . . I~ e QQ - ~ig In!! ... II ~... !.~~ i ,Ill :: 'i. :r:r - ~ I; 5'!5T~~ pPp.. ;: i' ~~ . ~ ---, ~ ~~ - m ool."'.l l' ~'tl ;: ~ o~ ... z~ ll:l i!;; 'tl ~ ~ o Z ~ ~Il ;: :I L I'~ I ;: .l i -, I, I mi, l!I ~ i ~ d N VI -- ;r- !i I!l !i o z IE " o '" n lD > L I o ~ i ~ ~ 1: :~! r ~: -~ ' h,; ~ ; . ------1 1 . I ... ------ ~ . ------ I I i - ; I ~ ~ I I B i o I ~ ! ; - i l' II :: NII~--i ----- - t: '1;'1 !~r - lrr j i rlr.... . J:rrj !1 Jf tJ or ~ - ~ ~ ~ I ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~,D ;; CI ------ .. . . . . . - IS.. Q QQ 51 =-g=- =- i~: I:: ~ ; -:; ;; : 3'" .... :-~:r.:r:r - ~!~~~~ pPPpp ~ ~ ' t:lm ~ --. .. I ~o ~ ~g - 51 r.atoJ cr ~"d ~ ~ o~ .. I\) :z: ~ n~ "d t:: n ~ I!I 0 :z: ~ !I L o '" '" " o p'" o!1l .t;~ o ~~ (0 "I", 1il !!l ~ I ~ n o 0 n p 'i' ::i~r -r- ,U ~" P g ~~ ~ ~ ~- OJ ffi ~ p~ & ~ ~~ ~ ~ "z ~ ~ ::i~ J; ~ "i'i i i l' ~ ~p ~ I I I I 13'-~" .'-." 2'-OJ!." 3' ,6' 13'-~" I ~l----. , ~ J ' . :~-~i-',ILi'-l!!- ~11--!--@ : : ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~~ I ~U I ) ; ) _J ~ C) o~ r z:: ~z I ~~ I I ) !iI r ri2 "l r> I 8 I : :L;=--_L__~ J--A-) I l ) ~ I." QQOOQ~. I.- ~~--L~ ----. i(-:I------i--@ ~ I I I 1; I I "> I J ~ 1 ] I " 1 ] ] J IIj ] - - - -:- - - - -1- t--i-- i- - - - - - ---::=-2'-----G I I -.l.-.J<- ] ] 1 I ! i~~A r"~" ] ] J' _iL o pOJ ~:i! J;~ o ~~ ~~ m r m < )> --i o Z o m --i )> r I ""(J ;;:0 m o )> (f) --i )> --i "Tl o ;;:0 CD m (f) CD r < o .. .. '" i 0 ~ " 0\ "'~ ~ "'~ ",0 ':1 "," 6% I' ~ ~~ ~~ " ~~ ~~ > % "''' ~ I I Ii I" I :I II - , !I , , :I~IIII i " i , ! '\\ 111111111111111 ~ ,.. , '.J I I I 111I1 !!l . ~ II IIII ; . ! III' ; I! I, 11111111111111 II ,I. ,I- . ~ .11 :. ~: i :1 I il I ~ I ~ L- r> I :; ~ I, . I f N v' ;1' '" '" " " ~ n ;: ~ ~ ~ .. 'I! I I' ! / ': .,' r I I " 11'1 "III - ----::- J 0 " ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ " ~ > --- 7 1/ ---- / I --- I r --- , ~ I " I , ! - !i - '. . 'I I, I I I " , - I , - I ., I , .:1 -I r I II " -11111111'11111", ';'.{. ,1 H_ ~ ~ 8 ^ I I' v n " Z n ~ I % o o n :: N t: . ;; .. ~ 1!I !I ~ r o z It " ., ... ------ ~ o n . 'z 0 ;0 -I I m )> (J) .. I ~ -I ~ .hf. 0 z ~I'~ -I . . )> la, G) 1.;~ ~ m ~-"' ----- - .' . co i ! , ~ ~ ------ j ~ ------ ~ .IIIr-- - ; ; ; : ~III : o _ - 111 . - ~ z .1 :: ~ ~""Jj"j"-- Nlj!I_~ j ~ w ~t;fl:!f&J - 1~1;!i! ; '-;j :!:!ri s.., ".1 J -JJJ;;~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;; ~ .. I z o ;0 -I I ~ m (J) -I ;0 m z o m ;0 z G) .. ~ I . . . . - ~. Q QQ alenee ~ ~~ -iR. -.. :;; I!-I! ~ l~~ ~8: II .=.:r :r:r - ~S~~~~ ,. ftPPftft ;;; I' ~g ~ ~g - m ~l"'.l b fJ~ ;;; ~ ~ ~ "'ll C n ~ 15 0 Z ~----, ~ d T !I ~;; f .c. . .~ . t~;.::~,.j ~'1J~t~;:;~ ~.~~.. ' . "'tlW'""",-.;. ~;~~~~tl 'V g :: N w ; ;; .. :;; ;;; ;;; 15 !I L o ., .J z It " " o n . I ~ ~ - j~" rq.. ~~g~ ~;i;l . 81i~~ ~ -____J ~ 1- ;;; ri ~ ~OQ~~ i!~ ~lb<<tO~ _ ~~~gi!i:~~ ...... ~ ~ \l ~:5:il ~ :I uo:::O <it _..0-.,,0.1'0> ~~~ n\!<o<D<D C5 0 0 :r:;.n" 1ft 8 ~ . - ?'FJ'? _ . z _-- ~ ffl ::i 8 ~ ;-;- !', . !'!' !ii ' _ > ::tI1ll 0) i: ~tn ~ zo z 0 !? Me:: :>lw ZM t;'l'1:l WtrI ::tI ;;::: ::j > '1:1 '1:1 C n > ..., o z -Ill (]l o I o ;;; N .. ~ o ~ ~ L I o " ... " 10 ~ II 'm I'" ~ < m =2: 'Tl ;:0 o ~ en "U Z m .. ~ > :;! o ~ =' ---, ~ :!l ~ ~ I t ~ g. ~ z m :: ;:0 m z o m ;:0 z G) ---. , <5 ~ o ;; <: :; ;; ;;; :::; 0; ;;; ~ -.J I ~ ;;J ~ III III '0 ~:., i!;> ,"w . -. 8~ '" -< -----1: > ;;I <D ----- 00" ~ ~ r III III > ~ ~ ~ '" '" " - ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o 0 0 Z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ @ - 2 ~ ~ o z " ---- ~2~ iv N :... -- 0 r... t.o ~ ~ ~ ~ "'..l...::::..,,:::,,__ c: ~~~~i"~~~~~ ~~:![&.:~~a HHH~~!! ;: ~~o~liZ.~!"l~ !"l ~,~ !. ~ g:i-;!~ i.~~.~ -;[~! ' -< - ~ ~ ~ g 0 '" ~ " i III ~ jI '" '" '" ~ '" -< -< -< -< ~ ~ .. ~ 8 > ~ 0; \ , I I I '" . til ~~ 80: @O~<ilil ~roI =>>,~o:P:l ~~~ g~~== ~ ~ ~ ~ :;-:-tt ~ ~ ~ ~ g.g.;.;. o ~ ~ :..~~:...:... "" ~ ii:n~~ ~ !".!'*!t o '" ; i z o -tIl (]l o I o iO ~ ~ o '" ~ f: ':? L ~ 9.: ~ i " . ;0 " ~ ..i' 'en -., m '1J I o -., o en 0; I~ --!- III '" S III ~ o ~ '" " '" '0 ~ II D j o ~ z o '" S IIJ 'f <5 o '" , ~ ,'0 " .~ " '" -< o ,> ;;I -; > ''ll !Al --Ii c: ;: ~ o ~ OtIl OCJ1 zo -3 t'lC: ~g; '1:1'1:1 :I:t'l 0:;0 -3;;;::: 55:::J > '1:1 '1:1 r-- n > -3 5 z ~ ::; .\ \ 0; , ;;; ~ 0 '" ~ M z ~ ~ ~ ':? ~ ~ " t ~ 1 , ~ ~ I ~ ~ - ; 9- ~ 19~ J ~~g';! ~~~~ . 8sl:dl z p 2 III Ii ~ .. =' Ii .. -< c ~ ;;l ~ '" c ~ ;;l --- ~ _ _ _ -1- 'i" ~~~- - 51 51 51 - 2 2 2 !,j] !,j] !,j] ~ ~ ~ ;; El ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - Ii ~ ~ !i !i 2 III !i e 'ij =' !i ::: .. -< ~~~--- N 1 t: ~ c .) ~ N .. J.!~ ;;l - ~ o ~ 0: i~crl~ ;g;;:;- 2 i''il ~ ~. i>" _ !_;>i,::~5~ !! .9.,00 .o~!. ~i '''i~i' .._~.[ :;: ~1;;;!~ h~; P3000.. if . 1,,1" i~,.~ g~.-5" ';ill.g P ~ -jjj~~~ ~ ~ ~ OJ ~ ~ ... ''';1.-< " .. ~ .. ~ ;;; o ~ ;;l I I I I , ~ ~ fig,;),;) ';!" ~ .iDO ;I!'~ e ..~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~: ~ ~ ~ "~ II !-c:-:: ~ .~ g. nnn ': .... :r':r~ - ~ ~ ;'5";;':":" ,., !,P!'~~ _ ~ OOtc ~! ~g e nC _ tc 000 01 zt'l o o-l"O I t'lt'l _ ~ ~::tl C) en '1)[$ ::co-l ~i'O 0"0 OOt:: (') ~ o Z ~- ~ :!l ~ ~ If. I T ~ L o '00 --I m \J I o --I o 00 3: m -i )> r -0 )> 2 m r I 7')-0 ......7') OJm OJn 0)> 2Ul ;::E-i ......n 20 02 On ;::E7') ~ ~ ,I Ul m 7') S n m -< )> 7') o - ., -1 I ! . IJ nn 0)> 2 Ul ' n-i 7')...... m2 -i-o m~ n m .!1I'DIF1 ~~ I j I I I I I I J J ~ I J I /,j ~ / !- --'l I - ~ I-:l ~ 1/ ",I , i '" . ] 1 i""1I1 'I," I ~~ "'1,:,".'.iIJ'I'l"'~- )/:,,1'" 'il I hi,"" 1 "1'/"';"""" I,' ,:,' Id:i"l.l~:~:t ~,I,1l '11.11, I!lrul.l1~~.hitlh~~ i--' q I " ,t L ,.. , ~ ~ :~~~ ". '. ~,\~\ T'" 'I. 'I: 4] I ~II ".:' I ..J} III ~II TI ]I OJ ~p~ . c:!;:J ~~ I I I I I I " I~ I i ~ I ~ : II ~ I'~ 1 I;~ / ~ I I I - I - -_. ---I- - --. -,- ,...-- . ~ ~ ~ I ~ 1 i r ; ~ :' ~ ; I I I , , - J I- I I I - 1- - ~ '- ,I II- I ,I 1= I I ] :1 4! , II I .,-J I I '. , !'l p~ 0;'" '1il ~ i - ...... n c 7') ~ r 2 I I ;::E I.- )> r r ~ ~ I I I I I I T 1. I I I /) I ~ I d ,7 L I ~), I' I ./ ~ I 1-- ,1l fl -- r -- ~ -- I ,;-- ,-' " ~ I I I I I - I I I - I , - I I I I 'I-- I f=- I -- T ~-= I I (-- "I f== ~ ~: I 4 f== ~ f== t f== fT - ~ I -..- ----- --I I- . 1 .. ~":U.~. J~~?~ " "'l:i~' ~"*~ , - f ~ i , _i .... - : ----' - ---.: >-- ---' --I I "_l==1 . r=='j. _I --I [- i'\;;; \. ' , I .,1 ; ;' \ t ,.. ~, t '-:. , ~ ~I p~ ~. ~ - .. ~"l ..~ ~ ;; ::: ;:; 0: -==~ _: I g 'e- A - ~, I ~t - ~y I ! 1- lo.i( ~i~- 1- -- -~ _..,1 I i-! - ; --- ~: - -- ~1 - ::~; - - _ iJ n:~ M I " ~. rJ - 1'- - ,-r" ::== =-= tr=:==" ~ -+,-,--f --: ----' - " >-- - >-- - - , - = 11 p~ 7~ ~ I g p~ ..'" ~ p~ g~ ~ p~ ~~ ~ d 'l;'" ~ :J: :;: 7') o o "TI l/l n 7') m m 2 <> ;;; ::; ;;; c; '" o ~ o " II: " % D .., o () .. E ~ : 9- i~:! f · d i ~ I I I I ~ ----- - z'(j) ~I -I)> 00 ~o ~~ m (j) --i C o -< lD > DECEMBER JUNE MARCH . r o I ~ I 9- 1:JR! t ~:~~ l' · hill ~ II ----- - i ! ~ ~ "_____1 ~ II . ------ I I I i -; ;: - I I: o . z i ! ~ ~ =lj"j"-- Nllii_~ _____1 ~ ;: I.rft :.l""i - vu:r:lJ :1 :ri;;Jr : ,}rd!11' f t,,, ~ -iii;;~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c; . CI ------ c; ~ 1 I . I . z Z'$: Sm -lO OI ~)> f:Z m- o )> r en -., )> o ^ en o ;0 m m Z en -., c o -< II: ~ III :- ~ ~ 1;1 - !~ Q QQ our g::r :r:r 'I. .. - ::r ::r ::; ; -;.. ::... : -: :: :;.7. 7 ~ S ~""~~ p pp c; I' ~g; ~----, ~ ~@ - 8l ot-J 'T' ~oo ;; ~ ~~ r-; :o:~ 0000 Ot:: ~O lj ~~ ~ .0 ooz ~ I q. - -< ~ ~ - . !i ... L 0 Z II: ~~ ...~.~ % D o " . ~ I I ~ -- -- -- - - - --- - - - - I I - - -- - - - - -- ~- I - -- ...-/' ~ - L_ _ _ -- tJ- - - - I I I I I > I I I I I ~ I /~ 11 ! I -i ~ I , I I _J I I I --+-----~-f- .. I I I I I I I I .. I I I I ~ I I --n I I I I ,~ I _'i -L I I g I I I > ~ I mrrh' N m X I )> C en -., ----~-- en -., )> o ^ en o ;0 m m Z m Z r )> ;0 G) m o '1J r )> Z ----- !~ ;: m X I )> C en -., en -., _..J )> o ^ en o ;0 m m Z m Z r )> ;0 G) m o m r m < )> -., o Z en I l ~ I- +-~--- : --J J ...........-+ ~ - c; c; ~ . , ~ - + I ~ I -1 ::; -+t - ,. ;; - -,---.- ~ ~ - -, ~ I l~ - n I ;; lj !i % D " " . Planning Commission Staff Report DATE: April 19, 2007 TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Study Session: Proposed South San Francisco Conference Center Expansion, Applicant: South San Francisco Conference Center Authority Owner: City of South San Francisco Address: 255 South Airport Boulevard Case Numbers: UP07-0030, UPM07-0003, DR07-0019 (Original Use Permit Number: UP 91-888) RECOMMENDATION: Planning Staff recommends that the Planning Commission conduct a Study Session to review the proposed 4,200 square foot addition to the existing South San Francisco Conference Center facility. BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: The South San Francisco Conference Center Authority is proposing to expand the existing Conference Center facility, located at 255 Airport Boulevard, by constructing a 4,200 square foot, single-story prefabricated building in the parking lot behind the existing facility. The Conference Center presently consists of 16,500 square feet of ballroom and meeting space and a kitchen facility within a 39,460 square foot single story building. The addition would permit the Conference Center to operate over 20,000 square feet of meeting space, The new project would require that the Conference Center remove 15 parking spaces from the parking lot behind the facility, In 1991, the Planning Commission approved the original Use Permit to allow for the conversion of a former industrial building into the Conference Center, As part of that approval, the City required that the Conference Center Director and Board provide a parking management plan that would involve the neighboring hotels, The Conference Center Authority was created, by Ordinance, by the South San Francisco City Council in 1992 to manage and operate the Center, The City owns the Center and leases it to the Authority. The Center opened in April 1993, Since the Center opened, the number of hotel rooms in South San Francisco has increased from 2,000 rooms to 29 approximately 3,000 guest rooms. Since 2000, the quality of the hotel space STAFF REPORT TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Study Session: South San Francisco Conference Center Expansion DATE: April 19, 2007 Page 2 of3 has also improved, with the additions of the Courtyard and Residence Inn, Hilton Garden Inn, Larkspur Landing, Four Points, and improvements to the Holiday Inn, Likewise, the Conference Center has hosted more events and generated more Transient Occupancy Tax (TOT) for the City. As a result of the increased demand on the facility, the Conference Center Authority and the City Council has been studying how the City can increase the Center's meeting space and capture the business that cannot currently be accommodated, Consultants have recommended either an expansion of the existing facility or construction of a new facility, Building Design & Design Review Board Review The proposed addition consists of a single story, 4,200 square foot prefabricated building that would be located in the existing parking area behind the Conference Center. The building would be sited over the parking lot, with a continuous awning creating a pathway that connects the entry with the south elevation exits at the main building, The prefabricated building would have a "high-tech" appearance, The structure consists of a fabric material covering a metal truss roof to allow for natural lighting, The exterior walls consist of powder coated metal panels, which would be arranged in a way that would use ribbing to show articulation on the elevation and would match the color of the Conference Center building. The applicant also proposes to install landscaping on the sides of the structure and improve the landscaping in front of the Conference Center, The Design Review Board will review the proposed project on April 17, 2007, Staffwill summarize the DRB comments during the Planning Commission Study Session on April 19, 2007. Planning Commission Review The South San Francisco Conference Center Authority representatives and architect will introduce the proposed project, discuss the key issues such as the parking management plan, answer questions and respond to comments from the Planning Commission, STAFF REPORT TO: Planning Commission SUBJECT: Study Session: South San Francisco Conference Center Expansion DATE: April 19, 2007 Page 3 of3 RECOMMENDATION: Planning Staff recommends that the Planning Commission conduct a Study Session to review the proposed expansion of the South San Francisco Conference Center facility, Respectfully submitted, /'1 j ~.'... "// .< /~. ~ /J .,,/ ~// ~// Michael Lap Attachments: 1, Vicinity Map 2. Discussion Memorandum: South San Francisco Conference Center with attachments 3, Discussion Memorandum: Conference Center Parking Management 4. Site Plans and Elevations Attachment 1: Location SSF Conference Center 255 South Airport Boulevard UP07-0030, UPM07-0003 & DR07-0019 SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO CONFERENCE CENTER Discussion. Addition of 4,100 square feet of Meeting Space March 23, 2007 Conference Center Background During the 1980's, considerable hotel and meeting space development took place in San Mateo County, particularly in the area south of the San Francisco International Airport (SFO), in the Bay Area, and in other areas of the state and country. This development included hotel rooms, lobbies and other amenities as well as ballrooms and meeting room spaces, The addition of these spaces enabled the attraction of lucrative group meeting business. In the area north of SFO, the South San Francisco hotels, most having been developed prior to this time, found it difficult to compete for group meeting business because of their lack of meeting space. The South San Francisco hotel community wanted to be able to compete for group business while maintaining its existing business. In 1989, the hotel community proposed an idea to the City of South San Francisco to fund a conference center on the site of the former Berkey Photo Lab on South Airport Boulevard approximately one mile north of SFO, Since overnight stays in South San Francisco's hotel rooms generate Transient Occupancy Tax revenue which go directly to the City to fund community services such as libraries, street maintenance, parks and recreation, police and fire, the City Council was interested in their proposal. The hotel community's concept was for the hotels to bear the burden with a "tax ourselves" proposal so that no conference center expenses would be paid by the City's taxpayers, Measure C, as the proposal came to be known, stated that all associated conference center costs were to be paid with a new, ongoing, dedicated $2.50 per occupied hotel room tax and the revenue generated by the center's operation, That same year, Measure C was placed on the ballot; and it was approved by 79.4% of the South San Francisco voters, It had the overwhelming support of hotel operators, business and civic leaders, The Conference Center Authority was created, by ordinance, by the South San Francisco City Council in 1992 to manage and operate the Center. The City owns the Center and leases it to the Authority. The Center was developed, designed, constructed and equipped for $7.5 million. In April, 1993, the Center opened; and the South San Francisco hospitality community was able to compete with other conference sites for group meeting business. The Center hosts conventions, conferences, product launches, trade shovv's, seminars, receptions, and banquets for groups in a variety of markets, primarily corporate in nature. With 16,500 square feet of ballroom and meeting 255 South Airport Boulevard South San Francisco, California 94080 teI650.877,8787 fax 650.877,5356 www.ssfconf.com Discussion - Addition of 4,100 square feet of Meeting Space March 23, 2007 Page 2 space and a complete offering of event services including in-house catering, audio/visual, business and event coordination services, the Center delivers the most demanding requirements with the highest level of service. Currently, there are 29 hotels containing approximately 3,000 guest rooms located in South San Francisco. The South San Francisco Conference Center is approaching its fourteenth (14th) anniversary. Through the most recently concluded fiscal year, the Center has realized the following successes: The Conference Center has hosted 5,429 Events. Attendance at these events totals 1,334,423 which equates to 246 attendees per event. In addition to hosting local, regional, and state-wide events, the Conference Center also hosts national and international events, The Conference Center has been awarded the prestigious Pinnacle Award by the readers of Successful Meetings magazine for the fourth consecutive year. The Conference Center Enterprise Fund balance, which is separate and apart from the City's General Fund, totals $1.85 million. Event attendees staying in South San Francisco hotels have generated $1.7 million in Transient Occupancy Taxes which flow directly to the City's General Fund to support community services. Current Situation With the exception of the period of time immediately following the events of September 11, 2001, the Conference Center has enjoyed a steadily increasing level of business. In addition, the number of hotel rooms in South San Francisco has increased from 2,000, when the Center opened, to 3000; however, the Conference Center's available meeting space remains the same. As a result, it has become more difficult and, many times, impossible to accommodate all of the events clients wish to book. The Conference Center is many times sold out of space and/or not quite large enough to accommodate many events and, consequently, the business is lost to another venue outside of South San Francisco. Not only does the Conference Center lose the business. but so do the South San Francisco hotels. And when the business is lost, so is the opportunity to generate Transient Occupancy and other taxes for the City's General Fund. Discussion - Addition of 4,100 square feet of Meeting Space March 23, 2007 Page 3 Since early 1999, the Conference Center Authority together with the City Council have been studying how South San Francisco can increase its meeting space and capture the business that cannot currently be accommodated. Consultants have recommended either an expansion of the existing facility or construction of a new facility on another site. The unfortunate events of September 11, 2001, and the resulting impact on the hospitality industry caused some delay in the study process. With the improvement in the marketplace, the study process has resumed. The City recently conducted a land-use study of the Oyster Point Marina area; and one of the uses suggested was that of a convention center, hotels, and other public use areas. More specific study of this recommended usage is planned by the Conference Center Authority, Today's Opportunity While study continues, the Conference Center and South San Francisco continues to miss business opportunities. In order to assist in meeting the current demand . for meeting space, the Conference Center Authority has identified a way to expand the existing Center by 4,100 square feet. By purchasing a manufactured, hard- wall, membrane roof structure and installing it behind the Conference Center, this additional square footage can be added to the Center's inventory and operations in a few months' time. A structure has been selected, and marketing literature describing it is attached. Aesthetically pleasing, the structure will be located on the southeast side of the Conference Center, It will adjoin the Center via a covered walkway from the south prefunction corridor, The structure interior will be finished similarly to the Center's meeting spaces. All servicing will be from the east side of the Conference Center via a corridor between the existing building and the new structure. All City processes are being followed to insure life safety, the meeting of code requirements, and appropriate blending with the existing building, grounds, and operations. The Conference Center Authority can cover all costs associated with the new structure from the Conference Center enterprise fund balance. By adding this square footage, the Conference Center will then be able to market over 20,000 square feet of meeting space. With the typical convention event requiring general session, breakout meeting, meal function, and exhibit space, this additional square footage will provide a third meeting space to better help the Conference Center accommodate this and all types of events. The current meeting space configuration is 13,500 square feet, which divides into ten different spaces, and 3,000 square feet, which divides into two spaces. The Conference Discussion - Addition of 4,100 square feet of Meeting Space March 23, 2007 Page 4 Center Authority is enthusiastic about this opportunity to expand the Center relatively quickly, within its budget, and in a manner which will complement the existing building. This will enable the Conference Center to provide a greater impact to the meetings and events market, the South San Francisco hotel community, and the City of South San Francisco's general fund. Respectfully submitted, Sandra M. O'Toole, Executive Director Attachments LOSBERGER ,/.-=>' 2 3 Photo courtesy of useful Structures UK RevolutionT" buildings are designed to provide you with environments that meet your needs in every respect. Site surveys, technical advice, engineering calculations, design, 3D modeling and installation are all part of our comprehensive project management service, taking care of every part of your project from concept to completion. 4 At Losberger U.s, we're experts at creating solutions to your requirements, Using 16ft x 16ft building modules, you are free to build almost any width, height, length or shape structure you need, then add to it in the future, quickly and cost effectively. The modular three dimensional aluminum superstructure gives you flexibility to increase length and width by 16ft increments or wall height from 10ft to 25ft. Make clever use of your floor space with scope for eaves heights of up to 25ft and clear span of up to 135ft, 5 6 Photo courtesy of Useful Structures UK ~~.- Losberger U.s, is creating a RevolutionT" in the temporary buildings industry with the introduction of its new line of relocatable Revolution structures. Contact us today to find out how you can benefit by using the Revolution building system at 800,964.8368, info@losbergerus,com or www.losbergerus.com. 7 LO ER Losberger U.S" LLC P,O. Box 74 Frederick, MD 21705 Phone: 800,964.8368 or 301.682,8000 Fax: 301.682,8005 E-mail: [email protected] Web site: www.losbergerus.com C 2006 Losberger U,S" LLC. Frederick, MD 21705 Revolution is a trademark of Losberger U,S" LLC Printed in U,S,A, SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO CONFERENCE CENTER Discussion - Parking April 6, 2007 The site upon which the Conference Center was developed had former lives as a photo processing laboratory and a warehouse facility - the building had been vacated and was an eyesore. The parking demand for the former uses was primarily by employees. In 1989, when the hotels proposed to the City the redevelopment of the site into a conference center, the parking limitation imposed by the site was a challenge that was eventually overcome. The conference center site could accommodate approximately 87 vehicles; and with a much higher parking demand anticipated, the Planning Commission would not approve the conference center redevelopment until the parking issue was resolved. The Center's hotel neighbors (Holiday Inn and Good Nite Inn - the names have changed from the beginning) agreed to include their hotels together with the Conference Center into a "functional package" for purposes of parking. Parking demand and requirements for all three facilities and their uses were studied as if there was one facility with 693 parking spaces, 544 guest rooms with 45%-55% of guests shuttling from the airport, 29,415 square feet of meeting space, two restaurants, two lounges, and employees. In addition, the Conference Center Board agreed to limit the number of Conference Center event attendees to 1,200 at anyone time even though the Conference Center physically can accommodate more attendees. The study determined that the majority of the two hotels' and the Conference Center's parking requirements could be accommodated with the "functional package" parking; however, there would be some days when the parking demand would exceed the "functional package" on-site parking. In an effort to facilitate the Planning Commission approval process, the Holiday Inn and Good Nite Inn made the long-term commitment to provide an off-site parking lot to cover those occasions when the parking demand from the two hotels' and the Conference Center exceeded what could be accommodated by the "functional package" on-site parking. The hotel operators secured a commitment from Travelodge to allow their lease of PG&E property, located under the power lines between their hotel property and the Best Western Grosvenor, to be used as the off-site parking lot. At the time, this area was an old, unimproved, partially-paved surface; a good deal of the area was still dirt. The hotel operators made a commitment to completely improve the area to a parking lot of approximately 277 spaces and provide for its ongoing operating costs. This commitment made by the operators of the Holiday Inn and Good Nite Inn greatly assisted the Planning Commission's decision in July, 1991, to grant a use permit for the Conference Center, with shared "functional package" on-site parking between the Holiday Inn, Good Nite Inn, and the Conference Center with the ability to use the off-site parking lot when higher demand days made it necessary. Both the Planning Commission and the City Council, who ultimately made the final decision on the Conference Center Use Permit in August, 1991, based a good deal of their decision on the long-term, parking commitments made by the Holiday Inn and the Good Nite Inn. The Planning Commission and the City Council required that there be a very thorough, enforceable agreement (which remained the commitment of the owners, regardless of a sale of the property), between the City, Holiday Inn, Good Nite Inn, and the Travelodge 255 South Airport Boulevard South San Francisco, California 94080 te/650,877.8787 fax 650.877.5356 www.ssfconf.com Discussion - Parking April 6, 2007 Page 2 to insure that the parking demand for the "functional package" could always be met. In addition, long-term parking was not one of the permitted uses in either the Conference Center's, Holiday Inn's, Good Nite Inn's, or Travelodge's Use Permits. With the parking issues resolved to the Planning Commission's and the City Council's satisfaction, with the construction bid being a reasonable price to renovate the Conference Center, and with the revenue stream ($2.50 per occupied room night transient occupancy tax and operating revenue) being sufficient to pay for the construction debt service, property lease, and the operating deficit, the City Council approved the construction contract and the issuance of approximately $6 million in bonds to pay for the construction costs allowing the Conference Center project to move forward. Ultimately, in early 1993 just prior to the Conference Center opening, the signing of the final agreements allowed the Conference Center's certificate of occupancy to be issued and construction to begin on the off-site lot. The final agreements provided for the Holiday Inn and the Good Nite Inn to pay $160,000, the Best Western Grosvenor Hotel to pay $40,000, and the Conference Center to pay $100,000 (the Authority borrowed these funds from the City and have since repaid the loan) towards the construction of the off-site lot. Regarding the day-to-day operating costs, the agreements also provided for the Holiday Inn to pay 50% and the Good Nite Inn and the Grosvenor Hotel to pay for the balance on a 60%/40% basis. It was anticipated that at some point in the future, it may be possible to charge for parking in the off-site lot. The final agreements provided that at such time as there was paid parking, the Conference Center would be repaid for their investment first from the proceeds with all the parties sharing the proceeds following the Conference Center's repayment. Per the final agreements, on site, the Holiday Inn, Good Nite Inn, and the Conference Center are able to share each others parking based on the "functional package" uses. Off-site, on event days or days when the parking demand necessitated use of the off-site lot, the Holiday Inn, Good Nite Inn, and the Conference Center have use of the entire lot; on non-event days, the Travelodge has use of 1/3 of the spaces, the Holiday Inn has use of 1/3 of the spaces, and the Good Nite Inn and the Grosvenor Hotel have use of the balance of the spaces on a 60%/40% basis. On days when the use of the off-site lot is required, the Conference Center coordinates the requirements with the Holiday Inn and Good Nite Inn and gives Travelodge 30 days notice of the requirements. Travelodge has the management responsibility for the off-site lot and is to make it available when notified of the Holiday Inn's, Good Nite Inn's, and Conference Center's off-site parking requirements. Our parking operations have followed this procedure since the Conference Center opened in April, 1993. The great majority of the attendee parking has been accommodated by the "functional package" on-site parking spaces; although on some days, attendees have parked in the back corners of the Holiday Inn's and Good Nite Inn's parking lots. Staff is exploring a shuttle system to transport attendees to the Conference Center during these Discussion - Parking April 6, 2007 Page 3 occasions - especially during night time hours or during inclement weather. Use of the off-site lot has been on an extremely limited basis. The addition of the new structure and its 4,100 square feet of meeting space is not anticipated to have an adverse affect on the Conference Center's parking operation. The expansion will enable our marketing to and hosting similar size groups (250 - 650 attendees) with a demand for more space that can currently be offered and a need for hotel guest rooms. This will enable the booking of business which now has to be turned away due to lack of space. Conference Center event attendees will continue to be limited to 1,200. The purpose of the Conference Center remains the same, but our ability to fulfill the purpose will be enhanced by the addition of this new meeting space. Purpose: The South San Francisco Conference Center was developed to positively impact the economy of the City of South San Francisco through the generation of various tax revenues. Operating as a public assembly facility, the Center hosts conventions, conferences, seminars, etc. Attendees of these events, by staying in hotels, dining in restaurants, and making meeting-related expenditures, spend money and generate the tax revenue, primarily Transient Occupancy Tax, which goes directly to the City's General Fund to pay for City services. andra M, O'Toole Executive Director Attachments: All Parking Agreements v ~; ~ I, (/ ~,: :s::~ ~ V 'Ty- 1 \ E--~ ...--- - ---':\- /-- ~- .--- ~~~~ ~ ~~::!;Jl )> ,,-ifil> ::E ::!':~;z: Z ~'!JG () S-~ z ~~~ ~ x;z: X ii !ij~ ~~ ~~ r= <J ~ ~ l> ;z: =r-ttt t~~= ..J I L___ _ , Vl - ::-1 qm II""'C - r b )> ., Z ~~;; ijr ~~~ ~~~ ~~i1 r~ ~n ~~~ )~~ ~~~ !Ii ~",' ~ {~~) ~ \,n,," SOUTH AIRPORT BLVD. i! ~ m ~ til m i! i! ~ til B B Q ~ " ~ m ('-- =~~ (--- I ^-1---- I I ~ \~~ '\S:' / --== =~ r ~ - ----=~ L_-J ~~ i---- (/ ~~ ~-~~-~~~-----~--~~~~-_.. f-~>~-::~>~~~~ - _ -_ -:~~ I~ ~ ------ -------- - I ~-___L...._ __ _ _ J__ - - - - - - -l '----- ,[~\- ( .--- I-- , I I I- I I I ( \ :: ,- II I: I I __,- ~ (/ : Y./ :1 ~ I :i~ ~ ~ Y ./ n~: ~ i ~ m. t~-. Yv/ ./ rn-iI<' L" : ,.. I I R ~ '-'-~ y< Ik~ ( / c i : ~, ( ./1 ~ ~'1' ....~\/j Ctf ~~d i U:, ~ il ~~ : " --- ---- ~ JC. ~~, , iI< pQ'-o.."j ~ I ~ ~ I ~ '" i i ~ 1 v- " I - - --;---- '~ r- I I T '~~1 :..:--I~ c. -.I.I~I_ccl ~..r--o- i I~ ~i 'I I I 01 ~ u I '-- ~ or--, .. ~ i ~~ ,it- J n :3 III ~~ ~ ~~ -! Cl~ Ii! /-" ... , ,~~".~I ~~I ~~~I~~"::~_c:2JJ l'! b ~ i3 ~ ~ ~ '" )> c: '" ~ S ,. ~ I '" <:: '" ~ e- m X ~ ....... '" II. '" ~ I P So N ....... @ SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO CONFERENCE CENTER 255 SOUTH AIRPORT BLVD, ~~~ ~~~ ~~.&~ " , ~:::~~ :j~:1 g~ ~~ ~ )>~'- K Q~~ -I -1m t1:E -I VI VI SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO, CA m >< V') --I Z C) OJ C ::; r- ~ 0 z ,. C) ~ "'T1 r- o o ~ \J s; Z 4 \~;J" \J ~ m "'T1 )> OJ ~ n ~ m 0 -- OJ ~ C - r- , 0 ~ z C) "'T1 r- 0 0 ;:0 \J s; Z ~ f~~~) ~ - -'/ '-.--" ~ '" c ):> '" '" ~ ..:::: ~ :l I s::: ", n ~ c I ~ rv ^' "" .. ~ -. !=' q N ---' 0 8 r:-o- ~-' - - . ('",; : .'~ -....- '.....'~~. ~ , ',~ '~"'~'_.""~ - ""'.~~ ',- "".,,'~---.~-~-~. . I ~. ...'." . ~ " ') .~ >' ._'~-;-':----:---'-.".:- {j.'~"-~" '. ~ <J"" -----1J ',' Ii . i>" <1. _-_. '.,' .Jt ".. ~ ,. ',,:' ~~""... : ~2 .". --__0 d' h 1'\- 'J ~ rr= -ri~ ~ .'0--- , ..., I ~ ~ z. '-~; r , '" ., -< 0......'" ,[ '[":'" L:.J::. ~ .,. ~ 2: ~ ! ~ ~ \: ~ ~ .~ .... ;S: ,l r='" r;::!- '1< 1E ~ ~ ... X ~ !l. ~ 1'. ~, r I ~ 'I" \( II r =-==> ~ -.. ~ o k r~lb ;:- - ~ ! W.,J'ciu I ~ I r- .- - - - ~'- - -r I I I I I I I 1 I ___ - J ----"/f'F \ ..". ~ ,. "I ~ ~ \ I I ./:-- - ~- m " "'0 -lz o~ ~ ~ril ~!lJ ~~~ i ~u elm ~~~ ~ ~ ~ mZ -.t---- "," ">R om ~-ii! on ~+ h;L ~ ~~. ~!2l Uti! ~ ~ ~~~ ;;1 '" 11'-0" fi-b 1/2" 11'-0' ~ 1I'i"-""" I"~___ ~ ~ _.Jl!I~-"_~. ' ~7 ~ J. CL-:-=r_ \~~)\-:~1}l<~--~>^", )"'" /' 'i-~~' ~:..../ ..../ ..../ ..../ ..../ ~7< I X X X X X ~ t.l 6 ~I /.... /.... /.... /.... /.... - ~ -~I I ~~.:,/,/// .................".//// ................ ////........ / ................ //// ................: ~~ I 1.~j' -:........ / I........ /Yc::.~-~ / I........ /~ - /}: 1 i~ . " 1;1l.... / .... // ........~ // ........ // ~ ........ // ~ t ........ // ........ / ~ / .... / ill .... / ~ ,.,,-----. '" X /x.... P ~x.... /x.... j /x.... "! ill L // ........ .... ~n.... /.... ~ /.... -0" ~1;1l/.... .... /.~.... / .... / .... ~----==.~. /....1 ~ ....1/ ....,/ .... ~ ~ t.l . ~l :....-/> -----.~ ~ /><: -- ~f~: /r-~'r ~ . I ............ /// .... /// .... /// ............ /// ............ /111' i ~ ~ /x.... /x.... /x.... /x, /x, ~llg " /, / ~ / ~ / ~ / , / , / , / , / ,/ ,/ ,/ .... / , / , / , / , ~ ~ __L ~-.~ Uit I ~ ~' eo',1' ~ '" ~ Z ~~~ )> s::- K t.:::~~ :::tl)>O 66.8.... n~I " , I Z m::~g :j~:~ -:J: -1m ,< ~I t)~ ~~ -IVl Vl SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO CONFERENCE CENTER 255 SOUTH AIRPORT BLVD, SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO, CA i: 'do ~ 4(Y>~ l! '~'~f' ;~ ~ 4 IJo . tIi; ~ , : r j""~'- · 6'..4f' ---t-- t Ii ~' '~l fH ~ ~ ~ ~H I ' . ~ -! '( f--- !4~~~_ 1 -~'~- --~ ~~<--f ~IXLJD~~ _ Co ._ ."-~::.,.:1~ n~ a ;'1 l\ II H n ~i~ "I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ II ~ II Ii l! ~ ~ ~t ~ I 1= ~ I ~i i Ii I l! , - : I' h 0;'-1' '.'... I~ j: IF .. ~--' ~.. il i !.~~-. '.'p.);~- .)- , ~ Vi /~--:-')--\-~ ~ i! ~ u::rT::Ll-'-~'r-_ '-.'" E . ~-~--t~~~--~." J )>~ I ~ "'... ~S g~ )>3:'- rI '" ~> SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO ,. ::0)>0 3:Z ~~ > :, ,. :l~ ~~_8 n::j:J: co ::15 CONFERENCE CENTER I 0 n :J: Z ~ ;;:: ::r: ~~ 0,", , , c: Z o;~~ UJ co " '" '" 255 SOUTH AIRPORT BLVD. :j8~ -:r: >:, -C 0 --1m I '" Ph~ ...... 0, 0 '3 SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO, CA 8g -IVl Vl \ \~ ~ -0 rn ~ :2 rn V\ r:. ~ n "I \ l l ~ il \ i ~!' ,i \; ~ H 1\ \ \ \ \ \ : ~\ ;~ 1,..\\1' ~- 1\1 I'r, ! p .~ Ii ," '.1 ;: "v\ 'j ./' j ",i ~ _".1 (/-' ~ ~ \ ~ ~ ~~ "0 g~~ )>~ )>'1 "" ~'Z. ~ SOUTH SAN fRANC\SCO tt~~~ ~~:I: "" 3~ \ "\ ;0 f5 CONfERENCE CENTER 0 n 000-' :I: Z I ~C\ 1\- '1 ~ g; ? "" <: a;:::~~ '" '" 255 SOUTH AIRPORT BLVD, ::1~~1 =t:I: ,.. 9 '" '" S ~~ rn~ ..... 0 J~ 0 ~V' ~ -J ~ ~~ ~ ~ SOUTH SI'N FAANClSCO, CA g V'